Fine. I'll post what I have.
Flavour Analysis #56 - do not like this post.
Flavour Analysis wrote:Reads:
Elli - Self voting.
Silavour: For being hypocritical, and hunting for weak reasons to prey on others like Zel1nk.
I'm cool with a wagon on either of these guys and I don't give a fuck what Fate think's because he is obviously wrong.
In other words, he's picked two people that have made "standard mafia tells" without considering the context as to those tells.
You'd be happy with a LYNCH on either? Really? Strong words. This is disguised policy and no one has any reason to hide it.
...since you're hiding it, you're not aware it's disguised policy and are just inventing reasons for a lynch.
ZeLink #71 -
ZeLink wrote:Unvote
VOTE: Flavour Analysis
#50, #51, #53, #60, #61... Whatever, just every post he's made.
His lack of stated reason for voting FA while taking the time to actually show the posts of FA's that are scummy (in other words,
trying to look like he's done some work) do not sit well with me.
Flavour Analysis #82 - somehow I must have missed this post in my original read. Yay, some emotion.
Fate #103 -
Fate wrote:K, FA is confirmed scum.
No town would go "oh Ive been daykilled? Let me claim all my shit..."
Nope.
If you really WERE daykilled, you'd die and flip Zebra.
If you WERENT you just claimed VT for no reason.
SO LOLDIE
Basically waht I've been saying to CKD this whole time. I don't see CKD pressuring fate. Translation? CKD/Fate are scumbuddies OR
Fate is town and CKD is scum trying to pick a fight with someone who won't cause complete chaos (ie. me --> but he's actually mistaken
I am more than capable)
Townread on jilynne #137 "contempt towards Fate but no wagon joining since doesn't think he's scum but if keep going on like that
will lynch him"
CKD #167 is the first time he asks me to explain my FA vote. I do so in #171. Based on what I've read, that should be enough --- but
noooo, he has to fabricate a case against me. Completely scum motivated. It's not scumhunting and it's not proper use of logic.
(He then responds in #177 to my response that "FA's response was unnatural" -- which should be enough, right? It completely and
utterly explains my vote. Yet he insists on carrying through with his bogus form of "scumhunting". The logic is terrible, and my
vote really should be on him)
It's post #178 and I still haven't figured out why Snarky is being voted for.
I'm confident at least one of Ellibereth and CKD is scum. Based on the above, it's more likely to be CKD.
Lowell is scum thuogh for #226. Way to not read any part of the game. Or have any opinions.
Amrun #232 is suspect. I feel like the first sentence is intentionally trying to cause confusion. (or maybe it's just confusing me?)
HezLucky #233 -- clear frustration that CKD is ASKING THE SAME F$^#^% QUESTIONS OVER AND OVER. I don't think he's a dumbass. Hence,
scum. (I lovelovelove that line of reasoning! Don't even need to meta to check that)
DeityKabuto #237 --- town read. LMFAO. This is the DK i remember from Open 302.
Dislike Snarky #247. This is purely because his read doesn't match up with mine. I've played exactly one game with DeityKabuto (we both
made it to the end as town and got endgamed) and read him as town off one post (and I'm more conservative than most of you with reading
people off one post) ... yet from the tone of Snarky's post, it seems like, in theory, he should be more familiar with DK's meta than
I am. His vote is suspect.
ZeLink #286 - really? you want to call DK scum because he said something stupid like "scum always claim VI"? Yet you claim to know his
meta. You're either not thinking straight or you are scum going for an easy lynch.
In general: I'm uncomfortable with people who are pushing the Snarky wagon because he "supposedly" rolefished. His question re:
Ellibereth/Fate was quite legitimate. I would have asked the same thing, and I think there is at least one scum who is helping in
blowing this out of proportion.
silavor #297 is SO STUPID. How can you reach this conclusion from who Peregrine calls scummy? I could call 10 people scummy, yet that
doesn't mean I'm dense enough to think there are 10 scum.
ZeLink #302 - I agree with DK being detrimental to the town in LyLo. I was scared to daeth of that in Open 302. Thankfully, we lost
the gaem before then.
Lowell #307 - god damn Lowell has done nothing this game. Every post of his is "Vote this person here are some generic sounding reasons
that have probably already been mentioned. Also I might throw in an FOS. That's it. Man I love lurking and makign it look like I'm
contributing". scuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuum
FA #310 - Don't like his vote on Earworm here. It seems similar to CKD's vote on me later on for "preventing scumhunting". Very forced,
easy (read: opportunistic) to attack and not something that indicates someone is scum.
Snarky #320 - I agree with his response to evilpacman's analysis of Altilysian. HOWEVER, when I read evilpacman's post I saw where he
was coming from with the Alti bit. Thus, while Snarky is correct in his reasoning, this is nowhere near a strong enough tell in any
manner for Snarky to be putting evilpacman on his scumlist. Snarky scum-read here.
elvis_knits #324 is GREAT. It basically says what I said in response to Snarky #320. Some inconsistencies are inconsequential, and it's
GREAT that elvis_knits is calling people out on this. Town-read
ZeLink #327 - Really? "HE IS TOWN" is a slip? On the contrary, I get a townread on Snarky for the exact same reason, as I don't think
scum would so strongly and vigilantly defend someone who isn't obvtown (but a town who strongly believes would). Thus, scumread on
ZeLink for this bs.
CKD #331 - CKD is once again completely missing the point here. This has nothing to do with "claiming day one", and everything to do
with "claiming in response to a supposed daykill".
Agree with Amrun #334 - this obsession on finding slips is absurd.
silavor #337 seems fake in the sense that I've seen CKD constantly ask questions, and it almost seems like silavor is trying to mimic
CKD's style of play in order to make it look like he's scumhunting.
ZeLink #341 is a good post though. The "coasting scum" was a strong bit (as I was about to type out "but how is this a scumtell?")
silavor #350/#352 ... you have got to be kidding me. Massive backtracking here. It was inherently very obvious that you were trying
to point that out as a slip. It would have been better for you if you had stuck vehemently to your wrong position, rather than try
and change it to something that nobody is going to believe. (and #362 -- is this guy a VI?)
DK's "speculator" #377 is gold. Had me in stitches for a full minute. (just imagine Nappa from DBZ Abridged saying "speculator")
elvis_knits #379 - really don't understand e_k's obsession over this "5 man slip" business.
Agree with PeregrineV #383 ... the "do you have a minimum criteria for calling someone scum?" business. It's probably how I would have
responded to the post myself.
HezLucky #385 -- CKD. Yes. You are distracting me from scumhunting. I could've reread this thread a long #$%#%#%#% time ago instead I
had to deal with your completely useless questions that I had ALREADY ANSWERED. What? You're afraid I'll find something?
Alti #387 - it's called "acting". The scum will say "dammit I was town" and peopel will tihnk "oh he must be telling the truth seeing
as he's already dead" ... but in fact, if the daykill was fake the scum just gained huge townie points in people's eyes. Town have no
motivation to do this. Too self-preservationist (although now that I think about it, it's entirely possible the Elli/FA exchange was
a setup and they aer both scum)
populartajo #395 --- faaaaaaaaaaaaake.
tajo wrote:AGAIN? THIS IS ENOUGH, I DON'T NEED TO READ ANYMORE
Really? You expect me to believe that was a legitimate response? Welcome to my wagon. Population scum.
(although you can't all be scum... :shrug:)
though I do agree with your Page 2 analysis on FA. The caustic town bit seems credible. Townread for FA on that post.
ZeLink #399 - his explanation is partially why I believe DK is town. Though if I were scum, I would give the exact same explanation so
this does not mean anything for ZeLink's alignment himself.
Cirno #400 - wow this is worse than me.
I read up to #411 I'm going to post it now.
