Stars Aligned III - The Tenth Day

[VasudeVa]

Vote: Feysal

[Triglav]

@TNM - Is alphabetical really the best way to handle suicidal testing? Seems like either the people we are likely to want to lynch anyway should either be front loaded or back loaded to the affair. Front - because then we would know what to do if it goes to night at this stage, or back because then we're more likely to catch those scum/murderers who decided to take the insanity because they don't think they're at risk.

In any case I think a clearer picture of what we are doing tonight needs to happen BEFORE we go willy nilly suicidal testing.

In short - stop rushing it, this is not pro town at this point until everyone knows what the plan for night is.

[totallynotmafia]

Everyone (who hasn't claimed to have suicidal) will be tested, so it doesn't matter what order we do it in. We only have a week before deadline, so I'm not rushing anything, this suicidal testing should have been done two game days ago.

[Feysal]

Feysal, what are your thoughts on Nacho, VV, and Trilo?

Nachomamma8 - probable cult.
VasudeVa - probable town.
Trilobite - torn between him and Triglav being the last cultist. If Triglav fails in his murder, I believe it is him, and this would make Trilobite town.

Everyone (who hasn't claimed to have suicidal) will be tested, so it doesn't matter what order we do it in. We only have a week before deadline, so I'm not rushing anything, this suicidal testing should have been done two game days ago.

As a matter of fact you are rushing. We don't have a night action plan yet, and if any of our tests results in a lynch, we will have no time to plan afterwards. At this stage we don't want a night where everyone is confused what to do.

Benmage said he would be drawing up the night action plan soon, so the delay should not be great. In the meantime, if you want to test me first, be my guest. I know my test won't result in a sudden night.

[Benmage]

I'll be the last vote tester for this insanity.

[Percy]

Vote Count

*whisper whisper*

Trilobite - 1

(Benmage)

Feysal - 1

(VasudeVa)
Nicodemus - 0 (

Nicodemus

)
Benmage - 0 (

Nicodemus

,

Nicodemus

)
xvart - 0 (

Nicodemus

,

Nicodemus

)

Not Voting (11) - (Feysal, Iecerint, kunkstar7, Nachomamma8, Nicodemus, totallynotmafia, Triglav, Trilobite,

VasudeVa

, VP Baltar, xvart)

Prodding kunkstar7.

The deadline for today's lynch is Thursday, 17 February 2011 at 9:00:00 PM (default site time).

With 12 alive, 7 votes secures a lynch.

[Triglav]

Everyone (who hasn't claimed to have suicidal) will be tested, so it doesn't matter what order we do it in. We only have a week before deadline, so I'm not rushing anything, this suicidal testing should have been done two game days ago.

It does matter.
Say night action revolves around X doing Y to A
A is lynched because A is suicidal - X goes
X is lynched because X is suicidal - does someone still need to do Y to A

Still think delay and more logic to order is needed as part of plan to control night action 'oops'.
Why do you not?

[Iecerint]

I actually think Feysal is more likely scum than Nacho. The only reason I'm sketchy about it is that VV is the one pushing for it when OBVOBVOBV Kunk is there.

Point is that I'm OK with testing Feysal.

Be vigilant.

Vote: Feysal

[totallynotmafia]

Everyone (who hasn't claimed to have suicidal) will be tested, so it doesn't matter what order we do it in. We only have a week before deadline, so I'm not rushing anything, this suicidal testing should have been done two game days ago.

It does matter.
Say night action revolves around X doing Y to A
A is lynched because A is suicidal - X goes
X is lynched because X is suicidal - does someone still need to do Y to A

Still think delay and more logic to order is needed as part of plan to control night action 'oops'.
Why do you not?

1. It'll take a while for everyone to place their votes anyway.
2. We only have a week so we're going to need to "rush" if we want to test everyone before the day is up.
3. Lynching scum today is imperitive. The point of the suicidal testing is to lynch scum. If somebody like Feysal whom we have no inclination of lynching is lynched from the suicidal testing because they are scum, I wouldn't be that worried that we didn't get the night plan in order. There should be plenty of time to get the night plan in order though, not much time for the suicidal testing on the other hand.

[Triglav]

1. Point.
2. Point.
3. Meh, heart of disagreement. (more the latter part than the former, natch)

We suppose since we are the only negative Nelly that you might as well proceed apace since we can't stop you, but if night actions are gakked up we reserve the right to act superior to you in all manners (especially penile length) in all future interactions.

[VP Baltar]

Vote: Feysal

who all is on the to be murdered list tonight? Just kunk?

[VP Baltar]

EBWOP: presuming we mislynch and Benmage is off

[Trilobite]

Vote: Feysal

Just a reminder whoever places the l-1 vote needs unvote immediately afterwards. Also if we do catch a suicidal, both Iec and Trig should shoot tonight.

[VP Baltar]

I've been thinking, kunk is likely cult and has been floating under the radar with all of the testing discussion....what if he has suicidal? I personally don't think the cult has rezz kits, so I want to know if Triglav is BSing or not about stalking. We're already not testing our other potential murder victim Ben because we know he has it. Do we want to test kunk or leave him for Triglav to prove his towniness with?

[Trilobite]

If Kunk has suicidal, he's the 3rd alphabetically to be tested, at which point the day would end. (Unless Feysal or Iec has suicidal in which case it will end before that.)

[VP Baltar]

Yer, that's what I'm saying. What do you think Trilo?

[Trilobite]

Well it would be a cult lynch, and that's great.

If we're trying to avoid lynching him for the purposes of testing Triglav's stalk, I've made it clear that we should test Kunk later on, or not even at all.

All things considered, I think things are a lot simpler if we just lynch Kunk, but that's just my opinion. (assuming we don't catch anyone else with suicidal)

[VP Baltar]

Yeah, but I really feel like letting Triglav murder, or attempt to, is going to show his alignment. That's really helpful for us.

[Trilobite]

Triglav's alignment or Kunk's?

If we're talking about Kunk's, I think it's been pretty clear he's scum for quite some time now.

[VP Baltar]

Triglav's. We know kunk is very likely to flip scum. So, if the scum don't have rezz kits and Triglav is telling the truth about his stalk, then he should be able to murder no problem. We still get a dead kunk-cult AND we get confirmed town Triglav. Seems worthwhile to me and it has very minimal costs.

[xvart]

Vote: Feysal

Will be a little challenged to be unvoting and voting until Saturday night, but I can try and get some accesss tomorrow.

[Benmage]

Vote: Feysal

who all is on the to be murdered list tonight? Just kunk?

Just kunk.

Vote: Feysal

Just a reminder whoever places the l-1 vote needs unvote immediately afterwards. Also if we do catch a suicidal, both Iec and Trig should shoot tonight.

Thats why I am doing the last vote.

Do we want to test kunk or leave him for Triglav to prove his towniness with?

Leave him.

[Benmage]

Oh which I guess is now.

Unvote

vote Feysal

Unvote

[Benmage]

Go ahead with the next testing...we're not testing Kunk, FYI.

[Iecerint]

One potential problem is that players may take Aversion or whatever to their cultmates.

Mod: If players vote a player to whom they have aversion, will they be punished in-thread? Will it show up on VC?