Open 867: PYP: SEFD - Day Three

[Enchant]

Roleblocker, which also fits Doctor slot.

And?

[PenguinPower]

Roleblocker, which also fits Doctor slot.

And?

Great. Great.

Now what was Bearfriend’s alignment?

[Enchant]

Town.

[PenguinPower]

Good good.

So, what information does that mean scum had when choosing the night kill?

[Enchant]

Picks. People who tried for Doctor/RB (and any role if we speak) but failed, knew there's doctor higher in order.

[PenguinPower]

Scum would have known they did not have that row so that there was quite possibly a doctor in play. They would also have known that Roden wasn’t scum (if Roden isn’t scum) and was 99.9% a PR so would have been the optimal protect.

Just because Roden is alive doesn’t mean Roden is scum.

[Enchant]

Aren't metaplay is to pick Ascetic Cop who can't be protected?

[Enchant]

UNLESS YOU GO FOR BULLETPROOF LIKE CHAD

[Enchant]

If you ask me.

Would i pick bulletproof again, if i did roll toppick?

Yes.

[JunkoChan]

on that note we could lim nsg, if nsg flips town, we lim roden, if scum we lim porkens or another roden call no?

[Gamma Emerald]

Aren't metaplay is to pick Ascetic Cop who can't be protected?

That is one option
A one-step-up play might be to pick PGO expecting to get targeted early

Also I’ll be upfront, I did try to pick rb because I figured it might slip the early draft spots and I feel like my record with rb is better than my record as doc, ESPECIALLY after CK9++. I’m bringing this up because if Penguin’s theory is correct, I’m effectively a miller to a draft cop.

[Gamma Emerald]

If you ask me.

Would i pick bulletproof again, if i did roll toppick?

Yes.

That only works if you either a) already have burden of proficiency (the type that gets you nightkilled early) coming in, or b) you put in effort to draw the nightkill.

[Gamma Emerald]

on that note we could lim nsg, if nsg flips town, we lim roden, if scum we lim porkens or another roden call no?

On an nsg townflip, my number 1 suspect would be you

[Gamma Emerald]

@enchant:

could you talk about how you feel about Dann?

Requoting this with the other portions removed since enchant has posted since the original post

[JunkoChan]

on that note we could lim nsg, if nsg flips town, we lim roden, if scum we lim porkens or another roden call no?

On an nsg townflip, my number 1 suspect would be you

huh

[JunkoChan]

[JunkoChan]

Well here we go, at this point in the post I feel like this wagon built faster than I fcking remembered 1 day and a few hours irl

right now in this very moment I think I'd most want to kill VOTE: nk15

first vote from dann, after re-reading through Dann's posts, I feel like he at least had a case on nk15 from start to finish, dann on a re-read what changes on your aprettiation of the game in 600? as it felt like nothing changes from there all the way to nk15's lim

Can we please eliminate NK15?

VOTE: nk15 I’d prefer this over pretty much any other.

again on a re-read I feel like porkens went from "flavour of the day" vote to "flavour of the day" vote without ever explaining or giving reason to anything, you can seee this in 391 534 654 and 764 they all fill blendy

VOTE: NK15

I STILL FOS GAMMA

scrrrdbear joins the wagon and...

Oh my fucking god you are beautiful.

VOTE: penguinepower

flavour of the day vote comes in

Aren't penguin was your top townread

Enchant points this out +town

I’m just super intimidated by him

and the answer is pfft is flavour of the day so I have to vote kappa

Oh my fucking god you are beautiful.

VOTE: penguinepower

Memeing is fun while we wait, but stop fucking with the vote count.

Kthx.

this interaction feels natural from penguin

VOTE: NK15

awkward hop in considering 386 is the only time jhonny ever talked about nk15 that I could find, what was the motivation there?

yeah - i'm fine with that

VOTE: nk15

annoyed tone yet natural

VOTE: NK15

And this was Yume's game-advancing content for today.

f'ing weird hop in, but consistent with yume's "gameplay"

BAH

VOTE: NSG

I DON'T THINK THIS IS TOWN

I have to give credit to bear's vote here, sadly we didn't listen, (not like the lolhammer gave us time to)

VOTE: NK15
Whatever. Let’s just him and me out back-to-back, give Penguin what he wants so fucking badly
Enjoy having 4 dead town by Day 3

penguin and gamma probably not mafia with this interaction

VOTE: NK15

I WILL PUSH NSG TOMORROW, THEIR D1 PLAY WAS SCUMMY

oh dear lord..

VOTE: nk15

Ok ok

lolhammer

[JunkoChan]

Roden
KittyTacky
Enchant

Gamma Emerald
PenguinPower
Dannflor
Not_Mafia
Yume

JohnnyFarrar
northsidegal
Porkens

I'm sitting on this

[JohnnyFarrar]

what was the motivation there?

Legit just compromise

[JohnnyFarrar]

Also I'm not gonna vote Gamma today barring something wild

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

vote count 2.01

with 12 votes in play, it takes 7 to make a decision. day 2 ends in (expired on 2022-11-13 13:48:00).

yeet

northsidegal [2]:

Roden, Yume

Porkens [2]:

Junkochan, KittyTacky

Roden [1]:

Enchant

not voting [7]:

JohnnyFarrar, PenguinPower, Dannflor, Gamma Emerald, Not_Mafia, Porkens, northsidegal,

mod notes

None

flavour

[KittyTacky]

Was re-reading the game. Pretty sure Porkens is scum, esp by the interactions with Gamma.
VOTE: Porkens

You too

147 and the string of posts onwards is just terrible. And the way you backed down makes it even scummier, if it was in a more natural way then I'd have let go but it gives me really terrible vibes.

[KittyTacky]

Kitty what happened to your scum read on me

I still think you're scummy for much the same reasons, I just want Porkens more.

[Enchant]

If you ask me.

Would i pick bulletproof again, if i did roll toppick?

Yes.

That only works if you either a) already have burden of proficiency (the type that gets you nightkilled early) coming in, or b) you put in effort to draw the nightkill.

i fear nks

[Enchant]

@enchant:

could you talk about how you feel about Dann?

Requoting this with the other portions removed since enchant has posted since the original post

Dann would be more favored if he didn't vote NK15 who i declared mason.