Reaper - Reaper probably needs to die, eventually. Yes he's been investigated and found not scum, but his play as been so poor lately that I'm thinking he was a likely night 1 recruit. His push on Ooba is poor, it's really poor. I get it he wants Ooba lynched, but I don't think he's that stupid that he can't see when he's tunnelling badly. His flip-flop on me with no reason is also incredible - notice his position on me late day 1- he iso's me and says he doesn't think I'm scummy. Yet day 2 when a I get a few votes he's quite quick to softly support the wagon
1447,
1483 he comes back around. In fact I've no idea what happened to this either:
Reaper in 1515 wrote:
Chronopie is a tantalizing second target for me; for now I'd rather stick with ooba though.
Which is fair enough.
But when he votes me, Chronopie his second suspect has 3 votes, which ya know isn't fucking exactly hopeless either? In fact he doesn't even mention Chronopie when he votes me, he mentions the ooba wagon but it looks like his suspicioun of Chronopie is feigned, I think that could possibly indicate some sort of attempt to distance here.
I'm not sure on Reaper, I think there's a very good chance that he's been recruited all in all.
SingerSigner:
TheLonging I'll iso later but singer's been scummy enough in her own right.
I mentioned earlier, that I think iso'ing your predecessor as a townie seems unneccessary, it's certainly only something I do as scum, and yeah Amished tell variation here.
Ooba's claim being the same as hers makes her suspicious for some reason. Seriously? What do you think the chances are of Ooba managing to guess the role.
Singer wrote:
I don't think Chrono is the lynch for today. Depending on what happens in the meantime, he might be tomorrow, but I think Ooba's either lying scum, or he was recruited, so he should be the lynch for today.
This makes NO FUCKING SENSE. Lying about what? I thought the case involved him being a recruiter, hence the failed investigation. None of this makes any sense and it looks like you're jumping on the bandwagon.
I agree with the case on Faraday. It may not be the strongest, but we're not going anywhere else. There's information to be gotten from every lynch, and I feel as though it's about time to get info from this one. If no one objects (formality), I'm ready to hammer.
Are you looking for an out tomorrow by saying the case wasn't the strongest? What particular parts of the case on me do you agree with, specifically Me=W, Yos2 and Prozac are the only ones to have posted reasoning (Iirc) so which of their posts convinced you? Especially considering :
What's this wagon on faraday?
To me indicated you disagreed with the wagon on me? Correct me if I'm wrong here though, as I guess it's kinda ambigious either way.
Either way, if we've got a scum loose cannon it's probably here I'd bet.
Inhim
looks pretty town, his Iso isn't great but I don't really disagree with a lot of what he's been saying. I don't agree with his points re: me, but then I wouldn't would I? I think there's a fair chance he's town at this point and one of the few I'm reasonably confident in saying this about too.
Friend
looked remarkably town day 1, less so day 2 but I think he's still probably town. I admit I'm slightly biased towards thinking playstyles like Jack's, and in this particular game Inhim and Friend look town. I generally find it pretty hard to articulate town reads anyway, but I can't really see scumfriend here day 2. He seems bored of day 2, althogh going a day to get flips and stuff isn't as useful here, it's a cult game. So yeah.
Vezok's
town for the soft claim nonsense that went on really early. He's horribly anti town regardless of alignment anyway but I think he looks a town, anti town here if you understand me. I have some meta on him as town and he seems similar here although it's hard to tell, admittedly I'd lean town on him. Oh he was replaced by robocopter who's spent the whole time he's been here complaining/not doing anything. Gl with that.
Andrius
is prob town, look at the early day 1 where he calls reaper town repeatedly for no good reason, it makes so much sense as a cop investigation and very very little sense as anything else.
Xvart
- Xvart's play has been okay I guess, but I've modded him 3 times now, twice as town and once as scum and he looks so much like his scum self here after a re-read in iso. Total gut feel here, but usually when he's town I can spot him quite quickly (see lay of leithian) but here he's just there for me and it's worrying. He's also pretty much ignored my bandwagon for the most part, and there's something about his interactions with Yos2 that I don't like either. I think there's a good chance he's a recruiter who recruited Yos2.
Yos2
- Nothing I can really pin on him again, he's very capable of being logical and posting cases as scum, I don't really like that he never commented on my supposed scumminess day 1, it just seems odd that he never so much as mentioned me untill a wagon started on me (that may not be actually 100% true, but you get the idea.
Ani/BBM (w/ prozac)- I think there's a decent chance he's a recruiter who recruited prozac night 1 based on the way day 2 has gone. Prozac was all over Ani day 1, like a fucking rash. Look at the differences in the way he's gone after ani day 1 (for useless posting) and the way he's attacking me, the difference is pretty noticable IMO. He's also ignored Ani for day 2, someone who seemed to be one of his top scum reads for day 1. I think there's a really, really fucking good chance Prozac's recruited, and my top pick for recruiter for him would be Ani. It also fits in what I think Ani would do (recruit someone who's attacking him). BBM's catch up post doesn't help either, no idea why his top town reads are who they are but yeah.
Seraphim read really town. Me-weird's case seems a nulltell (in so far as he's made that style of case in a few of his games and he's not scum everytime). Gonna go with town here, I think Seratown more likely to replace because of Vezok. Plus there was abn earlier comment about scumgroups that I read as genuine.
Gurgi's been lazy as fuck, he's done little to no scumhunting from what I can see, although it seems a general 'fucked up with mafia' vibe from his posts, I don't think that's an alignment tell either way. His jump on my wagon wasn't too bad, no reasons given but there's nothing really wrong with that. Bleh he's pretty neutral I guess, my gut kinda says town on him at the moment even though he's done absolutely nothing.
Erg0 - Townish. Seems to be scumhunting and I've no real problems with him, day 2 looks even better although I feel we could do with more of him ITT. I think that's everyone?
Gandalf I've no idea how to read. Looks scummy regardless of alignment to me, so you're on your own with that.
Chronopie's possible scum for doing nothing but softclaiming all fucking game. DIE DIE DIE DIE DIE.
Well that's about it, probably not very useful but whatever. Reaper's the guy I'm on the fence about most in all that. Xvart has a decent chance of being scum, Prozac and BBM do too although Prozac's probably a recruit if anything.
)
Faraday (Yosarian2, Chronopie, inHimshallibe, Me=Weird, ReaperCharlie, ooba, Porochaz)
