LOST: Dead Thread

[Bell]

I think the following outcomes would have been better for town.

1. You did gambit and hit scum then were night killed.
2. You did not gambit. 28.57% chance of hitting scum.
3. You did gambit miseliminated and were night killed.
4. You did gambit, miseliminated and avoided your own miselimination.

I think all of these outcomes were objectively better.

[Bell]

I don’t regret what I did.

That's fine. I just disagree and my request stands.

1a* you did gambit, hit scum and then survived the night.

[ProfessorDrapion]

I mean if not for my gambit I may have not realized that butterflies and Taly were wolves.

[MathBlade]

If I didn’t do the gambit I would have been a night kill I am forcing Butterflies and Taly to have to kill someone outside of the known confirm so probably BestBird.

You’re better off being a nightkill there.

Why would scum have to kill outside “the town firm” which doesn’t even exist?

You’re assuming you’re right (which I won’t acknowledge) then assuming scum have to do something based on you being right, which doesn’t follow.

[Enchant]

I don’t regret what I did.
Town would have been ML’ed either way if you put it on in simulation.

This way I removed a night kill they needed and forced it into an ML which unknowingly is actually bad for wolves.

Wow, you steal mafia kills.

Awesome

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

freeeeeeee freeeeeeee freeeee I'm finally freeeeeeee

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Spoiler: my lol guess for last scum

JohnnyFarrar/Noraa/OTH POE leaning towards JF/OTH

[Cat Scratch Fever]

congrats pooky

based on that kill, I'm guessing scum will try to mislim Butterflies?

[Rad]

Scum showing mercy to pooky here

[ProfessorDrapion]

Ok so that’s interesting.
I think butterflies killed Pooky because they knew the gambit I did they had to confirm someone so they did it before killing Roden.
Good move on butterflies part.
Now no one can sus why they are still alive and why they weren’t killed when they made sure to kill Pooky.

[ProfessorDrapion]

congrats pooky

based on that kill, I'm guessing scum will try to mislim Butterflies?

Scum is Butterflies.

(And Taly)

[ProfessorDrapion]

Butterflies also didn’t want to be town reading everyone except one come F5 so they got rid of Pooky.
Makes allot of sense.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

it makes absolutely no sense for nancy to kill me lol what

[ProfessorDrapion]

it makes absolutely no sense for nancy to kill me lol what

I already said my thoughts last day.

F5 with You/Them/Taly/Hook/ML Bait

They have no one to call the team.
They are pocketing Hook and town read you.
They need another player to call a wolf.

[ProfessorDrapion]

Should say I shared my thoughts here in this thread.

[RH9]

Spoiler: my lol guess for last scum

JohnnyFarrar/Noraa/OTH POE leaning towards JF/OTH

I agree with this PoE.
This will be pretty much what I'm at as well.
I still don't think that butterflies is confscum though I get why Drapion is certain on butterflies being scum.

[Rad]

it makes absolutely no sense for nancy to kill me lol what

I already said my thoughts last day.

F5 with You/Them/Taly/Hook/ML Bait

They have no one to call the team.
They are pocketing Hook and town read you.
They need another player to call a wolf.

This still doesn't explain why pooky before roden. No one can switch here to scum!Roden. Everyone could switch to scum!Pooky. Might make sense to kill pooky next but not here. So there's some other reason to kill pooky over roden here. IMO it's just wifom chaos kill.

[RH9]

Butterflies also didn’t want to be town reading everyone except one come F5 so they got rid of Pooky.
Makes allot of sense.

This doesn't make sense for Noraa to just randomly agree, though.
Why does ze agree to NK Pooky just so that butterflies has one less TR?

[ProfessorDrapion]

Spoiler: my lol guess for last scum

JohnnyFarrar/Noraa/OTH POE leaning towards JF/OTH

I agree with this PoE.
This will be pretty much what I'm at as well.
I still don't think that butterflies is confscum though I get why Drapion is certain on butterflies being scum.

Johnny is Town and same with Hook

[RH9]

Is this independent of the alignment of butterflies?

[ProfessorDrapion]

I think butterflies also made the kill to frame Johnny.

It’s funny cause I tell everyone who town is and no one trusts me.

[ProfessorDrapion]

Lol Johnny town slipped.
Said Roden could be a wolf, mafia knows they can’t cause they are a mason.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

It’s funny cause I tell everyone who town is and no one trusts me.

might have something to do with that fake track lol

[MathBlade]

Or just the sheer arrogance.

Even if you didn’t have a fake track “but I am right” doesn’t convince anyone

[Ircher]

Or just the sheer arrogance.

Even if you didn’t have a fake track “but I am right” doesn’t convince anyone

+1