Iec wrote:The only reason I might disagree with you is that (I think?) someone has claimed a successful stalk on Kunkstar. Scum are probably holding a rez kit for it, though...
I've been thinking about this. I'm kind of half inclined to let the person (Triglav?) go through with it. kunk is pretty likely cult and letting Triglav murder him gets rid of a cult and confirms a town player, which is our maximum benefit we can get from the situation. I don't know how many rezz kits the cult even have left. They appear to have wasted one trying to frame me, which was a pretty hilarious gaff if you ask me. Could have been a ploy to save kunk, who knows. But even if they have one and decide to save kunk tonight, then its one less rezz kit they have for two nights (since the offending cultist would have to launder too). Then we get investigator-Triglav and lynch kunk tomorrow, plus a hamstringed cultist that can't stop the murdering in the future. The other side of the argument is to lynch kunk today, which likely bags us a cult but leaves Triglav unconfirmed and leaves a potential rezz kit in the hands of cult.
Benmage wrote:Let's hear everyones 4 remaining scum.
kunk
Nacho
Iec (pending resolution)
Feysal
Trilo wrote:I think it's absolutely critical to lynch Kunkstar today, regardless of the claimed stalk on him, it reduces the body count overnight and allows Iec to kill Benmage.
Well, I think you're looking at this from the perspective of kunk v. Trilo....which I don't think needs to be the case at all. I'm not so sold on Trilo-scum really. I think we could bag and tag two cultists today by lynching maybe Nacho or Feysal and having Triglav kill kunk tonight. I'm pretty sure that would essentially seal this game for town.
Trilo wrote:If Kunk is cult the shot on him is most likely going to fail.
Why? After so many nights of rezzing, I'm not even certain the scum would have kits left. Plus keep in mind that if they ritual they get bloody and lose kits. I have a feeling it's unlikely they could stop Triglav.
Iec wrote:Yeah...cult setting up a scenario that makes SX look cult to kind-of make Benmage (who ALREADY didn't look like cult) look uncult is not plausible.
EDIT: Yeah, not to mention that SX isn't exactly a crappy player.
Why are you sucking up to Benmage so hard? I don't think it's that unlikely to bus Spyrex actually. I dont' think he was playing a particularly great game from what I saw and judging from how many insanities he flipped with, I don't think the cult were exactly planning on sending him to endgame. Bussing him early to confirm a hypo-cult Benmage isn't THAT absurd. You two are making me paranoid as shit, particularly with how you're both quickly trying to get out murdering Benmage. Iec, do you think it's best that you don't follow through with your stalk?
Looking at Trilo's town list, I feel like i am forgetting something that is supposed to be confirming Iec...what did he do again? I thought he hadn't murdered yet, but if he has then I need to adjust my reads accordingly.
