Simpsons Mafia (Game Over)

[jasonT1981]

Wanted to try and WIFOM the scum. Would I risk protecting the same person twice in a row or would I try and protect someone else who I was saying was town?

Yes, it lacks a vote.... For a reason.

I really want to see SH explanation.

[Benmage]

I want to hear rib's fakeclaim personally before we end this day too early. But both will suffice

[Mariyta]

VOTE: Steven Hacking Haven't even read past Ben's claim. Hiraki can die tomorrow.

[Mariyta]

Fonz is going to have fun with the ribwich claim. So we have confirmed scum w/ Steven and Ribwich, then Hiraki. The next few days are going to be busy.

[diddin]

Hiraki was on the Mist wagon. Like it or not, we aren't lynching him any time soon.

[Mariyta]

I know. But he's still scum, so we get to lynch him at some point.

[Benmage]

Much later methinks considering ribwich was on the wagon....Which leaves only 1 scum left on the wagon.

[The Fonz]

Guys, don't lynch either until we've heard both claims. There is a protown explanation. It isn't likely and it almost certainly doesn't apply to both of them, but it exists.

[jasonT1981]

Guys, don't lynch either until we've heard both claims. There is a protown explanation. It isn't likely and it almost certainly doesn't apply to both of them, but it exists.

hence why I have not voted yet.

[Wraith]

Okay, I can get on an alternative now that a tracker claim and accusation has been made.

Unvote Vote: Steven Hacking

I hope that's not a hammer because I'd like to hear his defense.

Also @sotty: What was your post restriction?

[Wraith]

Guys, don't lynch either until we've heard both claims. There is a protown explanation. It isn't likely and it almost certainly doesn't apply to both of them, but it exists.

FUCK

I didn't hammer did I?

[Consigliere]

Running down what I have so far (Please correct me if I'm wrong):

On the Mist Wagon (Claimed character after name)...2 of this list we assume to be dirty based on Sens' claim:

hiraki
SensFan - Lisa Simpson
jasonT1981 - Doc Hibbert
The Fonz
sottyrulez
DarlaBlueEyes - Groundskeeper Willie
KageLord
DemonHybrid - Marge Simpson
Nero Cain
Mariyta
ribwich

That leaves 7 unidentified...so if we take claims on that list at face...2/5 chance of hitting scum.

Off the mist wagon:

Consigliere
Benmage (Tracker claim)
Wraith
Diddin (Reverend Lovejoy)
Steven Hacking
Sleepless Assassin
Nachomamma
Lowell

Pretty much if I personally take Diddin and Benmage at face and sens' claim as truth, 3-4 out of 5 are dirty "off the wagon" in Wraith/Steven Hacking/Sleepless Asassin/Nachomamma/Lowell..60-80% is pretty strong for me. If Benmage has found one of the 2 in ribwich on the wagon, that would be pretty sweet. I agree we should hear from Steven before actin (Everyone should be given a chance to claim/Make their case)...but Ben could have made a big play here.

[Consigliere]

Okay, I can get on an alternative now that a tracker claim and accusation has been made.

Unvote Vote: Steven Hacking

I hope that's not a hammer because I'd like to hear his defense.

Also @sotty: What was your post restriction?

Nah...You were #7.

[Benmage]

Thats L-3 than.... Please no more votes

[Wraith]

Hang on.

@Jason: Why are you still alive?

[SensFan]

Restricted to 10 posts for the day. I'd spend more time on this, but it needs to be out there ASAP.

I lied yesterday; I needed a way to get my info out there and not be killed, since I'm actually a 2-shot Sensor.
5 threats to the Town on the lynchwagon yesterday.

[1/10]

[Consigliere]

BTW DHB...Why did you claim your character?

I was thinking if anyone claimed as such it would be more beneficial that off the wagon players do so to help the town make a better decision...(which includes myself, I know)...so yours seems kinda out of place to me.

[Benmage]

Ooooo Sens nice gambit..and the plot thickens...We matchup who was off the first and on the second and hopefully got this on lockdown.

(brb)

[Wraith]

Mist7676 - 13 - hiraki,

SensFan

,

jasonT1981

,

The Fonz

, sottyrulez, DarlaBlueEyes, LlamaFluff, KageLord, DemonHybrid, Nero Cain,

Mariyta

,

boberz

,

ribwich

Tragedy(12)-

Steven Hacking

, diddin,

boberz

,

Mariyta

,

jasonT1981

, DemonHybrid, Benmage, Lowell, Wraith,

ribwich

,

The Fonz

,

SensFan

Assuming Steven is scum, these are the correlations with both wagons. Combined with the fact that he is alive, I am significantly more doubtful of Jason's Doc claim right now.

[Wraith]

Forgot to bold DemondHybrid as well.

[Benmage]

So that cements that rib is even more likely scum.

Leaving fonz/DH/Jason/maritya?

[Wraith]

Mist7676 - 13 - hiraki,

SensFan

,

jasonT1981

, The Fonz, sottyrulez, DarlaBlueEyes, LlamaFluff, KageLord, DemonHybrid, Nero Cain, Mariyta,

boberz

,

ribwich

Tragedy(12)-

Steven Hacking

,

diddin

,

boberz

, Mariyta,

jasonT1981

, DemonHybrid,

Benmage

,

Lowell

,

Wraith

,

ribwich

, The Fonz,

SensFan

Consigliere

Benmage (Tracker claim)

Wraith

Diddin (Reverend Lovejoy)

Steven Hacking

Sleepless Assassin
Nachomamma

Lowell

Okay, here are my new reads based on the PR data.

[Consigliere]

So that cements that rib is even more likely scum.

Leaving fonz/DH/Jason/maritya?

sens' input also furthers your case against Steven.

However:

Mist7676 - 13 - hiraki,

SensFan

,

jasonT1981

,

The Fonz

, sottyrulez, DarlaBlueEyes, LlamaFluff, KageLord, DemonHybrid, Nero Cain,

Mariyta

,

boberz

,

ribwich

Tragedy(12)-

Steven Hacking

, diddin,

boberz

,

Mariyta

,

jasonT1981

, DemonHybrid, Benmage, Lowell, Wraith,

ribwich

,

The Fonz

,

SensFan

Assuming Steven is scum, these are the correlations with both wagons. Combined with the fact that he is alive, I am significantly more doubtful of Jason's Doc claim right now.

I'm not seeing this Wraith...If Jason was on the first wagon, based on sens' claim, that means the odds are very much against his being scum...Even if he's on the second wagon, the odds are actually AGAINST him being scum as there are only 5/11 scum on that wagon according to sens...and if we take Benmage at face and he is right about ribwich, the odds are strongly against Jason being scum from my perspective.

[Benmage]

sens' input also furthers your case against Steven.

Oh lol, you get tracked to a dead guy you die. None of this Supernatural/aCoK crap.

[Wraith]

I'm not seeing this Wraith...If Jason was on the first wagon, based on sens' claim, that means the odds are very much against his being scum...Even if he's on the second wagon, the odds are actually AGAINST him being scum as there are only 5/11 scum on that wagon according to sens...and if we take Benmage at face and he is right about ribwich, the odds are strongly against Jason being scum from my perspective.

I disagree.

1. With 5 scum on the Tragedy wagon, that leaves more of a chance of the repeat customers being the scum. We already have ribwich, and although Hiraki and Kagelord are also good suspects they were not on the Tragedy wagon. However, there is a flaw in this, that being that DemonHybrid, another scummy player, was also a repeat customer. However:

2. Jason claimed doctor, for no good reason, and remained alive today. He was not even roleblocked. FAKECLAIM ALERT