California Trilogy: City of Angels - On Camera (Game Over)

[ShadowLurker]

Oh no, Mr. Odbody and Mr. Locke are in conflict.

Kelly Garret pouts.

Think deeply, are any of you misrecalling?

[curiouskarmadog]

The one we should not choose (ie bad) is the one that does not come before the best choice in the alphabet.

Choices in alphabetically order.

Crone =A
Maiden =B
Mother =C

One is Bad, One is Good, One is Neutral

The note doesn’t help, can someone help me here, I am good at skinning boar, not critical thinking.

A Neutral
B Good
C Bad

Makes the statement true, the bad does not immediately come before the good.

A Good
B Bad
C Neutral

Makes the statement true, the bad does not immediately come before the good

A Bad
B Neutral
C Good

ALSO, makes the statement true, the bad does not immediately come before the good.


All three choices have an equal shot of being A,B, or C…what am I missing? There has got to be another part of this.

[curiouskarmadog]

cross post

[curiouskarmadog]

Kelly dear, I dont think you area understanding what I am saying...

ok, plugging in the Angel's help

[ShadowLurker]

Well I suppose the Truth Teller could be the Crone. In that case, the Liar does not come before the Crone, as there is nothing that comes before the Crone!

Mr. Locke, I have a minor point, does your note specify immediately before or simply before?

[curiouskarmadog]

If the Mother is not the bad choice.

Mother = B

The our choices are

A Bad
B Neutral
C Good

And

A Neutral
B Good
C Bad

am I doing this right?

Quote removed. Quote tags are not allowed. - Mod

[curiouskarmadog]

yes, but the paraphrased word I said was "instantly"..but your word was the word in the note.

[ShadowLurker]

I believe A could be Good, B Neutral, and C Bad as well.

[curiouskarmadog]

no wait, Madien is B.., Mother is C.

sooooo.....

If the Mother is not the bad choice.

Crone =A
Madien =B
Mother = C


The our choices are

A Bad
B Neutral
C Good

A Good
B Bad
C Neutral

A Neutral
B Good
C Bad

Someone else PLEASE back up my thinking here…

If the above is correct.

The Crone can be either Bad or Good
The Maiden can be either Neutral or Bad
And
The Mother can be either Good or Neutral

[ShadowLurker]

I see no flaws.

[StarKiss]

That's it.

[Thok]

Godwin looks a bit confused. His gun had disappeared, as did the prisoner he was carrying. And Death was nearby. "That can't be good" he thought.

I'm confused as to why Locke brought me here (even if he put me fifth): I'm pretty sure I mentioned that I didn't think it would be a good idea during the thread.

Based off of the above logic (which I agree with), if we trust the information elmo and CKD are giving us, then Mother would be best (no chance of bad, 50% chance of good) and Maiden would be worst. So it's a really question of how much we trust the information.

[ShadowLurker]

If the Mother turns out to mislead us, then we know that the Mother is not the only liar. Thus, I think the Mother is our best bet. After all, who wouldn't listen to their Mother?

[curiouskarmadog]

someone else double..triple check..

if all things are correct and taking what I and the Angel have been given as face value.

The Crone is a risky choice.
The Maiden should not be chosen
the Mother is the safe choice.

My gut tells me we should choose the Crone. However, if we chose the Mother and we get the bad choice, everyone then knows that either I or the Angel were lying or we were given bad info....I doubt that Mr Grey would give us bad info...like this anyway. So the Mother is probably the best choice....

Angel, do you know who gave you your note?

anyway, that is all fine and dandy.....but I think to make an informed decision, we should also consider the alignments of the dead..for obvious reasons.

waits for other to comment and maybe a message from our other friends.

[curiouskarmadog]

Godwin, out of the 9 people I had to choose from almost all said they didnt want to come here. I also was trying to balance the mix of who I trusted and didnt.

[StarKiss]

Angel, or Odbody?

[GoofballsAndBaloons]

Kkkkooooooobbbbeeeeee!

I miss you, you hunk for burning, shoot-guard'ing love... you asked me, "do you think about me?" The answer is a resounding 'yes' - I can do little else but think of you. Ever since that memorable dancing hippo spectacle when we feel in love, there is nothing on my mind but the virile contour of your regal African features, the tight but soft wrinkles of your lips, and the quivering of your eyes when you look into mine.

Around me, is nothing but a cast of tiresome, pedantic bores demanding that I make choices I care none about. I care for nothing but you, my one and only, and they are plotting to keep us apart. You're the only Evangelion I want to control, whatever Evangelions are, you're the copilot I dream of in Unit 02, and although my AT field, as described in Wikipedia, is the most powerful ever detected, strong enough to block out "light, magnetism, sub-atomic particles, everything" - my AT field does not have the strength to block out delicious thoughts of you.

Oh if only you could send me a sign...

Tabris collapses in a chair and begins to sob in what will surely be an Academy Award Best Crocodile Tears performance.

[elmosaurian]

I actually did not get a note. I looked upon the face of the mother, and I just knew that she could not be the bad choice.

[StarKiss]

Motherfu....

[curiouskarmadog]

isnt Odbody an angel?

(checking list)

oh..we have someone named Angel too...ha!

no that was directed to odd Odbody.

[StarKiss]

My spider sense is tingling.

[StarKiss]

Well, if Odbody is an angel as well, I suppose I could see how he believes Mother was telling the truth.... whatever it was she said.

[GoofballsAndBaloons]

Tabris spins on his angelic feet, with all the grace of a manga cartoon.

What's a crone anyway?

I don't trust anything that Mr Locke McSlop is saying.

The thought of Kobe Bryant's smelly sneakers enters Tabris' mind. Tabris welcomes the thought, and looks dreamily behind the ears of Locke McSlop.

[curiouskarmadog]

that hurts

[curiouskarmadog]

but I understand why.