Medieval Mafia - Game Over

[camn]

I forgive you.

[hasdgfas]

Also, why don't I have a bunch of people blindly following me? No IRC players in this game?

Xyl, could you explain why this post was necessary? Seems to me like it's just there because you

want

people to blindly follow you.

[OhGodMyLife]

Korejora is incredibly awesome and replaces CounselWolf. Thanks, Korejora!

[Xylthixlm]

Also, why don't I have a bunch of people blindly following me? No IRC players in this game?

Xyl, could you explain why this post was necessary? Seems to me like it's just there because you

want

people to blindly follow you.

I've gotten too used to being able to generate pressure wagons at whim. Bad habit.

[OhGodMyLife]

Vote Count:

9 to lynch

Jebus: 4 (populartajo, Xylthixlm, Yosarian2, qwints)
Thestatusquo: 2 (DrippingGoofball, camn)
DrippingGoofball: 2 (farside22, Korejora)
hasdgfas: 2 (Caboose, scotmany12)
camn: 1 (Jebus)
Xylthixlm: 1 (Thestatusquo)
qwints: 1 (Kmd4390)

Not Voting: 4 (stark, crywolf20084, hasdgfas, sam.samhorn)

[Xylthixlm]

Hi korejora. Be like the awesome players and jump right in.

[populartajo]

Also, why don't I have a bunch of people blindly following me? No IRC players in this game?

Xyl, could you explain why this post was necessary? Seems to me like it's just there because you

want

people to blindly follow you.

This cow needs to die. Please.

[scotmany12]

Also, why don't I have a bunch of people blindly following me? No IRC players in this game?

Xyl, could you explain why this post was necessary? Seems to me like it's just there because you

want

people to blindly follow you.

This cow needs to die. Please.

Said the person voting Jebus.

[populartajo]

Also, why don't I have a bunch of people blindly following me? No IRC players in this game?

Xyl, could you explain why this post was necessary? Seems to me like it's just there because you

want

people to blindly follow you.

This cow needs to die. Please.

Said the person voting Jebus.

Unvote Vote has

HAHA

[hasdgfas]

Also, why don't I have a bunch of people blindly following me? No IRC players in this game?

Xyl, could you explain why this post was necessary? Seems to me like it's just there because you

want

people to blindly follow you.

This cow needs to die. Please.

please explain why this post has had such an effect on you, because I sure don't see what you do.

[populartajo]

It wasnt only that post. I disagree with at least 80% of everything you have posted so far.

[hasdgfas]

It wasnt only that post. I disagree with at least 80% of everything you have posted so far.

so disagreeing with someone makes them scummy?

[populartajo]

It wasnt only that post. I disagree with at least 80% of everything you have posted so far.

so disagreeing with someone makes them scummy?

What you are proposing posts ago is scummy. Its not that the majority thinks different, as you assume. Its that I dont see any protown motive behind the proposition of outing our vig.
You are rolefishing like crazy.
You are not analyzing things that deserve to be analyzed. You are analizing weak things (like asking Xyl what he was trying to do with his joke comment in or asking camn for clarification of something obvious.) I mean, using your words, was that necessary?

[hasdgfas]

It wasnt only that post. I disagree with at least 80% of everything you have posted so far.

so disagreeing with someone makes them scummy?

What you are proposing posts ago is scummy. Its not that the majority thinks different, as you assume. Its that I dont see any protown motive behind the proposition of outing our vig.

that's fine, which is why I dropped it. Nobody agrees with me.

You are rolefishing like crazy.

I dropped the vig claiming thing, so please tell me you have a different example of this.

You are not analyzing things that deserve to be analyzed. You are analizing weak things (like asking Xyl what he was trying to do with his joke comment in or asking camn for clarification of something obvious.) I mean, using your words, was that necessary?

"joke comments" are often the most important things to look at, and camn's statement was obviously not obvious since I asked for clarification on it.

[Xylthixlm]

populartajo, hasdgfas: Do you do this in every game you're in together?

[populartajo]

It wasnt only that post. I disagree with at least 80% of everything you have posted so far.

so disagreeing with someone makes them scummy?

What you are proposing posts ago is scummy. Its not that the majority thinks different, as you assume. Its that I dont see any protown motive behind the proposition of outing our vig.

that's fine, which is why I dropped it. Nobody agrees with me.

Any idea why?

You are rolefishing like crazy.

I dropped the vig claiming thing, so please tell me you have a different example of this.

When did I say there was other example?

You are not analyzing things that deserve to be analyzed. You are analizing weak things (like asking Xyl what he was trying to do with his joke comment in or asking camn for clarification of something obvious.) I mean, using your words, was that necessary?

"joke comments" are often the most important things to look at, and camn's statement was obviously not obvious since I asked for clarification on it.[/quote]
You are not getting the problem. I can buy that joke comments can also contain information but when there are 1000000 things more important to analyze then there is something odd. You are avoiding them for whatever reason. Also whats the difficult part in camn's post?

[populartajo]

populartajo, hasdgfas: Do you do this in every game you're in together?

Last time we completed a game has was scum and I was town. I catched his scumpartners and catched him at the end near my lynch. So, no.

[hasdgfas]

looking at kmd, because I've been getting some strange vibes from him.

Post 2:

I could have sworn that all we had was a confirmation phase. Why is everyone act like we had a night 0?

Don't role fish.

(Another comment Camn can appreciate)

I already mentioned that this was weird, but looking at it closer, I find it really weird. Why is he making a "joke comment" that only one other person can understand? Feels like buddying to me. Plus, calling that role fishing, even as a joke, doesn't make sense to me.

Post 7:

I remember Cam Neely!
Just from the name, though... I never was into him... He was on some EASTERN conference team, wasn't he?
I live out west.

But I remember the name.

Yeah. Bruins.

TSQ, how do you have a serious vote on Farside already?

Already commented on this, but I will again, since I'm going through kmd. Commenting on someone's serious vote feels off to me, and I don't understand why kmd felt it necessary to ask how he has a serious vote out.

Post 10:

Because he didn't give a reason for it.

This as the explanation for him asking the question in his post 7 doesn't sit right with me. Expecting a reason behind every serious vote seems scum-motivated to me.

Post 11:

I'm claiming now, so you don't waste an investigation on me. I'm Sir Gawaine's son, a miller one shot day vig.

If you are a miller, this is the right move. Not sure I would have included the vig part though.

Adding the "not sure I would have included the vig part though" seems unnecessary to me. Why do you feel the need to add that? Seems like just making an inane comment that does nothing with regards to believing him or not.

Post 16:

Yeah, an unprovoked fakeclaim. And nothing to give us from it?

Interesting move...

This does absolutely nothing. Again, it's just a comment about what happened and not actually trying to draw anything from it or trying to say anything.

Post 17:

Vote Zwet

Ideally, I would like to see him dead before he gets to post again, just in case he is a scum dayvig. I am 100% serious about this.

This is a good point. If he's scum dayvig, I don't want to give him a chance to shoot a townie.

DGB is my second suspect right now.

Now kmd jumps on the zwet wagon after seeing that it's going quite fast. He had one of the earliest chances to vote for zwet after the fakeclaim, but decided to not take sides. Now he takes sides after seeing that it's popular. I don't like that.

Post 19:

Martyr? Pretty sure what you described is a bodyguard...

This also seems to do absolutely nothing for the game. Seems like this comment is just designed to bring unnecessary attention to the name of zwet's role, since the same role can have different names with different mods, flavor, etc.

Post 28:

Howzabout we lynch sam today and I protect DGB. That way, in the morning after people try to NK DGB, I'll be dead and confirmed, and DGB can

bus

TSQ.

The bolded is one of at least 3 things wrong with this post.

I don't like how you mention that there are at least 3 things wrong with the post, but only point out one of them. Why not point out the others?


Post 39: This is an analysis of qwints, followed by a vote, but I don't really know why qwints is being voted for. There's analysis, but no conclusions. Seems like trying to look like a case is being made, but I don't see one. Why are you voting for qwints?


kmd seems to be making a lot of inane comments that look like they're contributions when they're actually not. The case on qwints seems pretty similar in that it's supposed to look like a case, but just seems to be making little comments on his posts, followed by a vote. I don't actually know why he's voting for qwints.
Then there's him jumping on the zwet wagon really late after everyone else did, even though if he actually found what zwet did scummy, he had an chance 5 hours before. I find it unlikely that he changed his mind from it being not scummy to scummy in that period of time. I think he just jumped on because he wouldn't get a lot of flak for it.
Because of that and because I want some answers,

vote: kmd

PREVIEW EDIT:
@Xyl: Do what?
@tajo 516: which game was that again? (I'll look at 515 after posting this)

[hasdgfas]

It wasnt only that post. I disagree with at least 80% of everything you have posted so far.

so disagreeing with someone makes them scummy?

What you are proposing posts ago is scummy. Its not that the majority thinks different, as you assume. Its that I dont see any protown motive behind the proposition of outing our vig.

that's fine, which is why I dropped it. Nobody agrees with me.

Any idea why?

Because I'm horrible at explaining my reasoning for why it's a good idea.

You are rolefishing like crazy.

I dropped the vig claiming thing, so please tell me you have a different example of this.

When did I say there was other example?

I assumed there was because you said I was "rolefishing like crazy", and I would assume that that included more than one example.

You are not analyzing things that deserve to be analyzed. You are analizing weak things (like asking Xyl what he was trying to do with his joke comment in or asking camn for clarification of something obvious.) I mean, using your words, was that necessary?

"joke comments" are often the most important things to look at, and camn's statement was obviously not obvious since I asked for clarification on it.

You are not getting the problem. I can buy that joke comments can also contain information but when there are 1000000 things more important to analyze then there is something odd. You are avoiding them for whatever reason. Also whats the difficult part in camn's post?

camn said that she wanted a confirmed townie to get NK'd, and it wasn't clear to me that she was talking about a confirmed townie who was lurking, so I wanted clarification.

[Thestatusquo]

The argument between DGB and TSQ is really silly. I have no opinion on that.

I would really like for Jebus to come back though. Maybe he used his daykill? He should probably tell us in that case.

I would also support a Caboose lynch, if Jebus does not come to fruition. I'm getting bad vibes from him. A confirmed townie > vig.

Caboose is pretty much town in my eyes for the way he reacted to the second claim by zwet. Go look at it. It would take a lot of quick thinking and good acting to fake that.

KMD: I'm not over reacting, I'm frustrated. The attack about busing farside was just so ridiculous that it pissed me off, and then it was echoed by someone else.

[sam.samhorn]

OK so hasdgfas has proven in the last page that he's scum.

Vote: hasdgfas

Some more stuff:

1) DGB is so incredibly frustrating and terrible of a player that I refuse to read his posts so I just skim over them
2) I still think Caboose is scum (gut), checking to see if his post history matches the initial thoughts I have from him
3) People who are indeed town: camn

[sam.samhorn]

OK so hasdgfas has proven in the last page that he's scum.

Vote: hasdgfas

Some more stuff:

1) DGB is so incredibly frustrating and terrible of a player that I refuse to read his posts so I just skim over them
2) I still think Caboose is scum (gut), checking to see if his post history matches the initial thoughts I have from him
3) People who are indeed town: camn

Nevermind number 2. The gut scumtell I had on him turned out to be unwarranted. Anyways...hasgfas is mafia. I am too lazy right now to provide the full case, but if anyone wants me to squawk it then let me know.

[Xylthixlm]

Caboose is pretty much town in my eyes for the way he reacted to the second claim by zwet. Go look at it. It would take a lot of quick thinking and good acting to fake that.

QFT

[Thestatusquo]

XYL is going nowhere. I can def. get behind this has wagon.

Vote: Hasdgfas

[Kmd4390]

Well I'm on my home computer which is slow so I'm in lazy mode, but I should respond to hascow's case. Doing that now.

(Note that just because I'm posting in lazy mode doesn't mean that A)I've read everything else or B)My response will be lazy.)