Medieval Mafia - Game Over

[Korejora]

stark. And you could argue Tar, too, but not near as hard.

@DGB, by 'bussed', do you mean it in the classic sense of scum vs scum? I think it's a little odd for scum to try and go after camn (if she's town), as she's not exactly an easy target right now.

[hasdgfas]

Something tells me sam is too agressive/close minded to be a manipulating mafia. I could be wrong, though.

I think he's either really tunnel-visioned mafia who keeps going after the same people so he can lynch them or town who keeps going after the same people with no good reason to.

I do feel like the "dayvig" is an SK who is trying to look like a dayvig, because it just seems like too many town kills with the fact that the night vig-masons have multiple kills.

So stark, who do you think is scum?

Right now, camn.

Camn has said nothing of substance this game and only posts for the sake of posting. She is so incredibly mafia.

PS DGB: I am trying to undermine your "credibility" because you're an awful mafia player and you need to realize this ASAP.

This post gives me awful vibes. First is the nothing of substance comment which I feel is completely off base. I remember seeing quite a bit from camn, so unless sam gives some examples, I'm going to just ignore this accusation.

I don't like the "ad hom"-ish thing from him towards DGB. It seems like he wants to undermine her credibility because she's possibly hitting a little too close to home. I should look back at what she said that brought this comment from him.

[populartajo]

stark. And you could argue Tar, too, but not near as hard.

@DGB, by 'bussed', do you mean it in the classic sense of scum vs scum? I think it's a little odd for scum to try and go after camn (if she's town), as she's not exactly an easy target right now.

Also this.
Why exactly hasnt Rogueben claimed yet?

[camn]

stark. And you could argue Tar, too, but not near as hard.

@DGB, by 'bussed', do you mean it in the classic sense of scum vs scum? I think it's a little odd for scum to try and go after camn (if she's town), as she's not exactly an easy target right now.

Also this.
Why exactly hasnt Rogueben claimed yet?

He is VLA till Tuesday.

[OhGodMyLife]

Vote Count:

7 to lynch

Rogueben: 5 (Korejora, Xylthixlm, DrippingGoofball, populartajo, farside22)
stark: 2 (Rogueben, Xylthixlm)
camn: 2 (sam.samhorn, Yosarian2)

Not Voting: 5 (hasdgfas, stark, scotmany12, camn, Tarhalindur)

[Xylthixlm]

Someone needs to put another vote on Rogueben.

[camn]

I'd like to hear his defense first...

[DrippingGoofball]

@DGB, by 'bussed', do you mean it in the classic sense of scum vs scum? I think it's a little odd for scum to try and go after camn (if she's town), as she's not exactly an easy target right now.

You just described the perfect bus'ing weather. There's no better time to go after a buddy when there is no chance of it leading to a lynch.

[Tarhalindur]

Someone needs to put another vote on Rogueben.

1) Rogueben is at L-2.
2) There are more than ten players in the game.
3) Yesterday should be a good reminder of exactly why you force a claim at L-2, especially in large games.

No need for somebody else to put a vote on Rogueben, we should just force the claim now. Speaking of that...

Rogueben, claim or die.

(For those of you who are unaware, it is my policy to force the claim at L-2 regardless of previous support or lack thereof for the wagon.)

[Tarhalindur]

When night comes around, I'll investigate, but I think you've secured yourself a good position.

Are you officially changing your claim?

Investigate using my powers of reading through 30+ pages.

You seem to be under the mistaken impression that you will survive until the beginning of Day 3 without posting some kind of analysis on Day 2.

I suggest you reconsider that assumption.

Sincerely,
Tarhalindur, vig-mason representative

[Tarhalindur]

Oh right,

unvote

if voting.

No point in having my vote up while we're forcing a claim from Rogueben.

[DrippingGoofball]

stark. And you could argue Tar, too, but not near as hard.

Also, samhorn has been bus'ing camn. That's two players out of three that I believe are scum, going after camn when there is nothing at all suspicious about her, and there is no chance of camn being lynched. Do I ever smell distancing.

[camn]

When night comes around, I'll investigate, but I think you've secured yourself a good position.

Are you officially changing your claim?

Investigate using my powers of reading through 30+ pages.

You seem to be under the mistaken impression that you will survive until the beginning of Day 3 without posting some kind of analysis on Day 2.

I suggest you reconsider that assumption.

Sincerely,
Tarhalindur, vig-mason representative

Please.

Stark has been promising to do some analysis for, like, three weeks.
He clearly does NOT intend to do it.

This is the greatest one, from March 1st:

TO CAMN

I'm going to do try to do a serious analysis tonight. Things have been very busy for me, but I won't dissapoint.

Trust me, this is not the first time a high school boy has disappointed me.


And DGB.. stop distancing from me! Lets just check on stark and sam's alignment first.. and slander my good name second, OK?

[DrippingGoofball]

And DGB.. stop distancing from me! Lets just check on stark and sam's alignment first.. and slander my good name second, OK?

I thought you craved attention!

How is my paying attention? Call 1-800-PAY-ATTN

[Yosarian2]

Mod: I should be currently voting camm.

Fixed. -OGML

[camn]

Even OGML can't believe it.

[Yosarian2]

Even OGML can't believe it.

Yeah, it probably is hard to believe that I've caught two scum in one day.

[Korejora]

Oh, that makes four or so? And two prominents? I stand corrected, camn isn't an obviously difficult target.

[DrippingGoofball]

stark. And you could argue Tar, too, but not near as hard.

Also, samhorn has been bus'ing camn. That's two players out of three that I believe are scum, going after camn when there is nothing at all suspicious about her, and there is no chance of camn being lynched. Do I ever smell distancing.

WOW. Add Yosarian to the list.

stark
samhorn
Tar
Yosarian

I believe three of these players to be scum. That's almost too good to be true.

There appears to be a very strong and intriguing correlation between bus'ing camn, and making

ad hom

attacks on me and some may politely refer to as my 'scumhunting.'.

[DrippingGoofball]

Yeah, it probably is hard to believe that I've caught two scum in one day.

Who is the first?

[DrippingGoofball]

Oh yes, Kmd, never mind...

[camn]

Even OGML can't believe it.

Yeah, it probably is hard to believe that I've caught two scum in one day.

Alright, for serious.

I am getting tired of Yosarian taking credit for "catching" KMD. He keeps repeating it over and over.. and I would like to point something out:

FIRST. Mar 9, 5:20pm

OK.
I have done some wagon analysis.... And I have decided that KMD is scum....
My scumlist =

Stark
KMD
sam.sam
Korejora

and

Yosarian

and/or

Farside

Notice Yosarian on my scumlist. Also, at this time, IIRC, Yos was arguing with POPTAJO about cults and stuff.

THEN>>>March 10, 12:32pm

c) Shouldn't we just lynch Yosarian, then.. if he is unreadable? Better now than have him burn us in endgame, right?

Pfffttt. No one is unreadable.

Anyway, KMD's recent posts seem off to me;..blah blah scum-bussing-justification,

vote:Kmd

NOW, Yos is claiming to have "caught" KMD...

YOSARIAN IS SUSPECT!!

This behavior is odd. I can only conclude that:

a) Yos is scum
b) Yos is sofclaiming DayVig
c) Yos is delusional.

Which is it, my friend?

[Xylthixlm]

This behavior is odd. I can only conclude that:

a) Yos is scum
b) Yos is sofclaiming DayVig
c)

Yos

camn is delusional.

Which is it, my friend?

Fixed.

[Yosarian2]

I figured out KMD was scum, based on his posts today, for reasons unrelated to anything anyone else was saying. I made it clear that I thought he was scum, I voted for him, and I was trying pretty hard to get him lynched instead of Stark when he was dayvigged; if it wasn't for the dayvig, I think I would have had a pretty good chance of getting him lynched today, or if the stark wagon had been too strong, I think I would have at least gotten KMD lynched tommorow. So, yes, I caught a scum, in that I figured out he was scum based on a series of scumtells I laid out in the thread, and I'm pretty happy about it.

I like the way that you edited my post to remove my actual reasoning for why I first thought KMD was scum. This was the full case I was pushing on him, right before he got dayvigged (and, most likely, the one that convinced the dayvig KMD was scum.)

Show us why KMD is prob scum then.

It's mostly his behavior today. His case against Xyl was weak, but he stuck to it despite a really strong claim made by Xyl and backed up by another player. He then followed it up by attacking the two people who were attacking him, for no reason other then OMGUS. And I really hate how he just bought into DGB's bad case there, she just said "Either you or Yos is scum, which is it?" and rather then question her flawed logic or anything, he just accepted her premise, waved his arms and said "It's not me!"

So, yes, I caught your scumbuddy. (It's amsuing how you first deny that I caught him, and then in the very same post accuse me of "bussing" him; isn't that a contradiction?)

Also, Camm, as I noted before, right after I made this post, you posted a long post, totally and completly ignoring the case I made against KMD, and instead just kept pushing for us to lynch Stark. You and Kmd did have a few little tiffs before then, but those look more like weak distancing then anything else.

stark. And you could argue Tar, too, but not near as hard.

Also, samhorn has been bus'ing camn. That's two players out of three that I believe are scum, going after camn when there is nothing at all suspicious about her, and there is no chance of camn being lynched. Do I ever smell distancing.

WOW. Add Yosarian to the list.

Camm's been my main suspect for some time now, pretty much since the moment KMD died, and I thought I'd been making that pretty clear...

[populartajo]

Now that I think about it, is there any reason why we should peg camn as town?