Mad World: Time Travel Mafia (Game Over)

[Robbnva]

Ok. What the #%$&. Who are we lynching?

Pick somebody. Preferably whoever will give us the most info.

Not LMP though.

LMP I still don't think you've answered my question.

still waiting for you to actually start playing this game, why don't you start playing, read up and give some advice instead of posting random garbage and getting upset when people don't take your questions seriously

[KageLord]

kage, do you take Shark's word for his claim?

I believe that Shark is a redirector, but not necessarily that his alignment is town. I suppose I'll have a look at him in ISO and then see what alignment comes to mind.

[SharkFinn]

Mafuyu and LMP are the two scummiest players imo. LMP/Tasky was before he subbed in and after. I want one of them lynched today. I was hoping to get a Mafuyu claim, but someone unvoted before I could get one >_<

[ReaperCharlie]

Ok. What the #%$&. Who are we lynching?

Pick somebody. Preferably whoever will give us the most info.

Not LMP though.

LMP I still don't think you've answered my question.

still waiting for you to actually start playing this game, why don't you start playing, read up and give some advice instead of posting random garbage and getting upset when people don't take your questions seriously

i c wut u did thar chainsaw defense.

Now shut up and stop trying to critique my play.

And LMP, answer my question.

[Robbnva]

not chainsaw defense, just posting facts

I don't need any defense

[LimMePls]

RC, I'm guessing these are the questions you want answered. I missed them somehow. Here are my answers:

LMP please refresh my memory, did SharkFinn claim his power role BEFORE the possibility that he was blocked?

And just because he's got a claimed ability does not mean he's got a proven alignment. I've seen plenty of scum redirectors, and only remember seeing a town one once (and that was in a Smalltown game).

I think it's pretty convenient that all the people you (or Tasky) have investigated so far have turned out to be dead people. That seems too convenient and I don't like it. I've seen scum do that more often than not, just to make their claim sound believable.

If you're not lynched, who do you plan to investigate tonight, LMP?

Your answer had better be what I hope it is. And if that person dies, you WILL be lynched tomorrow, no matter how much you whine and twist and squeal.

As for SF claiming before the possibility he was blocked, I have no idea what you mean. He claimed that he redirected me to Robbnva. Whether or not he was RB'd I have no idea. Please clarify what you mean with this question.

I think SF is scum redirector. Look at my vote. We're in agreement there. Did you guys see how quickly he unvoted me after the cop claim, and then how opportunistically he jumped back on when other town players said they didn't buy the claim? That is scummy as hell. Add the mountain of other scum things he's done this game, plus the fact that if he is scum then I'm pretty much worthless this game, and I think he needs to go.

You can call it convenient if you'd like, I can't help that is how it has turned out. If it is a reason for you to disbelieve my claim, then so be it, but I can only tell you who I've targeted, I can't help that they ended up dead.

As for who I'm targeting, are you sure you want the scum to know that? If everyone thinks its a good idea for me to claim this I will, but I'm not sure its a good idea. I've never played cop before, so I have no idea if claimed cops ever tell who they plan to investigate, but it seems like a bad idea.

[curiouskarmadog]

was driving around thinking about this game, have another thought in LMP favor...

1.) we have a miller....which most of the time means we have a cop
2.) there is no cop counter claim.

[Robbnva]

was driving around thinking about this game, have another thought in LMP favor...

1.) we have a miller....which most of the time means we have a cop
2.) there is no cop counter claim.

really, you just thought of that today?

[SharkFinn]

CKD: Can we lynch Mafuyu then, if not LMP. I dont like either player at the moment. And a lynch is good when I have a 100% chance of hitting scum between Mafuyu and LMP.

[Robbnva]

so u and ckd are buddies now?

[Mafuyu]

Mafuyu and LMP are the two scummiest players imo. LMP/Tasky was before he subbed in and after. I want one of them lynched today. I was hoping to get a Mafuyu claim, but someone unvoted before I could get one >_<

Mafuyu wouldn't claim at L-2 as it stands.

100% is never 100% just because you think that one of the two has to be scum. Is it really necessary to add emphasis to your read?

[crypto]

Notes (pp. 1–14)

8. Seraphim: Town—reassessing, changing vote.
9. Tasky: Garbage.
26. Tasky: More garbage. No response to criticism.
30. ReaperCharlie: Fail.
37–38. Seraphim: Town.
42. Youngminii: Stops using meta because someone objects? Survivalist?
47. Curiouskarmadog: Rawr—looks town.
49. Diginova: What a guy!
53. Anon: Mega town. Why you gotta be dead? Need to read back to see who opposed Anon. He was such obvious town it might've been scum trying to get rid of him.
55. ReaperCharlie: Why you gotta be lame (relatively speaking)?
60. Diginova: What's wrong with a player being three away from a lynch on day one?
62. Youngminii: Scummy. Poor guy. Hope he isn't really so impressionable.
67. SharkFinn: Good stuff. Also, argument with Karma looks like town versus scum in light of Karma's flip.
72. CallMeLiam: QFT.
81. Zang: Toying with calling this a town tell.
82. Curiouskarmadog: Town.
90. Diginova: Comprends pas.
104. ReaperCharlie: Still zero analysis. Odd that you only consider 103 at face value, which I'd think you wouldn't do if you were remotely invested in scum hunting. Scummy.
116. Diginova: "Semantics" can be a great way to catch scum.
121. SharkFinn: So town.
124. Curiouskarmadog: ILY.
128. Tasky: Anger is not "a sign that you have no arguments left." Way, way off here. I don't even know where you could get this idea. Scummy.
129. SharkFinn: Hmm . . .
143. MagnaofIllusion: Fate's pro, kthx.
162. ReaperCharlie: Where's that promised content, yo?
166. SharkFinn: Reap is the only person you're concerned with? Huh.
180. Tasky: There's an alignment tell in here. I know it. Goddamn.
210. Diginova: Sarcasm is not a scum tell. I wish you people would get this. Furthermore, gut feelings are a great way to scum-hunt. Fail on all counts.
223. SharkFinn: Cue headache.
232. Alpha Werewolf: Wow. Nice sideways potshot. Maybe Shark is town after all.
234. ReaperCharlie: Scum.
235. Tasky: GODDAMN ELLIPSES. STOP.
263. Tasky: Why an FOS instead of a vote?
275. Tasky: If scum then probably not on the same team as Karma. Weird wagon switch. Need to reexamine this at some point.
283. Diginova: My Scumdar 9000 disapproves.
295. Alpha Werewolf: Null read on Tasky with no elaboration. Huh.

Reads (pp. 1–14)

Town

curiouskarmadog
Seraphim
SharkFinn
Zang
Empking
youngminii
Tasky
ReaperCharlie
diginova

Scum

[crypto]

so u and ckd are buddies now?

Scummy.

[ReaperCharlie]

I'm not scum crypto. Let's make an alliance with ckd though, I'm liking him.

[crypto]

From what I've seen you haven't done much to make you worth an alliance.

[ReaperCharlie]

Things will change when the alliance is forged.

Given that you help lynch scum today, that is.

[crypto]

Stop posturing.

[KageLord]

CKD: Can we lynch Mafuyu then, if not LMP. I dont like either player at the moment. And a lynch is good when I have a 100% chance of hitting scum between Mafuyu and LMP.

Why do you say "100%"? Is there a reason that you find it absolutely impossible that both are town?

[SharkFinn]

Either A: Mafuyu is opportunistic scum or B: Both are coordinating scum. See the votes on KL. Mafuyu's was 100% scummy.

[Robbnva]

so u and ckd are buddies now?

Scummy.

you really mean to tell me that comment to ckd wasn't scummy?

[Mafuyu]

Either A: Mafuyu is opportunistic scum or B: Both are coordinating scum. See the votes on KL. Mafuyu's was 100% scummy.

So you believe there isn't a single situation, at all, where Mafuyu could be town? Gee, what about the easiest counterpoints possible? Lazytown. Lurkertown. VI. The scum counterparts of those three. Third-party. You're missing out on a lot of options here.

[curiouskarmadog]

still rereading.

[Robbnva]

Mayfu, seriously no need to talk in 3rd person

but on a lighter note, I once crash landed on a deserted island and forged a friendship with Wilson, he wants to play so from now on Wilson will be playing for me.

Wilson needs to re-read and post his thoughts

[diginova]

Reading and will have my thoughts on D3 shortly, so I can actually be more of a contributor and less dead weight. Given up on getting access to my work computer, so I'll just re-write everything.

Two quick things:

1) Mafuyu, your 920 is horrible.

So you believe there isn't a single situation, at all, where Mafuyu could be town? Gee, what about the easiest counterpoints possible? Lazytown. Lurkertown. VI. The scum counterparts of those three. Third-party. You're missing out on a lot of options here.

'
How are any of those useful to the game as a whole? Scum counterparts are obviously scum. Third-party is good to lynch to get them out of the game, as they have other goals besides killing all the scum. VI is completely useless, and lazytown and lurkertown are almost as useless (hello, RC)
The $100,000 question, as you have still not explained your vote on LMP in 841, only stating that you hadn't expressed suspicion of a majority of players:

What were your reasons for voting lynchmepls in 841? You placed an L-1 vote on him, which means you definitely wanted to see him lynched. Specific examples, please.

2) Crypto: What is your opinion on I doubt it's playstyle before you replaced in? Do you think he was beneficial or not to us finding and lynching the remaining scum?

[Robbnva]

Wilson agrees mayfu is suspicious but stands by the vote for empking

Wilson is also skeptical of the RC & SF alliance, especially since the strong possibility of SF's redirector role is a anti-town