The Dark Goma Mafia: Massacre of the Cloth (Game Over)

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Vote: tubby

[tubby216]

[qoute="volkan"]The question is (fairly simply):
What made you change your mind?

A change of opinion in this particular game without some reason for it is scummy. The fact that the other game is a year old is relevant, but 'd still like you to answer the above. [/quote]

ok agian reason for changing stance on millers,

I did not like how that game turned out with the miller claim, I also ran across millers in games offsite, i discuss the miller question at length with ofther mafia players and i feel currently we should lynch all millers.

[vollkan]

The question is (fairly simply):
What made you change your mind?

A change of opinion in this particular game without some reason for it is scummy. The fact that the other game is a year old is relevant, but 'd still like you to answer the above.

ok agian reason for changing stance on millers,

I did not like how that game turned out with the miller claim, I also ran across millers in games offsite, i discuss the miller question at length with ofther mafia players and i feel currently we should lynch all millers.

Long-winded but ultimately dodged my question*

In that game you thought lynching millers was bad. Here you think it is good. I want to know what theory reason changed your mind.

(*Also, because there is such a difference opinion on this issue, I am concerned that you are simply trying to, in effect, hide in the controversy)

[Benmage]

It's possible Sociopath is a non-Town RB. Right now I'm inclined to believe that he's Town and thought he caught scum in a lie.

Maybe hes one scum party thinking he caught a second.

unvote vote Kaleidoscope

forgot, hes still with us.

[Benmage]

Long-winded but ultimately dodged my question*

Ahah i love how ones answers are never satisfactory for vollkan.

I think he wants to recall whatever discussion you had revolving the issue. mind boggling.

[Vaya]

Because of him bread crumbing it earlier and it matching up with the info Plum had, I actually believe tubby's claim. I'd say both him and milkshake are town.

Unvote

Also, it seems more likely that SocioPath is a town RB'er who came forward believing he had caught scum in a lie than him being a scum RB'er in this situation.

@SocioPath
If you don't mind though, could you explain you're reason for RBing Plum? I think she seemed rather town Day 1.

[vollkan]

Long-winded but ultimately dodged my question*

Ahah i love how ones answers are never satisfactory for vollkan.

No. I've been satisfied by many answers in my time on site. I just don't accept subjective or evasive answers.

I think he wants to recall whatever discussion you had revolving the issue. mind boggling.

A year ago he opposed lynching.
Now he supports it.

If he is town, he must have some reason for supporting lynching.

Ergo, him telling us his reasoning for supporting lynching will explain his change of mind.

[DrippingGoofball]

[quote="KaleiÐoscøpe"]

Vote: tubby

[/quote]

OMG!!!

We caught ourselves a real scum! I'm sure players that have been following the game will see the light very quickly, as I have.

vote: KaleiÐoscøpe

[tubby216]

volkan,

you asked me why i changed my mind i answered that.

now if you want to know why i think lynching millers is a good idea thats a different question

[VP Baltar]

Holy rolefishing, you guys are crazy.

@SC-what do you mean more posts? I've been quite active this game. I went out last evening so couldn't be here for the four or so pages that were added, but I hope you aren't going to fault me for something like that.

I also still think your mass claim idea is bad today, btw. It allows scum to game the setup far too much, especially if there is only one scum team. *insert chimp call*

Also, it seems more likely that SocioPath is a town RB'er who came forward believing he had caught scum in a lie than him being a scum RB'er in this situation.

I don't necessarily agree with this. Scum RBs are far more common and often claim they are town RBs so they don't have to fake their results. The fact that he claims to have blocked Plum gives me serious pause. I would like to hear his reasoning as well for picking her because that makes no sense to me from a town perspective.

Benmage is still a good lynch today.

Unvote, Vote: Benmage

Also, I hate pretty much everything Sajin posts, and K-scope's and dramonic's votes confuses the hell out of me after everything that happened.

[vollkan]

volkan,

you asked me why i changed my mind i answered that.

now if you want to know why i think lynching millers is a good idea thats a different question

Fine. Then why do you now think lynching millers is a good idea?

[SerialClergyman]

@SC-what do you mean more posts? I've been quite active this game. I went out last evening so couldn't be here for the four or so pages that were added, but I hope you aren't going to fault me for something like that.

Don't worry, I'm not having a go at you, I just don't have a read on your alignment yet, and I like you and you're a good player, so if you post more then I might be able to take a guess and be happier listening to you

As for massclaim - would have totally sorted out all the tubby + plum + SP nonsense, plus the inevitable nonsense that's likely to come from having so many roles... very tempting... I'll throw in a limerick... There once was a man called Serial...

[Papa Zito]

[quote="DrippingGoofball"][quote="KaleiÐoscøpe"]

Vote: tubby

[/quote]

OMG!!!

We caught ourselves a real scum! I'm sure players that have been following the game will see the light very quickly, as I have.

vote: KaleiÐoscøpe

[/quote]
Oh FFS. I've been trying to get people to kill scope all day.

DGB, stop trying to derail wagons kthx. Also, why would you jump on the same wagon as Benmage?

I mean, really. This game.

[DrippingGoofball]

DGB, stop trying to derail wagons kthx. Also, why would you jump on the same wagon as Benmage.

I approve of bus'ing and like to reward it when I see it.

[Elmo]

I mean, really. This game.

Yeah, tell me about it.

No, really, tell me about this game.

[curiouskarmadog]

Official Vote Count (Page 75, Day 2)

tubby216

-5 (stark, Sajin, Snow_Bunny, dramonic, KaleiÐoscøpe)
Benmage -5 (vollkan, SerialClergyman, SpyreX, Papa Zito, VP Baltar)
KaleiÐoscøpe -2 (Benmage, DrippingGoofball)
DrippingGoofball -1 (tubby216)
Spyrex -1 (Battle Mage)
dramonic -1 (chamber)
Plum -1 (SocioPath)

Not Voting:

Elmo, Kise, Plum, milkshake, LlamaFluff, Vaya

Note: Deadline will be at the earliest, 10/30 3:45 PM EST, with 23 whole votes available, it takes 12 to lynch.

[VP Baltar]

Don't worry, I'm not having a go at you, I just don't have a read on your alignment yet, and I like you and you're a good player, so if you post more then I might be able to take a guess and be happier listening to you

Yeah, I didn't feel like you were attacking me or anything. Just saying I probably won't be posting any more frequently than I am. If there is something specific you'd like me to comment on to help your read, feel free to ask.

As for massclaim - would have totally sorted out all the tubby + plum + SP nonsense, plus the inevitable nonsense that's likely to come from having so many roles... very tempting...

Well, that is true, but it was sorted out anyhow as is without outing every single role in the game first. I'm sure there is plenty nonsense to come, and I can understand where you are coming from, but I still think the cons outweigh the pros even if the mechanics here are different from your standard game.

And I'm all for limmericks. ...who liked to put the fear in all...

[Papa Zito]

I mean, really. This game.

Yeah, tell me about it.

No, really, tell me about this game.

Most fragmented town evar?

[Elmo]

Which fragments and over what issue(s), Commander Hayes?

[DrippingGoofball]

I just realized something.

Kscope, who clearly isn't paying attention to anything at all and is therefore scum, voted for tubby, when Benmage was one vote behind tubby. Therefore, Kscope isn't scum with tubby, he's scum with Benmage whose keister he just tried to save.

vote: Benmage

[DrippingGoofball]

Which fragments and over what issue(s), Commander Hayes?

Just vote Benmage already.

[Elmo]

Wasn't I supposed to be scum? Why am I bussing here? Why is Benmade bussing Scope?

Do you think I can play an entire game only in questions?

[Papa Zito]

Which fragments and over what issue(s), Commander Hayes?

You've already had two sentences, otherwise the try would have been epic.

This town gets distracted by every little shiny that comes along. It's maddening.

[SerialClergyman]

...his avatar was cute
but discussion was moot
because the proof he was right was empirical?

I think I might have had a rhyming stretch there.

Benmage, would you like to revise your claim, or are you happy claiming VT?

[SerialClergyman]

Also - I gave you the limmerick when we didn't massclaim!! Dammit.