Mini 1180: Game Over

[Secret Project]

You have cast weakly supported accusations at a total of four players;

I'm going to sleep now, but I just want to point out how unbelievably hypocritical this is. Pac, you can take this one, if you want =P

[jilynne1991]

Ok, can someone really quickly list out all the reasons I might be scum again? Since, right now, I'm super confused.

Also, something about Wormy makes me think he's scum, but I've tried to read his posts in iso, and I haven't found exactly what's setting off my radar. I'll try to post something about it in the near future unless he somehow proves he's town to me.

Ironhead...makes me wonder. Logically, I feel like he's scum, but he's not setting off my radar in anyway, and my gut feeling is that he's a not-so-smart townie. So, in a nutshell, those two are the ones that I think might be scum, but I'm not voting either, since I have nothing on them yet.

[Captain Corporal]

Jily seems newbtown to me.

[jilynne1991]

Explain why, please? (No, the not the newbie part, but the townie part.)

[Captain Corporal]

Ok... I've read over IronHead's ISO, and I have to say, I am picking up town vibes. Although, I will take Gerhards advice, and I'll read over him and Martin a little more closely.

P-EDIT:
Just a gut feeling, Jily. I still need to read over the whole thread to pickup some good reads, though.

[jilynne1991]

Question to everyone: are gut feelings good? And if they can be bad and good, when are they bad, and when are they good?

[Captain Corporal]

Gut feelings have found me scum before, but they aren't always reliable. It is good to back them up with evidence, but when none is available, it is better tan nothing. Which is the situation I'm in at the moment, until I can assess some of your posts properly.

[Ironhead]

Question to everyone: are gut feelings good? And if they can be bad and good, when are they bad, and when are they good?

They are good for figuring out your suspect list; you can narrow down the players to a short list of suspects to analyze, war-game, and pressure. Trust your instincts in this regard. But I do not recommend pressing a case on someone based solely on a gut feeling -- if you don't have something concrete to present to other players to persuade them of your case, you're not going to get the player lynched.

[jilynne1991]

Oh, ok, thanks! If I think someone's scum based on a gut feeling, should I share it with everyone or not?

[Secret Project]

I wonder if he plays every single game like this.

[Secret Project]

Jily seems newbtown to me.

^Hasn't read

[mastin2]

jily, go ahead and give your gut suspicion. I'll Defend ya from all the meanies who tease such things.

[jilynne1991]

...wormykrew and secret project, but I think my suspicion of secret project might be because, I don't like him... =_=

[mastin2]

It's okay, Jily. That suspicion is fine.

I, myself, personally concluded that I was finding it EXTREMELY hard to conclude both Hydras were town, and that one HAD to be scum due to certain interactions. (They're in my notes, somewhere.) So, yeah. You're fine. ^_^

[jilynne1991]

It's okay, Jily. That suspicion is fine.

I, myself, personally concluded that I was finding it EXTREMELY hard to conclude both Hydras were town, and that one HAD to be scum due to certain interactions. (They're in my notes, somewhere.) So, yeah. You're fine. ^_^

Sometime, when you have time, could you expand on that and explain a little more?

[Secret Project]

Trust me, after I game where I had a huge gut feeling on vollkan being scum and got lynched because I was tunneling it but not explaining and I ended up being right, I really believe in gut.

[Secret Project]

I'm thinking I wanna lynch krew though. I mean I want his help on the Ironhead lynch but that's just getting annoying to try to push cuz then I have to read Ironhead's replies to it and I'd much prefer to ignore him right now. Maybe it'll get him to talk about something else. We'll leave this one up to you mastin but we've already agreed we're not letting you have your way with the town for the whole game.

Anyway. alex or krew?

[Secret Project]

I don't like him... =_=

Pretty sure that's what we had on you too until you town slipped.

[Secret Project]

I don't like him... =_=

Pretty sure that's what we had on you too until you town slipped.

Also when you say him, you probably mean me. Marill's been slightly better about handling you.

[mastin2]

Krew. Hands-down.
(The question is, who's The Master, and Who is the apprentice? )

[jilynne1991]

^agrees with above, since I don'twanna lynch someone cuz i don't like him...that's stupid

[Secret Project]

unvote, vote: krew

[jilynne1991]

Vote: WormyKrew

So, everyone, who are the top 2 candidates for a lynch here? Everyone please reply.

[Captain Corporal]

Secret Project, what do you mean by "Does he play every single game like this"? I flipped through the thread and my gut said newbtown. Calm down.

I would say WormyKrew and Secret Project are my top two scum, but agin, gut feelings, nothing to lynch on... Yet. I STILL need to read some ISO. Sorry everyone for my laziness, but hey. As long as we get the scum in the end, it's all good. I mean, we have plenty of time. No need to rush.

[mastin2]

WARNING: Krew is likely dangerously close--or potentially past--being lynched. I'll see if I can confirm via the votecount.