Simpsons Mafia (Game Over)

[DemonHybrid]

I wanna know what happens if he attempts to. Vi mentioned that there hasn't been a priest in a game since years ago.

[Sleepless Assassin]

I'm Nelson, Two shot vig.

Shot Deer N1 and crumbed it here:

Wow. Looks like a vig got a shot off, but scum was stopped. Unless someone wants to explain why Deer makes sense as a scum kill. Diddin ignoring the possibility that scum didn't shoot Deer looks kind of . . . intentionally dense.

Shot Boberz N2.

[DemonHybrid]

Unvote

[DemonHybrid]

SA, where have you been the past day or so?

[DarlaBlueEyes]

unvote

[DemonHybrid]

Also: Dammit, you're supposed to be sleepless.

Here is the current data gathered.

One scum from this list:

hiraki, jasonT1981, DarlaBlueEyes, DemonHybrid, Mariyta

(downgraded from one to two scum, because we have a claimed 3rd party) One scum from this list:

Consig, diddin, Sleepless Assassin

ONE SCUM

from this list:

diddin, Mariyta, jasonT1981, DemonHybrid

Some of the possibilities:

Possibility #1: One of Sleepless or Consig is scum.
Diddin is confirmed town.
One of Mari, JasonT and DemonHybrid is scum + possible 3rd party (Mari, if not scum)

Possibility #2: diddin is scum, satisfying the requirements on both Green and Blue wagons.
One of hiraki, DarlaBlueEyes is scum. Again, possible 3rd party, would be claimed Mari.

Claims:

DemonHybrid - Marge Simpson, Town Bulletproof
diddin - Reverend Lovejoy, Town Priest
Consig - Martin Prince, VT
DarlaBlueEyes - Groundskeeper Willie, VT
jasonT1981 - Doctor Hibbert, Doctor
Mariyta - Sideshow Bob, Bart Assassin SK turned Neutral Survivor
Sleepless Assassin - Nelson, 2 shot vig. Shot Deer and boberz.
Hiraki - ???

5 kill flavors:

Disciplined - Llama
Bored to Death (likely Nuclear kill flavor) - SensFan, sotty, Benmage, Nero Cain
Shot - boberz, Deer
Silenced (likely Mafia kill flavor) - Fonz, Kage
Squeaked (likely 3rd Mafia kill flavor) - Nachomamma

Everyone else lynched

[DemonHybrid]

Disciplined is a likely Burns kill flavor; it stopped after he died.

I'm willing to believe Sleepless. It makes a lot of sense.

[DemonHybrid]

diddin, we may have to stop being friends again. Consig looks very town to me.

[DarlaBlueEyes]

I agree about Consig, and SA's claim sits well with me.

I still don't like Mari's claim and Diddin's seems sketchy

[DemonHybrid]

Vote: diddin

Mari can wait until we at least sniff out the one green wagon scum.

[DemonHybrid]

By the way, if anyone was wondering, this is where I learned maths:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pj2NOTanzWI

[DarlaBlueEyes]

vote diddin

[Hiraki]

Unvote

Should I claim?

Vote: Diddin

[Consigliere]

Ok...There's 4 on diddin right now by my count.

Somebody please unvote diddin for just a little bit please....I have some thoughts to share and I'm afraid of where things lie and would like to discuss just a tad more.

A couple thoughts:

Night 1: Only 1 person killed...Shot.

Night 2: 2 people killed....One shot...One disciplined.

Night 3: 1 person killed..."Bored to death"

Night 4: 2 people killed..."Bored to death" and "silenced"

Night 5: 2 people killed..."silenced" and "Bored to death"

Night 6: 2 people killed..."Bored to death" and "Squeaked"


Disciplined sounds like Burns to me.

Silenced is Johnny Tightlips.

Shot is probably mafia.

My hunch:

It's Sideshow and Krusty as a third group folks.

KRUSTY HAS TO BE IN THIS GAME...HE'S KRUSTY...and "squeaked?"

And think about Sideshow..."Bored to death"

To a T that is his character.

With his stupid intellectual crap, being booted from the show and nobody giving a holy hell about him....

Those two FIT PERFECTLY TOGETHER as a scum faction.

The only thing that throws me is that "squeaked" and "bored to death" both show up on night 6...

Is it possible that we've knocked out two factions out of three and the last faction is given their nightkills for fairness or whatever?

If this is the case, Sleepless might show up any minute and wax diddin....thus why I'm asking for an unvote for a short time to discuss this.

_____

Jason, who did you save each night?

____

Hiraki....I'm pretty sure you don't have to...It's obvious at this point from my perspective.

[Consigliere]

Per a Jason iso (answering my own question):

Night 1: Fonz
Night 2: Fonz
Night 3: Ben
Night 4: Ben
Night 5: ???
Night 6: ???

[Consigliere]

'sup jason...'sup.

Got that info on nights 5 and 6 by any chance?

[Consigliere]

Aaaannndd...Jason leaves.

Wassup wit dat?

[Consigliere]

Just doing some math on who is left.

8 left.

Two possibilities the way I see it:

2 scum, 6 town

2 scum, 5 town and a neutral


If we mislynch today and there are 2 nightkills this evening:

2 scum, 3 town

2 scum, 2 town, 1 neutral

[Mariyta]

Cons, you say "shot" sounds like mafia, but it fits perfectly with SA's claim. Shot only occurred nights one and two. Nothing since. If SA was scum, I doubt he'd stop shooting after night 2.
Also, who did you replace?

Fuzzy Beavers?

Nope. Tvellalot. Who many thought was scum.

DH, what makes you write off Cons as scum and focus solely on diddin (after you've declared diddin confirmed town)? I'm a bit confused on your whole thought process here.

Choices today (at least, my choices) are diddin and Cons. I'm going to re-read them both later, hopefully, after I get some work done.

[Consigliere]

Just doing some math on who is left.

8 left.

Two possibilities the way I see it:

2 scum, 6 town

2 scum, 5 town and a neutral


If we mislynch today and there are 2 nightkills this evening:

2 scum, 3 town

2 scum, 2 town, 1 neutral

That is, unless we (mis?)lynch Mariyta and she is telling the truth...Then we are looking at

2 scum, 3 town


So do we leave the town in the hands of a neutral potentially tomorrow instead of a town-sided player in scenario 2?


_____

(Sorry about the string of posts folks...Just tryin' to piece it together)

[Consigliere]

Cons, you say "shot" sounds like mafia, but it fits perfectly with SA's claim. Shot only occurred nights one and two. Nothing since. If SA was scum, I doubt he'd stop shooting after night 2.
Also, who did you replace?

Fuzzy Beavers?

Nope. Tvellalot. Who many thought was scum.

DH, what makes you write off Cons as scum and focus solely on diddin (after you've declared diddin confirmed town)? I'm a bit confused on your whole thought process here.

Choices today (at least, my choices) are diddin and Cons. I'm going to re-read them both later, hopefully, after I get some work done.

You realize I could hammer diddin right now and that there is ZERO CHANCE that both of us are scum.

Think about that.

[Mariyta]

I'm not town. I am a neutral. You had it right. (Though, maybe by neutral you mean SK, in which case, that's now wrong.)

P-edit: Yes, I do realize that. But to hammer now and have him flip town means your certain death tomorrow, so that's why it doesn't mean you're obvtown.

[Consigliere]

I'm not town. I am a neutral. You had it right. (Though, maybe by neutral you mean SK, in which case, that's now wrong.)

P-edit: Yes, I do realize that.

But to hammer now and have him flip town means your certain death tomorrow,

so that's why it doesn't mean you're obvtown.

Why again would it mean my certain death if he flips town?

[Consigliere]

Cons, you say "shot" sounds like mafia, but it fits perfectly with SA's claim. Shot only occurred nights one and two. Nothing since. If SA was scum, I doubt he'd stop shooting after night 2.

Also, who did you replace?

Fuzzy Beavers?

Nope. Tvellalot. Who many thought was scum.

DH, what makes you write off Cons as scum and focus solely on diddin (after you've declared diddin confirmed town)? I'm a bit confused on your whole thought process here.

Choices today (at least, my choices) are diddin and Cons. I'm going to re-read them both later, hopefully, after I get some work done.

As for the semantics of your "shot" (A good question indeed)...We only had 2 shots, that is correct.

What if Fat Tony was the shooter?

If he and Tightlips has one nightkill between them as Springfield mafia, he submitted night's 1 and 2...then he claimed on day 3 and we started seeing "silences" (Tightlips) and he probably stopped submitted so as not to be discovered by a potential night role....Night 3 there was only one kill, so they either refrained, were blocked by Fonz, or shot DHB....or something else?

LOTS of possibilities there.

By no means is a two-shot vig a guarantee.

And if you look at that boberz kill on night 2, there is ZERO CHANCE a vig would do that....ZERO....Boberz was on the friggin mist wagon with a sens claim saying the odds were HUGELY AGAINST BOBERZ BEING DIRTY.

I'm not buying it.

Not one bit.

Only a scum would want to hit boberz with those odds.

Mariyta or Sleepless.

I'm telling you people...Unvote diddin.

[Consigliere]

Vote:Mariyta

I know this splits the town...and that goes against one of my own personal rules of a "united town lynch"...but I can't see voting for anyone else today at this point. Her death explains so much...and, at worst, leaves us in a 3-2 situation....I'd much rather take my chances with 2 townies on my side than with 1 townie and 1 neutral....and I don't buy Sleepless' claim.