Warrior Cats Mafia [Day Three]

[Bell]

But this is mine.

Also. Still would like that poll if anyone is up to it.
I think it would help.

[T3]

I will say that T3 feels the most underwhelming content-wise in our hood overall when comparing all players.

They're catching up.

How do you know that is what they are doing or that’s what i meant?

Well given that I said that I was catching up multiple times

It’s what you’re saying based on catchup that i find underwhelming.
Them defending you because you’re catching up seems both out of tune and kinda like talking on your behalf which is questionable.

I see what you mean. I have notes and reads on nearly every player that I haven’t posted in-thread.

[Bell]

Please share with the class.
This may surprise you but you replaced into a slot so we do in fact need material for town to sort you.
Thank you~

[Bell]

ALIVE

Alisae: scum
catboi: town
Charloux: town
Datisi: scum
NorwegianboyEE:town
Bell: scum
KittyTacky: town
Dannflor:town
Mistyx: scum
SCRRRDBEAR: town
Titus: town
fireisredsir: town
mastina: scum
Frozen Angel: town
Cephrir: town
Marashu: Scum
Shiro: scum
Something_Smart: scum
Val89: town
Shiidaji: scum
PenguinPower:town

DEAD

EVENTS

[Bell]

^ when doing the above just go through each name and sort by the first alignment that pops into your head.
I’ll give you plus one bully points and think less of you if you write clown as an alignment.

[KittyTacky]

does T3 tend to struggle as scum

bc they're kind of reminding me of myself when i sub in as scum

In Sibyl's Elegy, they crashed and burned D1 as scum IIRC.

that is from a year and a half ago

That's the only T3 scum game I was in that I remember.

[KittyTacky]

mastina is teh best flip in the game
mastina wagon is the future

*gives a thumbs down*

[Marashu]

Hi I am a mason.

@Mastina: are you a mason?

Obviously.

mastina do you not have multiple abilities

I have one ability.

Clans aren't an ability. Everyone has that. It's not a PR if everyone has it. Saying a neighborhood is an ability in a game where everyone has it, is basically like saying a Vanilla Townie with the power of their voice and vote, is an ability. It's literally something even a VT would have.

Being an apprentice aren't an ability. That's a restriction on the abilities. A gate.

I have only one ability. Gated by being an apprentice. But only the one.

So to clarify, you're rescinding your mason claim? I get it was probably a joke but I just want to be super clear on this.

[Val89]

Alright. It's an interesting exercise, but it loses a lot on nuance in the process, because I think some of these would be more properly described as null. Cephrir in particular is one I don't think I would have written either and felt the same.

ALIVE

Alisae: scum
catboi: scum
Charloux: town
Datisi: scum
NorwegianboyEE:town
Bell: scum
KittyTacky: scum
Dannflor:town
Mistyx: scum
SCRRRDBEAR: town
Titus: town
fireisredsir: town
mastina: scum
Frozen Angel: scum
Cephrir: town
Marashu: town
Shiro: town
Something_Smart: town
Val89: town
Shiidaji: scum
PenguinPower:town

[NorwegianboyEE]

Same logic. Strength of read is not an factor, anything from full scumread to just very minor badvibes will be listed the same. That also goes for townreads.

Alisae=

Town

catboi=

Town

Charloux=

Town

Datisi=

Town

Bell=

Town

KittyTacky=

Scum

Dannflor=

Town

Mistyx=

Town

SCRRRDBEAR=

Town

Titus=

Town

fireisredsir=

Town

mastina=

Scum

Frozen Angel=

Town

Cephrir=

Scum

Marashu=

Town

Shiro=

Town

Something_Smart=

Scum

Val89=

Town

T3=

Scum

PenguinPower=

Scum

[catboi]

who all do you think is scummy right now (outside of me) catboi

titus
ceph
penguin

[Frozen Angel]

I dont have reliable net connection tonight. will try catching up tomorrow again instead

[Bell]

Happy scumday

[Mistyx]

good morning i am late for class because I overslept also I had a dream that S_S was scum

I am assuming these two facts are correlated and that this was important info that was meant to be revealed to me no matter the cost

[Charloux]

Alisae=

Scum

catboi=

Scum

Norwegian=

Scum

Datisi=

Scum

Bell=

Scum

KittyTacky=

Scum

Dannflor=

Town

Mistyx=

Scum

SCRRRDBEAR=

Town

Titus=

Town

fireisredsir=

Town

mastina=

Scum

Frozen Angel=

Town

Cephrir=

Scum

Marashu=

Town

Shiro=

Town

Something_Smart=

Scum

Val89=

Scum

T3=

Scum

PenguinPower=

Chad

Anybody null and below is treated as scum.

[PenguinPower]

I'm honored to be Chad.

[T3]

Spoiler: all my notes so far

catboi isn’t scum with Charloux, catboi might not bring Charloux’s post up. catboi is scum with Charloux because catboi defends Charloux while pushing him. Pay more attention to this slot.

Charloux is scum because of the ‘slip’ and Charloux tries to deflect the accusations by attacking Frozen Angel’s sense of humor. Charloux is clearly claiming pr, but Titus doesn’t like it. But maybe it’s an error of judgement by Charloux that’s unrelated to the game. Not much content from Charloux since then that I like, one post pinged me as bad.

Titus could have had a legit townslip with the whole protector thing?

Dannflor can’t detect tone. Dannflor saying Datisi’s vote is good is weird. Dannflor has weird voting patterns.

Datisi scumreading Frozen Angel for over explaining her vote is weird because Frozen Angel simply wasn’t doing that. Datisi’s explanation boiled down to him saying things that other people have already said in the thread.

Mistyx is scummy. She’s saying that things are arbitrary but not actually offering her own suggestions as to what the thread should be talking about. 452 is also scummy because it’s questioning mech stuff that isn’t public. Also her asking why mastina’s Norwee vote is the only vote Norwee cares about is bad because mastina was leading the wagon. 601-609 progression is bad. Her questioning of KT is good and displays clear scumhunting.

S_S had generally good observations but nothing concrete from that.

fireisredsir scummy that he said Datisi and Marashu are the same level of scummy, didn’t distinguish, implies an underlying agenda

Val is scummy because of his Alisae read. Discrediting Alisae’s push by attacking the premise of the push but not responding to the point. Val found some of the same posts as me to be good and persuasive. Val’s reevaluation tracks

Alisae goodvibes BUT looks like Alisae is trying to pocket norwee. No Alisae isn’t?

Bell’s case on Datisi is good. 449 from Bell is very towny, it shows that he’s actually reading the game with intent to get reads and is a post that scum might not think to fake.

BEAR’s point about Datisi is good and from my past experience with Datisi I agree with it. Points look organic

Mastina post 572 is horrible and very scummy. Writes off Alisae/Norwee as not being s/t and Alisae being town for bad reasons. Nothing to suggest that Alisae’s strong reaction isn’t towny, town will get annoyed if someone is scumreading them for dumb reasons. Mastina also doesn’t engage with the content of Val’s post. Mastina’s tone feels different to the last time I played with scum!mastina but it’s also been a while.

KT is scum. He doesn’t engage with the reasoning as to why people are voting him, he instead says that one-liners are scummy meanwhile people are voting him for his half-baked reasoning. KT also says that people aren’t looking at the motivations of his posts when they are. KT saying that Alisae’s vote is OMGUS is really bad.

Shiro I agreed with some of her points about the Mastina/Alisae/Norwee spat

Norwee: whether Alisae is town or scum, her read on Norwee always comes from a genuine place. Not sure if I trust Alisae to read norwee correctly tho

[Datisi]

Anybody null and below is treated as scum.

were you not townreading me earlier? what changed?

[Dannflor]

VOTE: Penguin

[Something_Smart]

good morning i am late for class because I overslept also I had a dream that S_S was scum

I am assuming these two facts are correlated and that this was important info that was meant to be revealed to me no matter the cost

it means that if you scumread me you will be cursed to be forever late to class (I hope your class was ok and you did not miss anything important)

Alisae=

Town

catboi=

Scum

Charloux=

Town

Norwegian=

Scum

Datisi=

Scum

Bell=

Town

KittyTacky=

Town

Dannflor=

Town

Mistyx=

Scum

SCRRRDBEAR=

Town

Titus=

Town

fireisredsir=

Scum

mastina=

Scum

Frozen Angel=

Scum

Cephrir=

Scum

Marashu=

Town

Shiro=

Scum

Val89=

Town

T3=

Town

PenguinPower=

Town

[Cephrir]

Following Mastina in her towngames is an adventure, an joirney if you will.
You see their thoughts evolve, their brainpower being put at full work and on display for all to see. It’s beautiful and freaking obvious whwn she is town.
As scum she is an terminator. One goal, one set of programming, no hesitancy, no doubt. Nothing may change the set values. It’s clear to me that this is what we are dealing with here based on the carchup.

Hm

This might be true actually

[Something_Smart]

mastina= Scum

this should maybe say town but idk I've been going back and forth on her a lot.

her whole thing about townlocking everyone in the hood except for me based on them literally just being excited about being in a hood together is eyebrow-raising, even for her.

[catboi]

Hi I am a mason.

@Mastina: are you a mason?

Obviously.

mastina do you not have multiple abilities

I have one ability.

Clans aren't an ability. Everyone has that. It's not a PR if everyone has it. Saying a neighborhood is an ability in a game where everyone has it, is basically like saying a Vanilla Townie with the power of their voice and vote, is an ability. It's literally something even a VT would have.

Being an apprentice aren't an ability. That's a restriction on the abilities. A gate.

I have only one ability. Gated by being an apprentice. But only the one.

So to clarify, you're rescinding your mason claim? I get it was probably a joke but I just want to be super clear on this.

she claims mason whenever she's in a neighborhood it's not a real claim

[catboi]

VOTE: penguin

[Datisi]

Following Mastina in her towngames is an adventure, an joirney if you will.
You see their thoughts evolve, their brainpower being put at full work and on display for all to see. It’s beautiful and freaking obvious whwn she is town.
As scum she is an terminator. One goal, one set of programming, no hesitancy, no doubt. Nothing may change the set values. It’s clear to me that this is what we are dealing with here based on the carchup.

Hm

This might be true actually

how accurate is norwee's description of mastina as town vs as scum?

to, like, everyone