Well crap … I’ve had completely sporadic internet access this last few days.
I very much dislike how Almaster pitched what is essentially a MD argument instead of addressing my points.
I think AGM is the best lynch for today based on his behavior but would certainly have chosen a Chesskid lynch over Thor since I will maintain that his end of Day 1 position makes no sense as scum (despite what I consider fairly lackluster play, no offense Thor). If he does flip scum then that theory does get blown out of the water.
Everything below this is only useful if the game isn’t over. If the game is over than I was wrong about my theories anyway further demonstrating that isn’t going to be harmful.
--
AGM wrote:This is really all I feel the need to respond to, because it shows that you have a fundamentally flawed approach to catching scum in this game.
No, it is not fundamentally flawed. You disagree with it because I’m pointing you out as scum. That you once again chose to attempt to minimize what I see as scum motivated play with phrases like “weak tells” and the like as opposed to actually responding I find scumtastic.
AGM wrote:Your I flip scum argument is are problematic because they pick-and-choose based on YOUR concept of how scum should play and not the meta of how I ACTUALLY play as scum. I've been mafia three times, and I bussed hardcore every single time. If I was scum in this game, I would have been continuing that thread by out-of-the-blue bussing SO. Your suggestion that we then look at "the people I ignored" despite alllll the evidence pointing the other way shows that you have zero grasp on what is actually going on and want to apply a generic "one size fits all" lens to every scumhunting situation.
I disagree completely. Your argument here, involving self-meta, is ludicrous. You are trying to argue that you ‘automatically’ act the same way as scum always. I don’t believe you are that poor of a Mafia player that you would have such an obviously easily identifiable Meta. Your impression that human nature, in the context of an online Mafia game, is very difficult to change is incorrect.
AGM wrote:We don't need cases. Cases at this point in the game are bad. What we need is big-picture process of elimination.
Yeah, because stating reasoning (via cases) why you are slotting people in the lynch pool for ‘big-picture PoE’ is horrible.
--
CES wrote:P.S. Furry, if you're really conflicted, try re-reading your role PM.
Are you still going with the theory that Furry is scum? Don’t you think letting you live so long as presumed Town thanks to your claim makes no sense for him as scum?
"I am a leaf on the wind ... watch how I soar!"
Pretty much Geriatric game restricted at this point ... unless there are players I REALLY want to play with.