Mafia of the Chosen Ones (Game Over!)

[Equinox]

Wait. What the fuck? "Attempted the impossible"?

DOES THIS MEAN WHAT I THINK IT MEANS.

VOTE: Guderian

Wagon, go go go.

Not sure I understand.

Vi hasn't updated the first post, so I can't really tell; however, it looks like we got a NK after all.

Preview edit: Thanks, guys.

PoE is a go!

[Guderian]

Use reasoning in your next post Equinox.

[Andrius]

HRM.
Anyone down for a Furcolow policy lynch? 100 more faith!
/joking
//actually...

[Magua]

I played with him in Last Will Mafia 2.

I don't think "attempted the impossible" is straight up flavor kill (I expect that is either "corrupted", from Holy Orders, or "shot", given the flavor in the OP).

No posts by him. Will worry about it later.

VOTE: Jack for [redacted]

[Kitoari]

HRM.
Anyone down for a Furcolow policy lynch? 100 more faith!
/joking
//actually...

I think there's a cap on faith if I remember MoHO correctly.

The differing kill flavors make it really hard to figure out what's a scumkill and what isn't.

[Guderian]

moth, you think that was a plan to gauge reactions?

[Equinox]

Andrius's proposal is tempting, but I like my wagon more.

Guderian, I've been using reasoning in all of my posts.

I don't think "attempted the impossible" is straight up flavor kill (I expect that is either "corrupted", from Holy Orders, or "shot", given the flavor in the OP).

Yeah, that's what's stumping me at the moment. I don't think Rhinox would've bitten a zeusbolt so early, though, even if we consider the fact that the battery power was converted.

[mothrax]

Yeah, according to the OP he "Might as well Be Walking on the Sun."
it doesn't sound like factional kill...

Pedit: @gud: yes, what I have read of/interacted with jack he does something like this a lot. That and if his rep is true he is not the type of player to make such a blatant slip d1 under that little (read 0) pressure.

[Equinox]

Vi, can the scum choose their Day 1 kill during confirmation phase, or do they have to wait until the day actually starts?

Yeah, according to the OP he "Might as well Be Walking on the Sun."
it doesn't sound like factional kill...

Pedit: @gud: yes, what I have read of/interacted with jack he does something like this a lot. That and if his rep is true he is not the type of player to make such a blatant slip d1 under that little (read 0) pressure.

But it's undeniable that Rhinox is dead, and the only way that makes sense to me right now is a NK.

Also, Guderian fell right into it. <3

[Guderian]

So if someone else said that, depending on who it was you'd be willing to lynch them (like our departed vezok), but because Jack's experienced you're unwilling to vote him?

[Andrius]

If there is a Faith cap it is 200, which is where they would be at if they did nothing.
So now they get to act.

[Guderian]

Equi, using little hearts and winky faces wont make your strange reasoning appear any less strange. If your vote is serious, explain, if its not, dont act like it is.

[inHimshallibe]

Wait what the hell.

[Andrius]

Inhim/Nixon.
We quicklynched vezok as a half-policy lynch and half-get 100 faith for the seraphs.

[Kitoari]

Just curious gude, why did you stop the newspaper thing?

P-edit: inHim: We lynched vezok in 50 posts. That's about it.

[RayFrost]

Hi guys, I disapprove of quick lynching. The faith given to seraphs is great and all, but they won't be able to

use their freaking powers

if we lynch before they send in a PM, just like all the other players that aren't on during this that have powers. This isn't a good strategy since it's essentially random lynching and putting all the faith in the seraphs (hehehehe, puntastic).

I promote a less random, willy nilly approach. Like actually playing mafia. Who knows, it might be a good idea.

[Guderian]

I liked it, but you and a few others seemed not to, so I stopped. I'm more than happy to start it back up if no one objects.

[RayFrost]

That's all I can post for now - bit busy with shiznit in real life. See yah guys when I get back. PLEASE don't quick lynch while I'm gone. It's not healthy for town, trust me.

[Equinox]

Equi, using little hearts and winky faces wont make your strange reasoning appear any less strange. If your vote is serious, explain, if its not, dont act like it is.

Okay, okay, I'll stop. Watching you squirm was entertaining, though.

I'll admit, I thought it was a slip at first until I remembered that scum tend to proofread. (Hell, when I'm scum, I check my shit twice to make sure that kind of slip doesn't go through.) Jack is experienced, yes, which means he probably either screwed up and posted without checking it, which is townish, or he did it on purpose, which would also be townish.

You gunned right for it.

Preview edit: AAAAH SO MANY NINJAS.

[Andrius]

Hi guys, I disapprove of quick lynching. The faith given to seraphs is great and all, but they won't be able to

use their freaking powers

if we lynch before they send in a PM, just like all the other players that aren't on during this that have powers. This isn't a good strategy since it's essentially random lynching and putting all the faith in the seraphs (hehehehe, puntastic).

I promote a less random, willy nilly approach. Like actually playing mafia. Who knows, it might be a good idea.

RayFrost, the POINT of this game is for the players (Seraphs) to choose the PRs to enter the game.
I HIGHLY doubt that there are any natural PRs in here (minus Mason-Recruiter me).

It was D1. We needed to lynch vezok anyway.

[Equinox]

Hi guys, I disapprove of quick lynching. The faith given to seraphs is great and all, but they won't be able to

use their freaking powers

if we lynch before they send in a PM, just like all the other players that aren't on during this that have powers. This isn't a good strategy since it's essentially random lynching and putting all the faith in the seraphs (hehehehe, puntastic).

I promote a less random, willy nilly approach. Like actually playing mafia. Who knows, it might be a good idea.

What made you think we were going to continue?

[Guderian]

So if someone does something ridiculous/ scummy, we should put them down as town because scum would 'proofread their posts?' Yeah, no.

[RayFrost]

Equi - I must've misread the multiple quickvotes after day two started as going for a fast lynch again.

[Guderian]

And his very next post is a correction to his previous, corresponding to your theory that he was scum, reread it, albeit after he posted, thought 'shit son' and the edited by way of post.

[RayFrost]

Post for Andrius that I was typing before equi posted:

Seriously guys, the idea of quick lynching to hope for getting scum is stupid. I disapprove heavily. Saying "let's let the seraphs do all the work and not do anything but randomly lynch peoples and hope we get lucky" is the pinnacle of pro-scum play, in my opinion.

Regardless of the lack of PRs or such, continuing this path is beyond the edge of foolishness. I can (if stretching myself) understand D1, but the fact you are trying to extend this to D2 is bad (and you DO NOT KNOW if there are other PRs, IIRC - the mod hasn't confirmed either way).