SpyreX wrote:OR, get this, Benmage is, like he's always been, going for murderer and making stuff up.
What am I making up? I'm bloody. You're bloody. I tried to kill you. I'm going to launder tonight. When Am I gonna be murderer? D20?
Noone is claiming rezz on you.
Why has SpyreX not be strung up yet?
xvart wrote:Yo Benmage - you never answered why you specifically wanted to rob Fate's grave.
xvart.
Pretty sure I did. Pretty sure I wanted to see if he had cult books. But I never made it mandatory for me to do so. Just that if possible I would've liked to. I didn't think it a major, because if the night actions went correctly, noone would've gotten gear.
Baby Spice wrote:Benmage. Since we're still waiting for all the claims, why did you suspect Spyre of being a cultist?
Do I have to? It's obvious I'm town playing towards the town WC. But his play didn't resemble town SpyreX. Moreover he wanted me dead. Plus all D1 despite ignoring me when I said I was killing Fate no questions he asked, he never bothered with me until the very end where there appeared some support to kill me. And he called for my death despite thinking me town. But again, his play really doesn't remind me of the strong town SpyreX i know... I don't feel like he's sunk his teeth into this game to get town to do the rights things. I think hes coating a bit too much.
Seacore wrote:
I've had a brief readthrough,
El G should probably not be the lynch today. Instead, we should commission somebody to murder them. All three should be absolutely ashamed of their play, but I think they're less likely scum at this point.
I concur.
We should nominate a nonlikely murder, likely cult to do the job.
Seacore wrote:Actually, Spyrex, fair call. Put me on board with the El G lynch. I just can't shake this feeling that they aren't scum, just a three headed village idiot.
One who's parents are siblings.
But logically, you're right, we shouldn't give them a walk for this.
Give me a day or two, (life days, not game days) I'll vote for them when I get back home.
Uhm... SpyreX is a way better lynch. Plus we can confirm someone and get em killed with the murder plan.
VP Baltar wrote:xvart wrote:Yes. I remember. My blood lust overcame me. But now I'm in a pickle after all the investigator flips because I don't think it is the town's best interest for me to kill my target.
I really hate this frankly. It's the perfect cult claim for gaining an insanity. "I stalked, but now I've come to my senses and won't be killing tonight. Sorry about the mess up guys." Perfect way to hide the ritual.
This resonates with me.
VP Baltar wrote:
Seacore wrote:El G should probably not be the lynch today. Instead, we should commission somebody to murder them. All three should be absolutely ashamed of their play, but I think they're less likely scum at this point.
Depending on what happens with Spyrex here, El G definitely should be the lynch today. Publically declaring they should be murdered is not going to work for a number of reasons. 1) you need to assign a murderer to them, which the cult can just kill. If you don't do this, you'll either have no one stalking or you'll have multiple targets stalking. 2) The cult can just ward El G to prevent the stalk tonight 3) The cult can just rezz El G even if they do let the stalk go through.
So you're talking like two nights of actions wasted and a number of insanities gained just so we can be in the same spot in a few days regarding El G and have to lynch them anyhow. I don't know if they are cult either really, but you don't get to blow your night actions two nights in a row and go 'whoopsee daisy, Is insane now!'
Grrrrrr, logic! VPB is right.
Wickedestjr wrote:
hitogoroshi wrote:Also, you're missing the point on suicidal. If you really are a townie, you make LYLO happen a day earlier because the scum can daytalk gang-up and all vote you at once.
I think that having a nearly confirmed townie in the game until the end is a much greater benefit than what could POTENTIALLY bring the town to LyLo a day earlier. Potentially, because if we were in MyLo and not LyLo, this wouldn't be a problem.
Yeah but there are several insanities that don't really affect your ability to play this game. I fubar'd and got suicidal prior to the forbidden list. I don't like, nor advocate others getting it.
VP Baltar wrote:Wraith wrote:@VP: It'll be bad in the future, if cult start outnumbering townies, but not right now. Why would we ever be voting our only really confirmed townie?
/kills self
What VPB you think it'll be good if cult start outnumbering townies??
Iecerint wrote:Well, Benmage, too, maybe, but I meant how ElG used Investigate even though it was a useless decision.
Me too what?
hitogoroshi wrote:Furc, please stop with the VP hate. VP's been doing a shitload to get the town together. If he's scum, he's playing the long game, "be so helpful no one believes I'm scum", and that's looking increasingly less likely.
Yeah VPB is one of the better town reads.
Baby Spice wrote:Killing Furcolow off before we get too near lylo is a definate pro-town move.
He's randomness in action thought and voting, and his tendency to knee jerk vote whoever even looks at him funny is a detriment to the town in the long run.
Couldn't agree more. I fear he could be whimsical enough to even vote someone like VPB. But he’s been pretty townish, and it would be way too irresponsible for us to be voting him today.
"ITT Benmage is making Shakespeare look cool. I need to bring you to my high school." -Vi
"If i must blantantly follow somone a player cannot do better than blindly following benmage" - tubby216
