Regarding hitogoroshi's insanities disapporval list:
It's a very good list. Those are insanities that as town, I do not want to take nor do I want the rest of the town to take either. I also would favor the ban of choosing Distractions. Some people have a habit of semi-frequently changing votes. If they have this insanity and desired to vote that player they really want to lynch, but can't because they unvoted that player already, it prevents them from being able to pressure their top suspect and force them to vote if they are absolutely confident or maybe not at al. If everyone but two players had this insanity and could not make a majority for a lynch, we would get a no lynch even without requesting it or reaching deadline and we don't want that to happen. I would definently be in favor of making this a forbidden insaity. Severe restrictions, although not complete ban, of the necrophillia insanity would also be a good idea as we should restrict that to 1-4 people max that we can trust to rob graves nightly.
As for sanities I approve of using, I would say if and when you gain insanities, you should choose these as first choices:
Twitchy: All you do is twitch for one post, nothing major.
Complusion: It removes blood off you anyway so you can use the actions that you have. Somewhat beneficial IMO.
Not really seeing why AurorusVox is scummy. From what I've seen, it resembles more of a townie. He's been contributing a lot and I like how he's been outspoken about his defenses and opinions on other people. Will re-read him more closely in ISO thought to see if I can see the case on him.
@Bowser: Do you have any suspects yet? It seems as you don't have any suspects when you declared the Fate/Benmage interaction as null and called Furcolow's a mixup.
@Benmage: Something I forgot to note in my big post. Yesterday, you said that you were glad to not be in a cult with Fate. Since you believe yourself to be town, that automatically means that Fate is cult. You are neglecting the possibility of both you and Fate being town. That's like if I said I was town therefore Seacore is cult, that logic makes no sense. Your you-town therefore Fate is cult theory makese as much sense as formentioned scenario.
You claim to be a confirmed townie. If you were cult and Fate was town, would you still be pushing for Fate's lynch and would you still claim that you'll be stalking him tonight?
Benmage wrote:@ssbf another whose Epiphany should be easiest ....you of all people should know my history of fate. You should have one of the best town reads on me. You can piss and moan about my actions and me immature and anything you'd like, but to suggest anything other than I am town.....would be atrocious play.
You are not obvious/confirmed town to us. Your play in this game resembles more of that of a cult, what town needs to get rid of. I haven't seen any evidence that supports you at confirmed town and as others have said, you saying you stalked Fate does not mean that you are confirmed town. Even if at least two kills gets through tonight with Fate being one of those NK's, it does not confirm you as town. Will it point you as likely town for Day 2? Yes it does, but saying that you'll be clear with a Fate + another person's kill Night 1 is a stretch. And even if if you were confirmed town Day 2, you wouldn't be on later days due to the possibility of you being a muderer.
Benmage wrote:Comments now seen more than once....me qft that me v fate is ruining the game. No fucking shit. I knew this was gonna happen. It happens in every game I play with him. Why do you think I nearly replaced out of the signup thread. Yet did ask fate nicely to pass on this game... Shittttt.....happy I stayed VPB? I called this from the getgo.
This wouldn't have happened had you actually explained why you found Fate scummy instead of making a terrible mask of a policy lynch by saying he's "cult" to substitute "policy lynch". And like I said, you brought this upon yourself.
Benmage wrote:Unvote vote baby spice
Nice opportunistic vote on baby spice. I can see cult here trying to blend in with the crowd knowing that Fate will likely not be the lynch.
ReaperCharlie wrote:1. Yes, it's an off chance that furc is scum.
2. You acknowledge that off chance.
3. You vote for furc ANYWAY. lolwut.
Going out to Wickedestjr as well (Since his call on me is similar to ReaperCharlie's). Should have edited off the "There is an off-chance that Furcolow is scum" part. That error is probably there because I managed to somehow get ample enough time to get caught up on the school computer and post this while still be updated. Waiting until the afternoon would be a bad idea as I would have to worry about catching up on 200+ posts instead of just 80+ posts. Basically, I wanted to get it done in school so I wouldn't have to stay on the computer all day just to catch up on this game like yesterday, hence the contradiction.
ReaperCharlie wrote:4. My vote on Seacore is awesome and pro-town and the fact that Seacore ignored it is basically proof that I'm right. He prefers to focus on ... other things, and suck up to the people that think he's town, for some crazy reason.
I read the quote again that caused you to vote Seacore, not seeing how that makes him cult or town. Also a person ignoring your case doesn't always mean you're right, it could because they find the case to suck to where responding would be pointless.
ReaperCharlie wrote:5. WHO are you calling out for posting fluff? ME???? over 5-10 other people that are posting NO CONTENT WHATSOEVER but are WASTING AWAY THE PAGES WITH A SELF-CENTERED WAR OF BATTLING EGOS?. *is baffled*
People who have posted minimal contents so far:
Bowser
El Goosuki
Wingless
Could only find three people who have produced minimal contents in these games as of now. Also, while the flame war was uncalled for, it at least gave us something to work on.
I was not calling you out for posting fluff in general, just that from what I see, your #298 is almost completely useless. It was full of fluff, added little to scum hunting, and overall, seems like a post that should not have been in the game but rather severely modified.
ReaperCharlie wrote:6. Nice lining-up-lynches with me and furcolow. Anti-town at best, pure scummy at worst.
I am not lining-up-lynches. What I said was to consider one of you/furcolow for the lynch if one of you two flips cult. Me lining-up-lynches would be "Lynch Furcolow today, ReaperCharlie tomorrow!". These two things are different.
ReaperCharlie wrote:7. WHAT SUSPICION ON HITOROGOSHI? I HAVE REPEATEDLY SAID THAT HE IS AWESOME AND PRO-TOWN AND HAVE AGREED WITH NEARLY EVERY POST HE'S MADE! Oh wait... you must be talking about my post #302... OH WAIT I F@#%&ING EBWOP'D IT LIKE 5 SECONDS LATER IN THE VERY NEXT POST.
Okay, I'll give you that on Hitorogoshi. That being said, I'd like to hear your reasons for suspecting Feysal (I don't see how Feysal is tunneling.).
ReaperCharlie wrote:I.E. THIS IS YOU TRYING TO FIND EVERY POSSIBLE THING YOU CAN ADD INTO A CASE ABOUT ME, BUT MISSING THE FOREST FOR THE TREES BECAUSE YOU'RE NOT ACTUALLY LOOKING FOR SCUM ANYWAY, YOU'RE JUST TRYING TO GET A MISLYNCH.
I add a lot into my cases because I want people to actually give that particular person a second look and get convinced that the person is scum so we can lynch scum. Granted quantity =/= quality, but adding seven good points to a case is more likely to convince a person that Player A is scum then a case with just one good thing to add.
ReaperCharlie wrote:SSBF, can you explain why oh why you are ACTUALLY 'suspicious' of me, other than because your idol Magna said he was?
If so, please throw me in the fire and test my mettle. Don't be afraid to ask me questions, refine me a little bit. Go ahead... come on. I want you to.
I've already explained my case on you and why I think you are scummy. I will expand on that if I find further actions to be scummy. Only other thing I need to do is to convince other people that you're scum.
ReaperCharlie wrote:Hmmm... how about cause I said so?
1. He is scum
2. We lynch him
3. ?????
4. Profit!
It's not easy as that. Before we lynch scum, we have to prove or at least show strong convincing evidence that the person we're pushing for is indeed scum. Your case on Seacore has very little substance and doesn't really point me toward him being scum.
ReaperCharlie wrote:^lol Benmage
Your vote on Baby Spice really wasn't any better.
Andrius wrote:Also, what do you think of my argument that Benmage is town?
Not really a fan of it. Benmage can still be cult that can attempt to convince his cult partners that they need to kill Fate tonight to confirm him as town and hope that there are multiple deaths tonight. I'm not saying he is definently cult, but I haven't like his play so far at all and even with his claim that he stalked Fate and will be killing him tonight, I am open up to the possibility of Benmage-cult trying to get rid of Fate for town creds if Fate isn't lynched today. Also you say that Benmage would not be putting himself out there as cult, I disagree. Given his history with Fate, I wouldn't be surprised if he pushed for his lynch regardless of alignment.
El Goosuki wrote:lolzKatsubesofunny.
Summary from somebody plz?
kthx.
I'm not giving you a summary of the game. A summary tends to be bias and do not give you the full information you need to scum hunt. The only way to achieve that is by reading the entire thread. Yes it's a lot to read, but it's a lot better then hearing it from a bias view.
Unvote
As much as I want to lynch Furcolow due to his scummy behavior, the ward evidences pointed out by AurorusVox/The Lost Butterfly/Trilobite are too damning to ignore, which points to him being town. Although I'll be watching him extremely closely, based off what have happened regarding the claims, Furcolow is not a viable lynch candidate today.
My top three suspicions are Benmage/ReaperCharlie/Bowser in no specific order. One of those three I will be voting (Barring any incredible scumminess from someone else).
As for my fourth suspicion? Possibly El Goosuki. Remembering what I saw from DrippingGoofball/Ellibereth in A Clash of Kings, they seems to be a lot more motivated and a lot more engaged in scum hunting. While it is still unorthodox, at least I was getting pro-town vibes from them.
This game, not so much. Next to no contents have been produced from them for the first thirteen posts, which definently is not giving me good vibes. Only positive thing we got from the hydra with the first thirteen posts was that they heard noise, which supposedly makes Furcolow likely town. The rest either parrots what others have to say on a particular subject (ISO: 9) or completely contentless. Which makes them hypocritical when they called Fate out for caps posts being contentless in the same post, yet they gave us very little to work with. I find ISO 18 to be a weak defense in their behalf. We finally see some results from the hydra in ISO: 13, but the posts still give me scummy vibes, although this is more of a gut feeling.