I see what Elmo was on about though, I've used that same argument in various forms myself. He mentions False Dichotomy in on his post (Benmage vs. I Am Innocent I believe) and the technical term(I think) for what I used on RC was False Dilemma, basically giving a range of reasons that either point to the player being incompetent or scum: All bad, none good. My answer to that is that I generally don't give a player the acceptable answer in the post I vote them for. Which was all right as Red showed he was perfectly able to get it on his own. I'll argue with the "trying to sound impressive...." part though. See above.
This I bugs me so I'ma say something about it.
First off, the vote on Red wasn't stretching. He even acknowledges that. This is Mafia, the way it is setup almost requires you to vote (or at least say something) when someone posts something that isn't true.Dry-fit wrote:..
unvote. Vote: Oso. He's put far too much effort into analyzing the votes on him. I also agree that his attack on Red is stretching.
Second, now Dry-fit is the one who is stretching. I have posted a defense against Elmo and IaI's votes against me here. It holds almost no analysis except for the part where I say I might have drawn IaI's vote because following the RC/Percy player chain of votes on Sotty7 for questioning IaI backwards, leads right back to IaI. The main thrust of that post was to to get out Point A.
in order to show exactly how weak both Elmo's and IaI's votes were. Not really needed at this point in the game since it was only two votes but like I stated, I had the time.Oso wrote:..
A - I chose to vote someone who verifiably said something that wasn't true.
..
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Dry-Fit
[/inb4 OMGUS] Unlike Elmo, who efforts seems to me right now as being legitimate, and IaI, who seems to have to have been starting meltdown mode during the time he voted, Dry-Fit is legitimately scummy trying to build a case on a player by using another player's reason that had no legs to start with and by adding one of his own that fails when you look at it closely.
I missed about a day and half of posts and will miss most of today's before being able to anything other than a skim catch up but I can live with this vote for the time being.
