Stars Aligned III - The Tenth Day

[Zachrulez]

We should have reverted to Sottyrulez after Ojanen flaked really.

[Iecerint]

Good job to VP Baltar in particular. I think you were the Cultist who most appeared town on the basis of play alone. The others seemed a bit scummy to me, granted that I thought half the town was scum, too.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Good game Town ... despite some overall questionable Town play (Cowering more than once ... really) and selfish greedy bastards going Murder you got it together and pulled out a win.

Overall my impression of the Scum was that they played at worst a solid game and got screwed over by some untimely missed kills.

After reading the first couple hundred posts in the Scum QT I now know to call Andy scum pre-emptively in any game I am Town we play together.

Best Town decision of the game IMO? xvart murdering Furc. It cleared up a mislynch in the offing and confirmed him as non-scum.

Zach - Chesskid jumps in every game that ends that I played to troll me.

[Iecerint]

Furc was obvtown IMO. Obvobvobvx343. But it did keep me from wanting to lynch xvart, I suppose.

[Zachrulez]

This game literally did drive me insane at times. Being left alive so long felt like a curse until day 9.

[VP Baltar]

Thanks to Percy for the game and Vi for coming through at clutch moments.

[xvart]

Good game. I'm sorry for sort of flaking out at times. This game taught me a lesson that I really have to be isolated to a single game or two to play a mechanics heavy game. I wish I would have continued to go the Murderer route even after my Benmage stalk failed. I'm anxious to see the full night actions but from skimming the Sanctum QT I think my next stalk would have failed due to being warded by the Cult; but man, that would have been sweet to try. With the personal things going on I probably would not have been able to keep track of any lying that I would have had to do; but I could have kept up the absent minded professor act.

Obviously I'm terrible at night actions but I will freely admit that it felt so good to vig Furcolow. That made the whole game worth it right there. And for reference, when I softly said something about his behavior not emulating town behavior I was referring to Succession mafia where he was basically strung up to L-1 (pretty much the same circumstances as this game) and he was not as volatile in that game. I couldn't get over that.

Xvart seems to have little idea on what causes insanity gain. Particularly the cult side. An idea echoed by Seacore and to a lesser extent, Benmage.
If I thought it was posible, I'd peg these three as communicating privately.

GASP! I'm offended at the mere suggestion.

[Iecerint]

Oh, it was a CONSTANT struggle to avoid going Murderer every night.

[VP Baltar]

-___- wish you would have

[Vi]

---FATE---SOUL RIPPED DAY 1---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 2
Night 0 - Search: Occult Books - Heard Noise
Night 1 - Passed Fetish (Insanity irrelevant)
At Death - Possessed Occult Books; Insanity Count: 1

---REAPERCHARLIE---SOUL RIPPED DAY 1---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 2
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit - Heard Noise
At Death - Possessed Resuscitation Kit; Insanity Count: 0

---LOST BUTTERFLY---MURDERED NIGHT 1---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 2
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit - Heard Noise
Night 1 - Cower (Insanity irrelevant)
At Death - Possessed Resuscitation Kit; Insanity Count: 1

---MAGNAOFILLUSION---LYNCHED DAY 2---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 2
Night 0 - Stalk: Lost Butterfly (Solist) - Heard Noise
Night 1 - Murder: Lost Butterfly (Obsession) - Heard Noise; Bloody
At Death - Possessed nothing; Insanity Count: 2; Murder Count: 1

---FURPANTS_TOM---DESTROYED NIGHT 2---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 3
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 1 - Resuscitate: kunkstar7 (not successful) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Resuscitate: Feysal (not successful) - Heard Noise
At Death - Possessed Resuscitation Kit; Insanity Count: 0

---EL GOOSUKI---LYNCHED DAY 3---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 4
Night 0 - Search: Forensic Tools - Heard Noise
Night 1 - Investigate: xvart (not successful) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Cower (Suicidal) - Heard Noise
At Death - Possessed Forensic Tools; Insanity Count: 1

---FURCOLOW---MURDERED NIGHT 3---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 4
Night 0 - Ward: El Goosuki
Night 1 - Search: Resuscitation Kit - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Ward: Iecerint - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Resuscitate: hitogoroshi (not successful) - Passed Fetish (insanity irrelevant)
At Death - Possessed Resuscitation Kit; Insanity Count: 1

---WICKEDESTJR---DESTROYED NIGHT 3---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 4
Night 0 - Search: Forensic Tools - Heard Noise
Night 1 - Search: Resuscitation Kit - Saved from death (Twitchy) - Heard Noise; Bloody; lost RK
Night 2 - Rob: Lost Butterfly (Obsession; gains and immediately loses RK); Investigate: Andrius (not successful) - Bloody
Night 3 - Investigate: kunkstar7 (not successful) - Heard Noise; Bloody
At Death - Possessed Forensic Tools; Insanity Count: 2

---SPYREX---LYNCHED DAY 4---FLIPPED CULTIST NIGHT 4
Night 0 - Craft Fetish: Seacore (success), rewq455 (aka Wraith) (success)
Night 1 - Craft Fetish: totallynotmafia (success), Trilobite (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Craft Fetish: nopointinactingup (success), Seacore (success); Ritual: Furpants_Tom (Twitchy) - Saved from death (Marked) - Heard Noise; Bloody
Night 3 - Greater Ritual: Wickedestjr (Solist); Ward: El Goosuki (Obsession) - Bloody
At Death - Possessed nothing; Insanity Count: 4

---WRAITH (rep. rewq455)---DESTROYED NIGHT 4---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 5
Night 0 (rewq) - Ward: ReaperCharlie - Heard Noise
Night 1 - Search: Resuscitation Kit - Passed Fetish (Twitchy) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Resuscitate: Furcolow (not successful) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Resuscitate: Furcolow (not successful)
Night 4 - Stalk: Nicodemus (successful; Insanity irrelevant)
At Death - Possessed Resuscitation Kit; Insanity Count: 2

---BABY SPICE---LYNCHED DAY 5---FLIPPED CULTIST NIGHT 5
Night 0 - Craft Fetish: MagnaofIllusion (not successful), ReaperCharlie (not successful)
Night 1 - Ritual: Wickedestjr (Solist); Craft Fetish: Furcolow (success), El Goosuki (success) - Bloody
Night 2 - Ritual: Furpants_Tom (Obsession); Rob: ReaperCharlie (success, Suicidal; gains Corpse Dust; cannot pick up RK because Bloody) - Bloody
Night 3 - Greater Ritual: Wickedestjr (Twitchy); Launder - no more Corpse Dust, Bloody
Night 4 - Ritual: Wraith (Necrophilia); Craft Fetish: [REDACTED] (success), [REDACTED] (success) - Heard Noise, Bloody
At Death - Possessed nothing; Insanity Count: 5

---PLUM---LYNCHED DAY 6---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 6
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 1 - Resuscitate: hitogoroshi (not successful) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Resuscitate: VasudeVa (not successful) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Resuscitate: Trilobite (not successful) - Heard Noise
Night 4 - Rob: El Goosuki (gained nothing, Twitchy); Rob: Furcolow (gained nothing, Solist) - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Resuscitate: hitogoroshi (not successful) - Heard Noise
At Death - Possessed Resuscitation Kit; Insanity Count: 2

---ANDRIUS---LYNCHED DAY 7---FLIPPED CULTIST NIGHT 7
Night 0 - Craft Fetish: hitogoroshi (success), Fate (success)
Night 1 - Ritual: Wickedestjr (Twitchy); Craft Fetish: AurorusVox (success), [REDACTED] (success) - Bloody
Night 2 - Launder - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Rob: Furpants_Tom (gained nothing, Solist); Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 4 - Pass Fetish: Benmage, Seacore, VasudeVa - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Ritual: Seacore (Hallucination); Craft Fetish: Iecerint, Nachomamma8, Plum (Obsession) - Heard Noise, Bloody, lost Rez Kit
Night 6 - Ritual: hitogoroshi (Denial); Ward: kunkstar7 - Saved from death (Marked) - Heard Noise, Bloody
At Death - Possessed nothing; Insanity Count: 6*

---AURORUSVOX---MURDERED NIGHT 6---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 7---
Night 0 - Search: Forensic Tools
Night 1 - Search: Resuscitation Kit - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Resuscitate: VP Baltar
Night 3 - Resuscitate: VP Baltar - Heard Noise
Night 4 - Rob: Wickedestjr (gained nothing, Twitchy); Rob: SpyreX (gained nothing, Taboo: Inv)
Night 5 - Stalk: Benmage (failed, Solist losing Forensic Tools) - Passed Fetish (Compulsion) - Heard Noise
Night 6 - Resuscitate: Seacore
At Death - Possessed Resuscitation Kit, Insanity Count: 4

---SEACORE---DESTROYED NIGHT 7---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 8---
Night 0 - Search: Forensic Tools - Heard Noise
Night 1 - Ward: Triglav (success) - Passed Fetish (Twitchy) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Investigate: El Goosuki (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Rob: Furpants_Tom (Solist); Investigate: Plum (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 4 - Stalk: Baby Spice (failure, Obsession) - Passed Fetish (Taboo: Investigate) - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Stalk: AurorusVox (success, Hallucination) - Saved from Death (Mutilation) - Heard Noise, Bloody
Night 6 - Murder: AurorusVox (success, Compulsion) - Heard Noise, Bloody
Night 7 - Due to the stupid user interface of Google Docs this result was lost, but the action was Launder.
At Death - Possessed Forensic Tools, Insanity Count: 7, Murder Count: 1

---KUNKSTAR7---LYNCHED DAY 8---FLIPPED CULTIST NIGHT 8---
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 1 - Craft Fetish: Plum (success), MagnaofIllusion (success) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Resuscitate: SpyreX (success, lost Rez Kit), Ritual: Furpants_Tom (Solist) - Bloody
Night 3 - Greater Ritual: Wickedestjr (Obsession), Launder (success) - Heard Noise, Bloody (but not for the Inv. that targeted him)
Night 4 - Ritual: Wraith (Suicidal), Ward: Nicodemus (success) - Bloody
Night 5 - Ritual: Seacore (Twitchy), Ward: Benmage (success) - Bloody
Night 6 - Greater Ritual: hitogoroshi (success, Denial), Craft: Nachomamma8 (success), Nicodemus (success), Trilobite (success, Mutilation) - Heard Noise, Bloody
Night 7 - Greater Ritual: Seacore (Marked), Ward: Trilobite (success), Denial (Hallucination) - Heard Noise, Bloody
At Death - Possessed nothing, Insanity Count: 7*

---HITOGOROSHI---DESTROYED NIGHT 6---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 8---
Night 0 - Search: Forensic Tools - Heard Noise
Night 1 - Ward: Trilobite (success) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Rob: MagnaofIllusion (success, Twitchy); Investigate: Nicodemus (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Investigate: Plum (failure) - Passed Fetish (Solist) - Heard Noise
Night 4 - Stalk: Baby Spice (failure, Obsession) - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Stalk: Andrius (success, Compulsion) - Passed Fetish (Taboo: Investigate) - Heard Noise
Night 6 - Murder: Andrius (failure, Insanity irrelevant) - Bloody
At Death - Possessed Forensic Tools, Insanity Count: 6

---VASUDEVA---DESTROYED NIGHT 8---FLIPPED INVESTIGATOR NIGHT 9---
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 1 - Search: Forensic Tools - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Investigate: Plum (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Resuscitate: Trilobite (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 4 - Resuscitate: VP Baltar (failure) - Passed Fetish (Twitchy) - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Investigate: Plum (failure)
Night 6 - Stalk: kunkstar7 (failure, Compulsion) - Heard Noise
Night 7 - Resuscitate: Seacore (success, lost Rez Kit) - Heard Noise, Bloody
Night 8 - Launder
At Death - Possessed Forensic Tools, Insanity Count: 2

---TRIGLAV---LYNCHED DAY 9---FLIPPED CULTIST NIGHT 9---
Night 0 - Craft: Wickedestjr (success), xvart (success)
Night 1 - Ritual: Wickedestjr (Solist); Craft: VasudeVa (success), xvart (success) - Heard Noise, Bloody
Night 2 - Launder
Night 3 - Craft: Seacore (success), VasudeVa (success)
Night 4 - Ward: Plum (success) - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 6 - Resuscitate: VP Baltar (success, lost Rez Kit) - Bloody
Night 7 - Greater Ritual: Seacore (Twitchy); Ward: xvart (success) - Bloody
Night 8 - Greater Ritual: VasudeVa (Insanity not noted); Pass: Benmage (success), Iecerint (success), Nachomamma8 (success) - Bloody
At Death - Possessed nothing, Insanity Count: 3

---FEYSAL---MURDERED NIGHT 9---CULTIST---
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 1 - Craft: Furpants_Tom (success), hitogoroshi (success)
Night 2 - Craft: Iecerint (failure), Nicodemus (success) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Craft: AurorusVox (success), Benmage (success)
Night 4 - Ward: Andrius
Night 5 - Craft: totallynotmafia (success), Trilobite (success)
Night 6 - Greater Ritual: hitogoroshi (Solist, lost Rez Kit), Resuscitate: Andrius (success) - Bloody
Night 7 - Launder
Night 8 - Search: Resuscitation Kit - Heard Noise
Night 9 - Greater Ritual: Trilobite (Insanity irrelevant); Ward: VP Baltar (success) - Bloody
At Death - Possessed Resuscitation Kit, Insanity Count: 2

---TRILOBITE---DESTROYED NIGHT 9---INVESTIGATOR---
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 1 - Resuscitate: hitogoroshi (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Resuscitate: hitogoroshi (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Rob: Furpants_Tom (Twitchy); Search: Occult Books - Heard Noise
Night 4 - Commune: Triglav (failure, Taboo: Commune)
Night 5 - Resuscitate: xvart (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 6 - Resuscitate: VasudeVa (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 7 - Resuscitate: xvart (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 8 - Stalk: Feysal (success, Compulsion) - Passed Fetish (Obsession) - Heard Noise
Night 9 - Murder: Feysal (success, lost Rez kit, Insanity irrelevant) - Bloody
At Death - Possessed Occult Books, Insanity Count: 5

---VP BALTAR---LYNCHED DAY 10---CULTIST
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 1 - Pass: Fate (success), Seacore (success), Wraith (success)
Night 2 - Craft: Trilobite (success), Wraith (success) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Pass: Furcolow (success), hitogoroshi (success), xvart (success) - Heard Noise
Night 4 - Rob: Wickedestjr (success, Twitchy), Ward: Baby Spice (success) - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Pass: AurorusVox (success), hitogoroshi (success), Nicodemus (success) - Heard Noise
Night 6 - Greater Ritual: hitogoroshi (Solist); Ward: xvart (success) - Saved from Death (Mutilation, lost Rez Kit) - Heard Noise, Bloody
Night 7 - Greater Ritual: Seacore (Obsession); Craft: Iecerint (success), Nachomamma8 (success), VasudeVa (success, Hallucination) - Bloody
Night 8 - Greater Ritual: VasudeVa (Denial); Pass: Nicodemus (success), totallynotmafia (success), Trilobite (success) - Heard Noise; Bloody
Night 9 - Greater Ritual: Trilobite (Sociopathy); Ward: Triglav (failure, Necrophilia) - In Denial (Marked) - Heard Noise; Bloody
At Death - Possessed nothing; Insanity Count: 8*

---BENMAGE---INVESTIGATOR
Night 0 - Stalk: Fate (success, Obsession)
Night 1 - Stalk: SpyreX (success, Suicidal) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Rob: Fate (success; took Occult Books; Solist); Murder: SpyreX (failure, Taboo: Occult Books) - Bloody
Night 3 - Launder - Heard Noise
Night 4 - Rob: El Goosuki (success, Marked); Rob: SpyreX (success, Mutilation) - Passed Fetish (Twitchy) - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Rob: Wraith (success, Necrophilia); Rob: Baby Spice (success, Compulsion) - Heard Noise
Night 6 - Rob: Plum (success, Denial); Stalk: kunkstar7 (failure, Hallucination)
Night 7 - Rob: Andrius (success, Insanity irrelevant); Search: Resuscitation Kit - In Denial (Insanity irrelevant) - Heard Noise
Night 8 - Rob: kunkstar7 (success, Insanity irrelevant); Resuscitate: Nicodemus (failure) - In Denial (Insanity irrelevant) - Heard Noise
Night 9 - Rob: Triglav (success, Insanity irrelevant); Resuscitate: Nicodemus (failure) - Heard Noise
At End - Possessed Resuscitation Kit; Insanity Count: 15*

---NICODEMUS/BOWSER---INVESTIGATOR
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 1 - Resuscitate: hitogoroshi (failure)
Night 2 - Resuscitate: hitogoroshi (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - COWER (Twitchy)
Night 4 - Resuscitate: Seacore (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Resuscitate: Seacore (success, lost Rez Kit) - Passed Fetish (Solist) - Heard Noise; Bloody
Night 6 - Launder - Heard Noise
Night 7 - COWER (Compulsion)
Night 8 - Search: Forensic Tools - Passed Fetish (Obsession) - Heard Noise
Night 9 - Investigate: Nachomamma8 (failure) - Heard Noise
At End - Possessed Forensic Tools; Insanity Count: 4

---NACHOMAMMA8/NOPOINTINACTINGUP/SUPER SMASH BROS. FAN---INVESTIGATOR
Night 0 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 1 - Resuscitate: Wickedestjr (success, lost Rez Kit) - Bloody
Night 2 - Launder - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Search: Occult Books - Heard Noise
Night 4 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 5 - Resuscitate: VP Baltar - Heard Noise
Night 6 - COWER (Twitchy) - Heard Noise
Night 7 - Stalk: xvart (Compulsion) - Heard Noise
Night 8 - Resuscitate: Iecerint (failure) - Passed Fetish (Obsession) - Heard Noise
Night 9 - Resuscitate: Iecerint (failure) - Heard Noise
At End - Possessed Occult Books and Resuscitation Kit; Insanity Count: 3

---TOTALLYNOTMAFIA---INVESTIGATOR
Night 0 - Search: Forensic Tools
Night 1 - Search: Resuscitation Kit - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Investigate: xvart (failure)
Night 3 - Investigate: Wickedestjr (success, lost Forensic Tools)
Night 4 - Resuscitate: xvart (failure)
Night 5 - Stalk: VP Baltar (success, Twitchy) - Heard Noise
Night 6 - Murder: VP Baltar (failure, Solist, lost Rez kit) - Bloody
Night 7 - Stalk: kunkstar7 (success, Obsession) - Bloody
Night 8 - Launder - Passed Fetish (Hallucination) - Heard Noise
Night 9 - Search: Resuscitation Kit - Heard Noise
At End - Possessed Resuscitation Kit; Insanity Count: 4

---IECERINT/MANHO/WINGLESS---INVESTIGATOR
Night 0 - Search: Forensic Tools
Night 1 - Search: Resuscitation Kit
Night 2 - Resuscitate: Furpants_Tom (failure) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Resuscitate: nopointinactingup (failure)
Night 4 - Stalk: Baby Spice (failure, Twitchy) - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Stalk: AurorusVox (success, Taboo: Resuscitation Kit) - Heard Noise
Night 6 - Stalk: kunkstar7 (failure, Solist, lost Rez Kit)
Night 7 - Stalk: Benmage (success, Hallucination) - Heard Noise
Night 8 - Investigate: VP Baltar (success, lost Forensic Tools) - Passed Fetish (Obsession) - Heard Noise
Night 9 - Stalk: VP Baltar (failure, Compulsion) - Heard Noise
At End - Possessed nothing; Insanity Count: 5

---XVART---INVESTIGATOR
Night 0 - Ward: MagnaofIllusion (success) - Heard Noise
Night 1 - Ward: El Goosuki (success) - Heard Noise
Night 2 - Stalk: Furcolow (success, Twitchy) - Heard Noise
Night 3 - Murder: Furcolow (success, Solist) - Passed Fetish (Obsession) - Heard Noise, Bloody
Night 4 - Rob: Furcolow (success, Suicidal); Launder - Heard Noise
Night 5 - Stalk: Benmage (failure, Compulsion) - Heard Noise
Night 6 - Search: Forensic Tools - Heard Noise
Night 7 - Rob: Andrius (success, Necrophilia); Rob: AurorusVox (success, Mutilation) - Heard Noise
Night 8 - Rob: hitogoroshi (success, Distraction); Rob: Paranoia (success, Paranoia)
Night 9 - Rob: VasudeVa (success, Sadism); Investigate: Benmage (success, lost Forensic Tools)
At End - Possessed nothing; Insanity Count: 10

Successes and failures may not all be accurate but etc.

[Lost Butterfly]

So glad we died >_>

Our reads weren't bad though actually but still 221 pages. Ehhh.

[Vi]

Fun notes about the actions.

Scum didn't hear any Noise N0. That means nobody targeted any of them with anything.

Almost all of Plum's Noise was due to people Investigating her every Night.

All of Iecerint's Insanities were from Stalks. Iecerint never tried to Murder.

All but one of VasudeVa's actions (Search doesn't count) failed. Trilobite wasn't far behind.

As a general rule, until the scum had to scramble they had fewer Insanities than the Town.

[Lost Butterfly]

Triglav I kept getting confused with Trilobite. I still don't know which one was scum and which one was town...>_>"

Also this, I'm pretty sure I got them confused more than once on day 1 but I thought at least one of them was scum >_>

[Vi]

Commentary.

At this point the game as it has been run has been cracked. If this game comes up again, there will necessarily be a different mechanic to play with.

Complaints about the game being overcomplicated are entirely warranted. It was just a bit too much for the mods to take care of, and it's not much of a surprise that the players got confused too. Granted, this is more a feature of the setup than a bug, but etc.

Vote-based Insanities (except Suicidal) are terrible ideas from a mod-maintenance point of view.

One of the major reasons the game was cracked is because the Investigators held together and monitored every action. While this is within the spirit of how Percy envisioned the game, it wasn't in mine and it's in

neither

of ours at this point. Half the point of things like vote-based Insanities is that the scum want to try to slip it by the watchful eyes of the Town; organized testing defeats the purpose. I'm pretty sure the players didn't find it all that fun to go through, either.
To that end, I believe the best solution is to cut deadlines WAY way down to the point where keeping track of actions and ordering people around would simply be infeasible within the time limit. One can argue that that would push the balance back into scum's favor, but that can be worked with. I'm coming to buy into 10-day deadlines in general, because that's about when Days start stagnating even in other games. Two weeks for D9 and D10 were too much.

In the future, if you're Cult, consider NOT Warding people who are being Stalked. (But consider Resuscitating them.~)

ReaperCharlie has a wiki term to put up now that this game is over.

Thank you for playing!

[Zachrulez]

I'm actually surprised cult didn't try wifom ressing townies that were stalked.

[VP Baltar]

In the future, if you're Cult, consider NOT Warding people who are being Stalked. (But consider Resuscitating them.~)

I don't know how sustainable that plan is.

[Iecerint]

I don't think it was really game-breaking. It trades the (significant) utility of Occult Books for a limited number of free vigs that cripple the town. That's not to mention situations like mine where someone got 6 insanities from being ordered to stalk and restalk and restalk and restalk over and over.

Why did cult start claiming more insanities than they had at the end? Makes no sense to me.

[Fate]

gg yay town win!

*counts it*

[chesskid3]

>modkilled.
>counts as win
nope.jpg?

[Iecerint]

It also makes the town more vulnerable to Murderer defection, though that didn't happen this game.

[Zachrulez]

Modkills are usually an autoloss for the offending party.

[VP Baltar]

Why did cult start claiming more insanities than they had at the end? Makes no sense to me.

That was actually from the beginning of the game when we thought occult books would be in play more. We were stock piling them so we'd always show up as "not more insane" than everyone else. It didn't really hamper us in any way and was a good safety mechanism just in case. That's why meat shield cult members like Baby Spice and Spyrex had so many insanities at their flips.

[hitogoroshi]

Best Town decision of the game IMO? xvart murdering Furc. It cleared up a mislynch in the offing and confirmed him as non-scum.

I disagree with this. I don't think furcolow would have been mislynched (he certainly wouldn't have been until I was dead, at any rate). The one-shot vig is, in my mind, for killing scum, with the confirming as a bonus. No offense, xvart, but Furcolow was a terrible, terrible shot.

[Vi]

In the future, if you're Cult, consider NOT Warding people who are being Stalked. (But consider Resuscitating them.~)

I don't know how sustainable that plan is.

*Townies who are being Stalked

[hitogoroshi]

paging through the QT

Yo Spyrex, you're my boy and all, but stop bringing up this murderer plan thing. It's bad for us in a lot of ways.

I'm holding onto a shitstorm making it fall apart (because, I still think that would have been the right thing to do)

SUP SPY