Mystery Box Mafia - Game Over

[Empking]

Emp. DK.

You not getting it right.

Why?

Finding DK scum is not possible unless he's found guilty, slipped or something else that's tangible and leads to scum. His entire meta leads to a null basis because of his incoherent and outright horrible logic.

I thought you knew this.

I refuse to accept that. At least wrt his RC vote, this isn't about playstyle but an absolute scum tell.

[kunkstar7]

Vote Count:

ReaperCharlie(4)

- xvart, inHimshallibe, hohum, DeityKabuto

CooLDoG(1)

- Primate

inHimshallibe(1)

- Sathoris

xvart(3)

- Kublai Khan, MagnaofIllusion, CooLDoG

Primate(1)

- Rikana

DeityKabuto(1)

- Empking

Not Voting(8)

- danakillsu, DeathNote, SpyreX, LobsterCatapult , Neruz, jmj3000, ReaperCharlie, Junox

With 19 alive, it is 10 to lynch.
Deadline:

(expired on 2011-07-29 11:10:00)

[SpyreX]

Finding DK scum is not possible unless he's found guilty, slipped or something else that's tangible and leads to scum. His entire meta leads to a null basis because of his incoherent and outright horrible logic.

I thought you knew this.

Ohhh META well then.

Unvote, Vote: DK

[Neruz]

Wait what, why is DK scum?

[SpyreX]

Spoiler: DK ISO - RC

Post restrictions are always null-reads.

Threat, possibly.

Reaper, can you stop the rapid multi-posting, it's spam.

Unvote
Vote ReaperCharlie

I am not putting up with your shit, maybe if people pile votes on you, you will stop.

Vote ReaperCharlie

The cause of deaths made me lol.

I'm one of the few town left.

5 kills one day...

Please, lynch RC so we can play..

37 Pages, D2.

Lynch ReaperCharlie. I have a feeling, he may turn out scum, I mean with 5 dead N1, the chances increases.

I for one, am town, Idc if you don't believe me..

Cooldog, scum could obv. be flying on the post restriction radar, so thanks.

I am not one of them, but I refuse to play this game normally until the

constant walls are gone

. *cough* RC

The other posts? Mostly Yami white knighting.

Take them away and what do you have? Nothing! Except Rikana of the short list defending this under "2bad4scum"

[Neruz]

Hmm, you make a compelling argument.

[DeityKabuto]

Spoiler: DK ISO - RC

Post restrictions are always null-reads.

Threat, possibly.

Reaper, can you stop the rapid multi-posting, it's spam.

Unvote
Vote ReaperCharlie

I am not putting up with your shit, maybe if people pile votes on you, you will stop.

Vote ReaperCharlie

The cause of deaths made me lol.

I'm one of the few town left.

5 kills one day...

Please, lynch RC so we can play..

37 Pages, D2.

Lynch ReaperCharlie. I have a feeling, he may turn out scum, I mean with 5 dead N1, the chances increases.

I for one, am town, Idc if you don't believe me..

Cooldog, scum could obv. be flying on the post restriction radar, so thanks.

I am not one of them, but I refuse to play this game normally until the

constant walls are gone

. *cough* RC

The other posts? Mostly Yami white knighting.

Take them away and what do you have? Nothing! Except Rikana of the short list defending this under "2bad4scum"

So wtf is your reason for voting me o.o

Die scum!

Unvote
Vote SpyreX

The statement made earlier that you can't find someone scum until proven guilty may be true, but my gut is saying you are scum.

You are using the situation to an advantage just like everyone else, you haven't contributed any this game, as haven't I. The game itself is unstable, and I am town, and if you push on my wagon more, you will only feel like scum to me.

[CooLDoG]

Spoiler: DK ISO - RC

Post restrictions are always null-reads.

Threat, possibly.

Reaper, can you stop the rapid multi-posting, it's spam.

Unvote
Vote ReaperCharlie

I am not putting up with your shit, maybe if people pile votes on you, you will stop.

Vote ReaperCharlie

The cause of deaths made me lol.

I'm one of the few town left.

5 kills one day...

Please, lynch RC so we can play..

37 Pages, D2.

Lynch ReaperCharlie. I have a feeling, he may turn out scum, I mean with 5 dead N1, the chances increases.

I for one, am town, Idc if you don't believe me..

Cooldog, scum could obv. be flying on the post restriction radar, so thanks.

I am not one of them, but I refuse to play this game normally until the

constant walls are gone

. *cough* RC

The other posts? Mostly Yami white knighting.

Take them away and what do you have? Nothing! Except Rikana of the short list defending this under "2bad4scum"

So wtf is your reason for voting me o.o

Die scum!

Unvote
Vote SpyreX

The statement made earlier that you can't find someone scum until proven guilty may be true, but my gut is saying you are scum.

You are using the situation to an advantage just like everyone else, you haven't contributed any this game, as haven't I. The game itself is unstable, and I am town, and if you push on my wagon more, you will only feel like scum to me.

Ohh my eyes!

Read the friggin' post man. You are blatantly attacking RC for his post restriction. And on that alone. You don't even try to find a scummy post made by RC, just that he is posting and has a moderate wagon him is enough for you to vote for him.

Voting block is go:

Die Scum!

unvote, Vote: DK

Also, stop trying to look town with those silly "Die scum", "Scum could obv...", and "I am town" one-liners. We know you are just tring to look town.

Xvart, DK, Rikana (something bugs me about her, for some reason.) scum team anybody?

[DeityKabuto]

Spoiler: DK ISO - RC

Post restrictions are always null-reads.

Threat, possibly.

Reaper, can you stop the rapid multi-posting, it's spam.

Unvote
Vote ReaperCharlie

I am not putting up with your shit, maybe if people pile votes on you, you will stop.

Vote ReaperCharlie

The cause of deaths made me lol.

I'm one of the few town left.

5 kills one day...

Please, lynch RC so we can play..

37 Pages, D2.

Lynch ReaperCharlie. I have a feeling, he may turn out scum, I mean with 5 dead N1, the chances increases.

I for one, am town, Idc if you don't believe me..

Cooldog, scum could obv. be flying on the post restriction radar, so thanks.

I am not one of them, but I refuse to play this game normally until the

constant walls are gone

. *cough* RC

The other posts? Mostly Yami white knighting.

Take them away and what do you have? Nothing! Except Rikana of the short list defending this under "2bad4scum"

So wtf is your reason for voting me o.o

Die scum!

Unvote
Vote SpyreX

The statement made earlier that you can't find someone scum until proven guilty may be true, but my gut is saying you are scum.

You are using the situation to an advantage just like everyone else, you haven't contributed any this game, as haven't I. The game itself is unstable, and I am town, and if you push on my wagon more, you will only feel like scum to me.

Ohh my eyes!

Read the friggin' post man. You are blatantly attacking RC for his post restriction. And on that alone. You don't even try to find a scummy post made by RC, just that he is posting and has a moderate wagon him is enough for you to vote for him.

Voting block is go:

Die Scum!

unvote, Vote: DK

Also, stop trying to look town with those silly "Die scum", "Scum could obv...", and "I am town" one-liners. We know you are just tring to look town.

Xvart, DK, Rikana (something bugs me about her, for some reason.) scum team anybody?

You idiot.

My logic for voting RC may be shit...

But your logic for voting me for voting RC is also shit.

Someone voting someone based on being annoyed by their post restriction is not a fucking scum tell, you are simply annoyed by the fact the I am annoyed by a post restriction and you think that is a scum tell, huh?

Well it's not.

Now you think by posting everyone voting RC and labeling them as scum is your method of scumhunting, it's shit. None of us are scumhunting, your tactics are fail.

I am town, and that's why your strategy is easily flawed.

Just because I vote RC based on his post restriction, doesn't make me guilty, kthx.

You could be scum yourself, by taking the advantage and trying to persuade others by saying that everyone voting RC is scum.

AND I ROFL HOW YOU ARE DEFENDING RC.

There are 5 kills a day, the chances of RC being scum are increased, and I know I'm town. But a post restriction like RC is a threat, so I don't see why not get rid of him. If he can't post normally, than that's like saying "Hey I'm a disabled child, I'm an excuse for being scum, so overlook me!". It's not freaking fair like that, I hope you understand where I'm coming from and I ask you fucking remove your votes because I AM FUCKING TOWN.

[Kublai Khan]

Okay, finished my re-read/skim for votes and positions on ReaperCharlie per SpyreX's request..

15 - ReaperCharlie starts 1-posting. Indicating that he opening his box early. If he's faking it, he did it clearly before most of the other restrictions.
195 - Juls is first to notice it.
222 - Mastermind of Sin notes super-early that alignment is independent of Rrestriction.
225 - Primate argues Mastermind of Sin's point.
226 - DeityKabuto says post restrictions are null reads
227 - ReaperCharlie confirms Restriction
230 - Primate thinks ReaperCharlie is lying. No vote.
258 - Hoopla calls ReaperCharlie's restriction bullshit. Lays foundation for other's votes.
261 - Neruz FOSes ReaperCharlie for implausible restriction
267 - Hoopla - "Real lynch or policy lynch. Lets just do it."
270 - Primate votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
285 - Hoopla questions ReaperCharlie's restriction again.
290 -294 - ReaperCharlie explains the syllables/phase thing
301 - Neruz votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
309 - Sathoris. Strongly doubts that ReaperCharlie is faking.
316 - Sathoris opens box and gets post restriction.
317 - DeityKabuto votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
329 - hohum votes ReaperCharlie for wagonning purposes(?)
338 - xvart votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
368 - MagnaofIllusion votes ReaperCharlie for being cheeky
396 - YamiChan votes ReaperCharlie because he's the biggest wagon.
403 - YamiChan reasons that ReaperCharlie is faking restriction
431 - danakillsu believes ReaperCharlie's restriction
449 - LobsterCatapult believes restriction
533 - Neruz unvotes ReaperCharlie because of Mastermind of Sin's restriction.

Day 2

801 - MagnaofIllusion questions ReaperCharlie's restriction
802 - xvart votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
813 - inHimshallibe votes ReaperCharlie. No reason given.
860 - hohum votes ReaperCharlie for wagonning purposes again.
865 - DeityKabuto votes ReaperCharlie. No reason given.

---
I think xvart, hohum, and DeityKabuto all come away as being scummy based on this analysis alone. The timing of Sathoris's 309-316 posts is also weird. I dislike any coincidences, as amusing as they may be.

[Kublai Khan]

Also, I want anyone who is voting DeityKabuto to note any previous playing experience they have with him.

[Empking]

Umbrage's open is a game both myself and DK were in.

[DeityKabuto]

Umbrage's open is a game both myself and DK were in.

Empking you got lynched D1.

[Empking]

Umbrage's open is a game both myself and DK were in.

Empking you got lynched D1.

1. No I didn't.
2. So?

[xvart]

No you didn't. It is not a stupid question. You simply have no understanding (and have proven that you don't by the above quote) of how RCs restriction works. You are simply going for the easy lynch.

Boy ohh boy, did we just take a shit? This my point. You have no idea what RC's restriction does. Simply put you are just voting to get someone lynched. RC had already said what his post restriction does (read his post with link). That was my point for asking the question... To see if you even knew what you were voting on.

As I've identified previously, I understand/understood the supposed mechanic that he gets increased words as the game goes on. What is misunderstood was the degree at which his supposed words can increase (phase vs. day). Even so, that has nothing to do with why I think he is lying and you arguing the semantics or my comprehension is just ridiculous.

Also, I was asking RC to clarify what his post restriction did... Just to make sure if it was a word a phase...

And this warranted the threat of vote on him because?

I'll use Kublai Khan's progress list to illustrate what I'm talking about:

15 - ReaperCharlie starts 1-posting. Indicating that he opening his box early. If he's faking it, he did it clearly before most of the other restrictions.
227 - ReaperCharlie confirms Restriction
258 - Hoopla calls ReaperCharlie's restriction bullshit. Lays foundation for other's votes.
285 - Hoopla questions ReaperCharlie's restriction again.
290 -294 - ReaperCharlie explains the syllables/phase thing

RC only added the ability to gain additional syllables after being put under significant pressure and the threat of lynching. Everything thing about his post restriction screams ridiculous and fake. The progress and evolution of his supposed fake restriction is damning enough evidence alone.

[DeityKabuto]

Okay, finished my re-read/skim for votes and positions on ReaperCharlie per SpyreX's request..

15 - ReaperCharlie starts 1-posting. Indicating that he opening his box early. If he's faking it, he did it clearly before most of the other restrictions.
195 - Juls is first to notice it.
222 - Mastermind of Sin notes super-early that alignment is independent of Rrestriction.
225 - Primate argues Mastermind of Sin's point.
226 - DeityKabuto says post restrictions are null reads
227 - ReaperCharlie confirms Restriction
230 - Primate thinks ReaperCharlie is lying. No vote.
258 - Hoopla calls ReaperCharlie's restriction bullshit. Lays foundation for other's votes.
261 - Neruz FOSes ReaperCharlie for implausible restriction
267 - Hoopla - "Real lynch or policy lynch. Lets just do it."
270 - Primate votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
285 - Hoopla questions ReaperCharlie's restriction again.
290 -294 - ReaperCharlie explains the syllables/phase thing
301 - Neruz votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
309 - Sathoris. Strongly doubts that ReaperCharlie is faking.
316 - Sathoris opens box and gets post restriction.
317 - DeityKabuto votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
329 - hohum votes ReaperCharlie for wagonning purposes(?)
338 - xvart votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
368 - MagnaofIllusion votes ReaperCharlie for being cheeky
396 - YamiChan votes ReaperCharlie because he's the biggest wagon.
403 - YamiChan reasons that ReaperCharlie is faking restriction
431 - danakillsu believes ReaperCharlie's restriction
449 - LobsterCatapult believes restriction
533 - Neruz unvotes ReaperCharlie because of Mastermind of Sin's restriction.

Day 2

801 - MagnaofIllusion questions ReaperCharlie's restriction
802 - xvart votes ReaperCharlie for fake restriction
813 - inHimshallibe votes ReaperCharlie. No reason given.
860 - hohum votes ReaperCharlie for wagonning purposes again.
865 - DeityKabuto votes ReaperCharlie. No reason given.

---
I think xvart, hohum, and DeityKabuto all come away as being scummy based on this analysis alone. The timing of Sathoris's 309-316 posts is also weird. I dislike any coincidences, as amusing as they may be.

You always act aggressive towards me, ofc. you would blindly say I'm scum without taking shit into consideration.

[DeityKabuto]

Also, I want anyone who is voting DeityKabuto to note any previous playing experience they have with him.

Read post 933

[Neruz]

Can anyone else make heads or tails of what the hell DK is trying to say? Because right now from where i'm standing it looks like he's throwing up an incomprehensible smoke screen to try and dodge the fact that his reasoning behind his RC vote is complete bollocks.

[DeathNote]

poor DK. You need to learn to be more like me and not base your own thoughts or attempt to appear town. Just follow someone who you think is town and then you wouldn't appear scummy to everyone else. Advice from one bad player to another.

[Kublai Khan]

There are 5 kills a day, the chances of RC being scum are increased, and I know I'm town. But a post restriction like RC is a threat, so I don't see why not get rid of him. If he can't post normally, than that's like saying

"Hey I'm a disabled child, I'm an excuse for being scum, so overlook me!"

. It's not freaking fair like that, I hope you understand where I'm coming from and I ask you fucking remove your votes because I AM FUCKING TOWN.

So you're angry that ReaperCharlie is co-opting your typical mafia survival strategy?

Lol hypocrite.

UNVOTE: xvart
VOTE: DeityKabuto

[Empking]

Umbrage's open is a game both myself and DK were in.

Empking you got lynched D1.

1. No I didn't.

2. So?

[DeityKabuto]

There are 5 kills a day, the chances of RC being scum are increased, and I know I'm town. But a post restriction like RC is a threat, so I don't see why not get rid of him. If he can't post normally, than that's like saying

"Hey I'm a disabled child, I'm an excuse for being scum, so overlook me!"

. It's not freaking fair like that, I hope you understand where I'm coming from and I ask you fucking remove your votes because I AM FUCKING TOWN.

So you're angry that ReaperCharlie is co-opting your typical mafia survival strategy?

Lol hypocrite.

UNVOTE: xvart
VOTE: DeityKabuto

You stupid?

How DFUCK does it make me a hypocrite?

[DeityKabuto]

FUCK. You guys are easy wagonning me, you don't care what my defense is, you just hop on the wagon, I dun give a shit anymore, there are probably 15 scum, since 5 Nkills happended, this game is scum ruled, so I don't care for anyone's opinion anymore.

[Kublai Khan]

DeityKabuto,

In your own words, your reasons for voting ReaperCharlie were shit. Voting for someone who votes others for shit reasons isn't a shit reason.

In this game, everyone will insist that they are town. So repeatedly insisting that you're town is meaningless. Calling people scum because they are voting you is a shit reason to call people scum.

Nobody is over-looking ReaperCharlie. Despite his restriction, he has given reasons for his votes that weren't shit. Saying that ReaperCharlie is now more likely to be scum because there are less players in the game then the day before is a

VERY SHITTY REASON

for voting him.

People who vote people for shitty reasons are more often scum than not. Therefore you are likely scum who IS LYING about being town. Because that it what scum do.

[CooLDoG]

People have already said what I would have said. I don't feel like posting before I have a rather enjoyable evening at a friends cook-out.

@xvart, read the bolded red spoiler tags. That should answer pretty much everything I have to say about you.

@DK, atleast you aren't bringing out the noob card... "I am town, and that's why your strategy is easily flawed." - prove it.