In post 366, Dannflor wrote:is putting all solving in hood more likely to come from town or scum
open question i honestly dont know
I GUESS WE CAN'T SAY. I THINK I ASSUMED 1-1-1-1 BECAUSE OF REPRESENTATION HEURISTIC/DISTRIBUTION BIAS, SO ON THOSE GROUNDS I WOULD ARGUE THAT IT'S AN IDEA MORE LIKELY TO COME FROM TOWN, BECAUSE IT'S A MISTAKE THAT'S LIKELY TO OCCUR ORGANICALLY. HOWEVER, I WOULDN'T PUT A LOT OF STAKE INTO THAT WITHOUT THE CONTEXT OF WHAT ELSE IS GOING ON IN THE ISO OF THE PLAYER WHO SAID IT.
In post 722, catboi wrote:Why did you choose the most NAI post imaginable from mastina to quote with a vote?
BECAUSE I INFERRED IT MEANS MASTINA IS AFRAID OF HOW SHE WILL BE JUDGED IN THE THREAD, SO SHE'S PROMISING MORE ACTIVITY LATER. I GUESS IT COULD BE NAI BUT IT SEEMS LIKE A SOLID LEAD CONSIDERING IT'S STILL RELATIVELY EARLY ON D1. DO YOU TRUST MASTINA?
In post 605, Mistyx wrote:i avoid reading into emotional posts on personal policy so i don't think you're going to move me with that
i've been trying to get norwee to engage with me on multiple occasions and he's ignored me so i doubt i'm moving my vote until he acknowledges my questions towards him
Your questions aren’t going to solve me or change your mind. So why should i bother answering them.
In post 722, catboi wrote:Why did you choose the most NAI post imaginable from mastina to quote with a vote?
BECAUSE I INFERRED IT MEANS MASTINA IS AFRAID OF HOW SHE WILL BE JUDGED IN THE THREAD, SO SHE'S PROMISING MORE ACTIVITY LATER. I GUESS IT COULD BE NAI BUT IT SEEMS LIKE A SOLID LEAD CONSIDERING IT'S STILL RELATIVELY EARLY ON D1. DO YOU TRUST MASTINA?
Okay you're an alt so I don't know if you've played with mastina but she literally always ends up behind in games and writing massive catchups that take her a ton of time so it is usually a while before she gets current with the thread. Saying that stuff about promising content later is a nulltell for her. My read rate on mastina is not very good but I think she's been fairly towny so far.
In post 722, catboi wrote:Why did you choose the most NAI post imaginable from mastina to quote with a vote?
BECAUSE I INFERRED IT MEANS MASTINA IS AFRAID OF HOW SHE WILL BE JUDGED IN THE THREAD, SO SHE'S PROMISING MORE ACTIVITY LATER. I GUESS IT COULD BE NAI BUT IT SEEMS LIKE A SOLID LEAD CONSIDERING IT'S STILL RELATIVELY EARLY ON D1. DO YOU TRUST MASTINA?
Okay you're an alt so I don't know if you've played with mastina but she literally always ends up behind in games and writing massive catchups that take her a ton of time so it is usually a while before she gets current with the thread. Saying that stuff about promising content later is a nulltell for her. My read rate on mastina is not very good but I think she's been fairly towny so far.
I'm here and paying attention, just trying to formulate an opinion based on the posts made.
While waiting for more from certain low post players.
Consider my Datisi read slightly blunted.
I can't really read Alisae.
I can't read Titus. They've kind of been like this since the last 3-5 games I've played with them. Where the activity and content is so erratic and sort of unrelated to anything that I can't make sense of what their actual trajectory is.
I'm still sitting on Norwe, because I don't think that me feeling bad if they get eliminated early if they're town is an actual reason not to kill them. It's frustrating tho.
you seem to be either intentionally limiting the thoughts you share or just not really having them in a way that seems more like scum you
your posts feel like they're being made out of obligation rather than natural thought. 640 especially feels way more like turing test bell than town bell
im not like too pressed about sorting you immediately tho so
I don’t understand Alisse well, but currently. I’m neutral to lean town on them, I think.
Their engagement style conflicts with what I think scum would do. But I can’t quite articulate why.
I really don’t agree with person rewrites posts a few times and decides to be concise and is therefore scum.
I would have accepted Bell wasn’t posting with an internal timer which led to the change. But the reasoning just doesn’t reach the truth in this case.
In post 734, Bell wrote:I really don’t agree with person rewrites posts a few times and decides to be concise and is therefore scum.
I would have accepted Bell wasn’t posting with an internal timer which led to the change. But the reasoning just doesn’t reach the truth in this case.
I just iso’d all of Marashu’s posts and they look fine except for one aspect that is off but it has been a year since they played. They used to be more in-depth with their analysis, where here they refer to thinking rather than actually thinking out loud. But it’s early.
In post 738, Bell wrote:I just iso’d all of Marashu’s posts and they look fine except for one aspect that is off but it has been a year since they played. They used to be more in-depth with their analysis, where here they refer to thinking rather than actually thinking out loud. But it’s early.
THAT'S TWO BAD SIGNS IN ONE BECAUSE IF THEY JUST TOOK A YEAR OFF THAT MEANS THEY'RE MORE LIKELY TO GET SCUM FROZEN BECAUSE THEY HAVEN'T ROLLED SCUM IN A YEAR, AND YOU'RE ALSO SUGGESTING THEY'RE MORE LIKELY TO HAVE A POLARIZED GAME AS SCUM FOR THE SAME REASON. MY INTERACTIONS WITH MARASHU INDICATE THEIR PLAYSTYLE IS QUITE A BIT DIFFERENT THIS GAME FROM WHAT YOU REMEMBER THEM BEING LIKE AS TOWN.
FMPOV AS SOMEONE WHO HASN'T PLAYED WITH MARASHU BEFORE, THEY DO OBJECTIVELY SEEM A TAD LIKE A DARK ONE AND NOT SIMILAR TO THE PLAYER YOU'RE DESCRIBING AT ALL.
In post 652, Datisi wrote:marashu like. i'm sheeping catboi here, sue me, but i vibe with the idea that the fixation on me/bell is fake. i'm fine... leaving this for now and seeing what he does today and how he answers suspicion, but yeah uh not a fan
In post 686, Marashu wrote:mastina's case on Alisae/Norwee is very compelling. I feel like her arguments on Alisae are stronger so it's interesting that she's more sure on Norwee. VOTE: Norwee
so given this, why are you voting norwee and not alisae, if you think the case on ali is stronger?
Because that's where the pressure is currently, and if they're both scum then does the order matter?
MARASHU, WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT DATISI'S READ ON YOU AS A DARK ONE?
In post 600, catboi wrote:I've had a long day at work and haven't had time to read the whole thread properly but that kittytacky post is the worst I've seen in this game by quite a bit.
In post 600, catboi wrote:I've had a long day at work and haven't had time to read the whole thread properly but that kittytacky post is the worst I've seen in this game by quite a bit.
the worst? how so?
its a bunch of quote stripes followed by one-liners with no thought put into them, half of them don't even say anything important, and he ends it with a really obviously opportunistic vote on half baked reasoning - just "I'm convinced" and absolutely nothing more which doesn't feel like he had real thoughts about norwee's alignment at all
It's about the most classically newbscum post you'll ever see
If you ever played with me, that's how I play as town lol. Lots of one-liners. I'm struggling to adapt to this post restriction. And if I legit had nothing to add to a case I agreed with, what would I say besides "I agree"? Sheeping is not scummy.
In post 621, fireisredsir wrote:i like catboi's posting on this page quite a bit more than previous stuff which is a nice surprise. not enough to lean town yet but im less worried there i think
kitty doesn't feel scummy in quite the same way that he felt scummy when i played with him when he was scum but he still feels kinda scummy so sure
VOTE: kittytacky
Yes because this is my fucking town playstyle and now I'm being wagoned by someone who never played with me. I legit had nothing to add to the case, why on Earth would I say something else?
When i open this game, and starting read, i immediatly close it because i starting strongly consider self last townie alive and others are just jesters.
When i open this game, and starting read, i immediatly close it because i starting strongly consider self last townie alive and others are just jesters.
In post 644, mastina wrote:{Norwee, Alisae, Something_Smart, Titus, KittyTacky} (default team of five) feels a bit too easy to be the right solve.
This is also an issue for me. I asked for confirmation that 394 was a claim of KittyTacky's membership in Windclan and not a mistake since they still haven't posted there, and was told by Norwee is was the most unnecessary question ever, but if that is confirmed, and KT is scum, that means Windclan is both a 6 player clan and one that is absolutely stuffed with Dark Forest cats.
I understand that is a possibility given the nature of random assignment, but I do wonder if that was the case if they would have chosen to play this the way they did.
I feel like this is town
Shame on a martyr claiming friends
From either perspective of &
In post 623, catboi wrote:Like, do you think you're out of scum range right now? Because so far I think you're in the middle of both your ranges.
no, no i don't think so. though, out of curiosity - if i had answered "yes, i do think i'm outside my scumrange here", then what would you do?
ftr, my poke towards you wasn't meant as a "catboi *should* have a read on me by now," it was a "i hoped he'd have a read on me by now, as that will potentially help me read him."
anyway, i like the reasoning for kittytacky being scum. upon my skim, i skipped that post because big post, but when i got back to it... it really did not say anything, huh. and the fact that he took the time to photoshop my avatar onto a clam (and photoshop it kind of *well*, considering the white pixels are barely visible), rather than, you know, do things in the game... yeah. it kind of reminds me of that one thing i did in smuggler's, where i also tried to be funny by posting an image instead of like, y'know, doing things. also, screw you for making me remember that game.
VOTE: kittytacky
after i eat, will get to isoing people to try to make sense of my weaker reads, and actually give reason for my stronger ones. interested in why mastina's so certain she's not misreading me here (despite fire specifically saying her reasoning is flawed - which i do agree with).
I did it because I had paint.net already open and thought, why not. As for why I'm not doing a whole lot, what can I even do when there's a case, or rather two cases, that I agree with the reasoning of? Legit question. If I have nothing to say, I say nothing instead of posting (even more) filler or made-up extra reasoning, because that's even scummier.
When i open this game, and starting read, i immediatly close it because i starting strongly consider self last townie alive and others are just jesters.
When i open this game, and starting read, i immediatly close it because i starting strongly consider self last townie alive and others are just jesters.
Catboi is probably just wrong town tbh. I strongly TR him in spire of everything because I understand why someone would SR me for my weird playstyle. But with me, you gotta look at the motivation behind my posts.
When i open this game, and starting read, i immediatly close it because i starting strongly consider self last townie alive and others are just jesters.
In post 746, KittyTacky wrote:Catboi is probably just wrong town tbh. I strongly TR him in spire of everything because I understand why someone would SR me for my weird playstyle. But with me, you gotta look at the motivation behind my posts.
In post 746, KittyTacky wrote:Catboi is probably just wrong town tbh. I strongly TR him in spire of everything because I understand why someone would SR me for my weird playstyle. But with me, you gotta look at the motivation behind my posts.
can you elaborate on that townread?
I read through his walls and imo the reasoning within them is uninformed rather than informed and bent towards a conclusion he already knows.
When i open this game, and starting read, i immediatly close it because i starting strongly consider self last townie alive and others are just jesters.
When i open this game, and starting read, i immediatly close it because i starting strongly consider self last townie alive and others are just jesters.
