Mini 2284: The Thing Anonymous [Day 2]

[Palmer~]

Nauls: Human
Garry: Thing???

I always find it very hard to make scumreads this early unless someone does something outrageously scummy. That second one is very faint and I mostly have townreads and nulls right now.

Lars also town, as strong as Nauls.

So is Windows on a re-read of everything.

OK Norris is scummy, scummier than Garry.
VOTE: Norris

Can these actually be explained? They don't actually mean anything to me right now.

[Palmer~]

I'm gonna go out on a limb and say that Lars' treatment of Norris is

worse

than Copper's is, assuming Norris is town. Copper's vote is naked and unexplained, sure. But reading through Lars' posts on the bottom of page 7 and top of page 8, they give off this aura of Lars trying really hard to appear superior to Norris. It doesn't read like he's actually interrogating Norris, it reads like he's trying to show to the rest of us how unreasonable and scummy Norris is.

I also think Norris is a type of player that is easier to read if he's allowed to do his own thing, rather than if he gets jumped on early. Which is an additional point that gives me the chills about Lars here.

[Palmer~]

VOTE: Lars

[Lars~]

I was interrogating them until they started trolling and refused to answer. At that point, I felt like I knew exactly what they were doing, and also that it was probably going to work. That was why I thought the most important thing for me to do was try to get others to see what I was seeing instead.

I was trying to show you why Norris' actions don't make sense as town and explaining what their motivations would be as scum because I knew that most people were going to fall for the play.

[Lars~]

at least, that was my mindset at the time. I'm not as certain as I was in the moment, but I still think they're most likely scum.

[Copper~]

Elaborate.

Gut and sheeping Lars.

[Copper~]

I'm also getting opportunistic vibes from Copper which is making me think Norris is more likely town here. Not huge on the (basically) naked vote from Copper there.

Opportunistic how? It's mostly a gutread but we're not even on page 10.

[Copper~]

Nauls: Human
Garry: Thing???

I always find it very hard to make scumreads this early unless someone does something outrageously scummy. That second one is very faint and I mostly have townreads and nulls right now.

Lars also town, as strong as Nauls.

So is Windows on a re-read of everything.

OK Norris is scummy, scummier than Garry.
VOTE: Norris

Can these actually be explained? They don't actually mean anything to me right now.

Garry = tone, Nauls and Lars seem to be trying pretty hard to solve even this early and that's +town imo, Windows mostly on tone, Norris on tone and sheeping my townread Nauls.

[Copper~]

Also this kind of trolling is really scummy imo.

[Palmer~]

How are Garry's and Norris' tones different than Windows'?

[Norris~]

LALALA I CANT HEAR YOU HATERS MAYBE YOU SHOULD TRY BEING LOUDER ABOUT IT

Somebody else ask me something.

[Palmer~]

Do you still feel Windows is scum and who (else) do you want to kill?

[Norris~]

Alot of the conversation I find boring, I was going go try to make a readslist last night but I got too focused on trolling. Gotta troll my haters.

So I'm not sure my reads right now.

Though I remember somebody said something about tring Garry which I disagree with, its too generous for what they are.

[MacReady~]

OK Norris is scummy, scummier than Garry.
VOTE: Norris

Also this kind of trolling is really scummy imo.

Why is the trolling scummy?

[petapan]

The Clark~ account has been given to a replacement player.

[Garry~]

I only have one vote to punish wolfy play, I wish I had more.

[Clark~]

I'm back with upgraded pronouns, time to read the thread

[Palmer~]

Though I remember somebody said something about tring Garry which I disagree with, its too generous for what they are.

I am one of those people; what's wrong with Garry?

[Clark~]

End of page 1 I'm liking Windows and Mac

[Clark~]

page 2 Garry seems towny

[Clark~]

I’m going to be frank

Nice to meet you Frank

[Garry~]

MacReady, Windows, Fuchs
Blair, Bennings, Palmer
Copper, Nauls, Childs, Norris
Clark, Lars

Somewhere around here. I’m having issues processing this game because of the familiar profile pictures and my inability to distinguish men.
I feel weird about Lars the last few pages (not condemning for a bottom tier read I know, can’t write paragraphs currently, Clark is MIA after yesterday’s exit and I still think he could be trying to wait out the pressure. Nauls I think I need more from to get to a townread, a lot seemed catchupy. Childs was... not great on a quick read but this one is prone to change depending on deeper looks into. Norris shouldn’t be rewarded for their play, defiance and anger can be easy to fake. (Side note though it’s also easy to look good from condemning it, Lars r.e Norris was meh. Childs arguably worse iirc.) Considered having a null Copper tier because I think they’re likelyish to be town but still dwelling.

Edit: Timing!

[Garry~]

I’ll allow you space to catch up Clark, but when you have the time please give us more depth?

[Clark~]

Frank!
Ask me some questions so I can go look for answers and get involed

[Garry~]

Finish reading first, and then circle back to trying to explain your townreads?