Warrior Cats Mafia [Day Three]

[catboi]

He posted at 6:27 in pt
I posted at 7:56 in main thread
This is my local time obv.

After thinking about it i have to admit my joke would mainly be funny among teens, sorry about that.

thank you but please don't reference timestamps

[catboi]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Ceph

[Charloux]

Btw is it posted somewhere that scum have daychat i didn't find it in the ruleset. I could totally see them being distributed among the clans and not being able to communicate.

[Ydrasse]

Do not quote, make reference to, or otherwise attempt to convey information such as timestamps from private topics. This will be the only warning given.

[Something_Smart]

this is what i mean by over-explainy - she presented a reasonable explanation, dismissed it as "doesn't make sense" (even though it does), and then proceeded to try to justify her vote and appear like she's Really Thinking About The Game

I think that's the right amount of explanation, though. You see something that doesn't make sense as town, then you provide a reason why it makes sense as scum. If I saw someone pushing a vote because it "didn't make sense" I would consider that under-explained.

Having an issue with her specific logic-- that's more reasonable, iirc FA is the type to deliberately push phony reasoning like that but of course my meta is stale. But I do kind of agree that the joke doesn't make sense (I don't really see what's funny about pretending that something obviously false is true), and I did have the scum PT thought as well, though I arrived to the conclusion that it was unlikely nobody else posted in the scum PT.

[PenguinPower]

Btw is it posted somewhere that scum have daychat i didn't find it in the ruleset. I could totally see them being distributed among the clans and not being able to communicate.

Any and all Private Topics will be open at all times, unless otherwise stated.

[Cephrir]

i am townreading frozen angel for calling a case against herself solid in the process of questioning someone else

re: charloux: the case where i might find this compelling is one where the scum chat was not open until game start (possible because the neighbor PTs weren't) but there is no way to know this probably

[Datisi]

Having an issue with her specific logic-- that's more reasonable, iirc FA is the type to deliberately push phony reasoning like that but of course my meta is stale. But I do kind of agree that the joke doesn't make sense (I don't really see what's funny about pretending that something obviously false is true), and I did have the scum PT thought as well, though I arrived to the conclusion that it was unlikely nobody else posted in the scum PT.

my first thought was also "oh shit scum pt slip???" but yes, right after i realized the only way that works is if scum is literally not posting in the scum pt, AND scum was actually careless about referencing a pt knowing that if they reference wrong, they're caught (which is not something i'd expect from a 2016-er)

[Datisi]

the joke made sense to me because it seems like something i would do, or something i would think of doing at least

[Cephrir]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Ceph

this vote will not help you divine my alignment because either way i know you are just doing it to see if i will overreact

you'll need a few more votes to see if i claim scum or not

[Bell]

VOTE: datisi?

[catboi]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Ceph

this vote will not help you divine my alignment because either way i know you are just doing it to see if i will overreact

you'll need a few more votes to see if i claim scum or not

Interesting you assume that's why I voted you.

[Frozen Angel]

well theoretically if this was a true slip, he only needed to mistake the scum pt with neighborhood pt when he posted - which could be earlier than when he made the post in the thread (or anytime toward the start of the phase). then later he would be like "I don't see the thread popping up with an unread notification so I'm the only one posting" so he made the comment

FA is the type to deliberately push phony reasoning like that but of course, my meta is stale

I see you remember my reaction testing and behavioral pattern analysis style

i am townreading frozen angel for calling a case against herself solid in the process of questioning someone else

re: charloux: the case where i might find this compelling is one where the scum chat was not open until game start (possible because the neighbor PTs weren't) but there is no way to know this probably

well, that was just my assumption cause that was how all neighborhood chats were, and no access to even see those threads were given till the game started.

Personally not a fan of 127 either. feels faked and forced to assume scum has no day chat directly after being accused of slipping by mistaking private threads.

[Charloux]

re: charloux: the case where i might find this compelling is one where the scum chat was not open until game start (possible because the neighbor PTs weren't) but there is no way to know this probably

I was actually thinking among the lines they know scum have pt, but town had no way of knowing that. Didn't read the rules correctly tho

[Bell]

I feel like datisi is scum this game.

[Datisi]

wrong

[Cephrir]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Ceph

this vote will not help you divine my alignment because either way i know you are just doing it to see if i will overreact

you'll need a few more votes to see if i claim scum or not

Interesting you assume that's why I voted you.

Lucky guess

[Bell]

What if I’m scum? Then technically, I’m right.

[Datisi]

i don't get it

[Bell]

If i’m scum then calling you scum when you’re town would be the right thing to do.
Therefore I’m right if I’m scum.
But you said I was wrong which means that you know I’m town and you know that I’m wrong which only SCUM WOULD KNOW
Therefore I’m right.

I’m always right is what I’m getting at.

[Datisi]

i'm gonna kashoot myself

[Dannflor]

datisi destroyed with FACTS and LOGIC

[NorwegianboyEE]

(っ◔◡◔)っ ♥ Hey Datisi! ♥

[NorwegianboyEE]

So guys, i'm trying to change my font and playstyle for this game. Tell me if you like it. <3

[Marashu]

It was mainly snark and confusion on my end; I did think that it might be a PT slip but figured that scum would be more careful. I hadn't considered whether or not the scum PT would be open during pre-game. I was too busy trying to figure out if I was misreading the title of the Clan PT.

@Mods:

does the 200 post limit apply to all game threads (like the neighbourhoods) or just the public thread?