Why, something wrong with it? I researched the top wagons, and after I finished, I found I had lost confidence in those cases, particularly the one on MoI. I thought of an alternative, and voted Baby Spice. Or perhaps you wanted a more thorough explanation of the case on her? Here it is, I just did another ISO read.Trilobite #2336 wrote:For someone that is so careful with his vote Feysal's explanation for his Babyspice vote looks really bad. He is really climbing the scum list with this.
As said, the original reason for the wagon on Baby Spice was her confusion in calling Benmage town and anti-town. Her explanation was that Benmage was likely an investigator, but playing in an anti-town manner, which sounds plausible. I said this much in my first ISO of her.
Much more suspicious is the fact that both Baby Spice and xvart claimed to have warded MoI. It could happen, but it is also a possible false claim for the cult. Originally I thought xvart was more suspect, but my opinion of him has improved since. Baby Spice was the first to claim, but she could have known MoI had been warded due to the failure of a craft fetish action, so she could still be cult.
I also found something new to add to the case. When nopoint and I claimed to have resuscitated Wickedestjr, Plum asked for our reasons. This gave me the idea of checking why Baby Spice and xvart chose MoI.
Baby Spice #308 wrote:I also warded. Chose MoI basically at random since I have played with virtually no one here...
I've never played with MoI before, apart from another game which started shortly before this one, but I've understood he is considered a strong player. xvart choosing to ward him based on his abilities makes sense. But Baby Spice claimed to have chosen him at random. Given that there were only 8 potential targets needing to be resuscitated, and probably several people with res kits, I can believe nopoint and me picking the same target. But with 27 potential ward targets and only 4 people who claimed wards, the odds of picking the same person are considerably lower. If Baby Spice had chosen MoI based on experience with his play, I might believe it. But choosing the same player at random is an awfully convenient coincidence.xvart #603 wrote:I warded MoIbecause of his play and smarts in aCoK large theme, and his thought/thinking in that game, which would be beneficial in this game due to the complexities.
Other than that, Baby Spice tunneled on Furcolow for much of day 1, and was the last to unvote him. To be fair, her being the last may not mean that much, since she was away at the time. In the last vote count before she posted her V/LA Furcolow had 6 votes. The next day she was the only one left. What is suspicious that when she came back, she suddenly changed her opinion of Furcolow, deciding he was being a VI, which most others had realized long ago. That was pointed out by some players, and it does look like she was looking for a way out of a failed wagon.
Since then, there is nothing really remarkable about Baby Spice's posts. There is some discussion of game mechanics, she supported RC's case on xvart, and commented on game events for most of today.
Overall, this is certainly the strongest case I have at this time, and I like my vote where it is, for now. I can switch to avoid a no lynch, but I am not too sure about any of our current top wagons.
