Toy Story Mafia (Day 9)

[glowball]

glowball I'd like to know what your read on Peregrine is and why you support a jmurph or beefster wagon.

clever clever- back up noted.

peregrine- not scum, possibly 3rd party or if another faction exists

jmurph is probscum

beefster is prob the same as peregrine

[glowball]

oh and don't think you'll get any more answers by continuing that line of questioning with back up. I don't play that, but I award creativity- just once.

[DeathNote]

Oh want my Character's name? - Lenny the Binoculars

I guess this is my que to step in.

I counter claim Lenny the Binoculars. I am really surprised at his claim.

[Ray Montano]

Now I'm really confused.

[petroleumjelly]

God, this game.

1.)

FlavourAnalysis, since you’ve claimed, would you mind explaining your use of capital letters in the middle of words? Now that I’m looking over your posts, you only seem to have this problem when you type the word “Day” (in ToDay, YeSterDay, etc.) Is this something you do in other games, too, or is it only confined to this game?

Also, now that I’m reading over your posts more closely, why did you start the game munching on donuts? That sounds far more suggest of a Cop crumb than it does a Vigilante crumb. Were you eating donuts in real life? Why did you make that post?

In fact, please link me to other games you have played, and more specifically, games you have breadcrumbed in. Do you breadcrumb often? Did you breadcrumb being Woody (or a Vigilante) at all?

2.)

@PJ: Please tell me what post you found from Nanook that was well thought out and looking at suspects because right now I'm not seeing reasoning that makes sense except Kendall.

I don’t recall saying Nanook’s posts were “well thought out and looking at suspects;” I said he was clearly not lurking, and that he’s been posting content.

But sure, even looking at Nanook’s posts right now, it’s pretty clear he has been looking at suspects, asking questions, and giving opinions. Just isolate him and this is pretty obvious to me. I’m not here to defend Nanook because I think he is Town – I really don’t have much of a read on him at all, in fact. But the case on him for “lurking” was so bad I felt I had to say something.

3.)

Concerning the Lenny the Binoculars claim, at first blush I’m leaning towards FourseenCircumstances being scum, if only because it seems unlikely DeathNote-scum would just decide to counterclaim out of the blue like this. But I will definitely need to sleep on it.

[TheJakalope]

Was there even pressure on FC to Name Claim?

[Flavour Analysis]

PJ

: Yes I do that in all my games. To emphasize game days. It's a habit.

That wasn't a crumb. I don't crumb. That was a joke. Before joining this game, I joked with Chkflip (on face book chat, he invited me to this game) saying I'd joke crumb OBVIOUSLY and LOUDLY, in my first post, regardless of what role I got. Beefster most likely saw that, and is TOWN from his reaction in his #962. Also, I do like donuts alot. I made it as obvious as possible. I do not think I could ever refer to that as a real crumb. I would try to be more subtle with a crumb if I were being serious.

I don't crumb so I don't have links to other games of me crumbing. : D I might crumb if I get better experience with PR's, but not so much at this point in my mafia career.

Concerning the CC. I am very giddy inside. I just am curious as to why FourseenSCUM would claim a char that could get him CC'd to his death. I do think it's best we wait for Fourseen's reaction. ;o

[Flavour Analysis]

Jakalope

: Farside and I asked him Fourseen to claim.

[TheJakalope]

Oh alright, then He's scum.

I was thinking that if no one asked him, then it wouldn't have been very prosperous as scum to name claim when there is a possibility that someone else had the role.

VOTE: FourseenCircumstance

[petroleumjelly]

4.)

And

wow

, I somehow missed glowball claiming Buster (Andy's dog), even though I definitely read his post where he claimed to have lied. I honestly have zero clue how I missed that. God, this game is so dumb. I don't even.

[Blonde Doctor]

7 pages just today...you guys are making it hard for me to keep up! O_o

Ok, so I've ISOed "myself" and the mod, and read up to the Kendall wagon, all while trying to keep up with this stupid activity!
-I was interested in seeing the whole tunneling point of view...apparently it generated the discussion it needed to, haha.

Kendall: I think you mixed up Jmurph with Beefster. (This means Kendall and Jmurph aren't the same alignment) What is your read on Beck?

-This is weird...it would only imply that if one is mafia, it's highly unlikely the other one is mafia as well; HOWEVER, this doesn't mean they can't both be town. Such a curious statement to not even acknowledge that possibility...
-re: the cop discussion (this was within a couple pages of my replacing in), I don't think a cop should investigate whomever is "scummiest" by the end of the day, because chances are they're going to be a pretty big target for a lynch the next day, and if you come up with an innocent, then you run the risk of either outing yourself to save a lynch, or having wasted an investigation on someone you can't save...if that makes sense?

I'm also ISOing Kendall and DonJosh (now petroleum).

Up through page 8:

-Speaking of which, it's worth noting Don's 129 is very curious...seems veeery much like he's avoiding anything scummy...but then he comes out right in the open and says "I won't do this because it LOOKS scummy"...wtf...
-In the next post Kendall points out that he thinks Beck is preemptively excusing himself from scummy behavior, where in the same vain RIGHT BEFORE Don does the same thing...selective "scumhunting"?
-keeping a vote on someone != tunneling...

Kendall wagon:

you are voting for me because i am trying too hard to be pro-town. how is someone exemplifying extreme pro-town behavior your first suspect to be mafia? that, in itself, is a logical fallacy.

-*sigh*
-I agree with Ray Montano when he said it seemed like all Kendall was doing was throwing spaghetti.
-Still going...oh boy...kind of facepalms all across the boarder with this one...I need to sleep before I can keep reading and swallow any more of this.
-Umbrage started the Kendall wagon...

[Flavour Analysis]

Hmmm, good point. Let me re-phrase. Essentially, because of that, they wouldn't be scum together. You are right, it could have been possible for both of them being town. Basically, if Kendall was scum, then obv Jmurph wouldn't be the same alignment as her. (Because she messed up the names, and she wouldn't forget a buddy) That was my line of thinking.

[bobsnox]

I go out of town for two days and I miss 10+ pages ;_;

Who needs to be lynched? Was that a CC on Fourseen?

[farside22]

Farside

: Yes, I answered it. I wanted to see the rest of your play, which I didn't like either. It was a slight suspicion. Again, it was scummy to me because you were bringing attention to something I have already explained. If you were in catch up you would have SEEN my explanation.

There was 2 pages I had read and made notes on, I don't recall which pages, but I type in a note pad, went to bed without saving and didn't have the energy to go back and reread to make notes further.
I recall looking back seeing your response to the question, but that's all I remember.
What other things? Vague does not work in this game with me.

I have a scum read on Glow. You take her AtE as a town tell and I feel you are wrong on that. I can understand you relating to her stating she is sad that no one is listening to her. I even felt that way with my MB53 wagon. But I don't think you are really judging her WHOLE play and I want to be a bit more open to that. If there is ANYTHING else you feel is a town tell, then I am open to considering it.

Will work on this later.
*put on to do list*

Alright well unless something else exciting happens tonight I'll be back tomorrow night. I'd like to see EVERYONE who hasn't commented tonight to run down all their thoughts on pretty much every player who has interacted tonight (myself, Flavour, Rainbow, farside, Spyrex, glowball, Fourseen, Nanook, diddin).

Unvote

Will work on this later.
*put on to do list*

Now I'm really confused.

This ^

I think Deathnote claim is odd. Watcher and Lenny make sense but a CC on a name claim..........
I'm thinking about this a bit.
This could be one for one exchange. Lynch one if it flips the character they claim, then the other is scum for sure........

Forseen proved he was a watcher and deathnote replaced Hirk so

unvote:
vote: Deathnote

Concerning the CC. I am very giddy inside. I just am curious as to why FourseenSCUM would claim a char that could get him CC'd to his death. I do think it's best we wait for Fourseen's reaction. ;o

Are you thinking scum have a watcher?

[NanookTheWolf]

Ok guys. Time to be blown away.

I targetted Soda. You want a reason? Check my last posts at the end of the Day.

I am Woody. Town 1 shot Vig. Thanks Fourseen for being a nub and outing me early. You're lucky I got no more bullets.

Beefster is confirmed town for #962

Ok,

I don't know why this wasn't brought up, but wasn't bogre aka woody and confirmed dead/town?

I wouldn't think that there'd be two woodys in the game.

Vote: FA

[farside22]

@Nanook: No. See front page by mod

Bogre, Andy (Town Jailkeeper) killed Night 1

[NanookTheWolf]

Right,

Got the two characters mixed up obviously,

unvote: FA

[farside22]

Also before I head to work. If anyone should paraphrase their role PM between Forseen and Deathnote. I would prefer Deathnote goes first as Forseen already proved his watcher claim and Deathnote hasn't proven dick.
Both should paraphrase their role PM.

That's just my POV on this.

[FourseenCircumstance]

Deathnote/FA Team all making sense now.

[farside22]

*Noted: Deathnote CC's the role name and does not vote Forseen.
Forseen has his name claimed CC'ed and doesn't vote for that player.

Oy my head

[FourseenCircumstance]

in this situation we kill either deathnote or FA today to clear one of us.

[Scott Brosius]

Vote Count 2-4

Beefster

(0)-

bobsnox

(0)-

Blonde Doctor

(0)-

chkflip

(1)- inHimshallibe,

DeathNote

(2)- diddin, farside22,

diddin

(0)-

farside22

(0)-

Flavour Analysis

(1)- FourseenCircumstance,

FourseenCircumstance

(1)- TheJakalope,

glowball

(0)-

inHimshallibe

(0)-

jmurph3

(0)-

mikehart

(1)- Rainbowdash,

NanookTheWolf

(4)- Flavour Analysis, SpyreX, DeathNote, PeregrineV,

PeregrineV

(0)-

petroleumjelly

(0)-

Rainbowdash

(0)-

Ray Montano

(0)-

Silver1337

(0)-

SpyreX

(0)-

TheJakalope

(0)-


Not Voting (11)- Beefster, bobsnox, Blonde Doctor, chkflip, jmurph3, mikehart, petroleumjelly, Silver1337, glowball, Ray Montano, NanookTheWolf,

With 21 alive, it's 11 to a lynch.

Deadline is September 4th at 3pm EST.

Replacing Beefster

[FourseenCircumstance]

unvote. vote: Deathnote

You don't CC a Name when I am confirmed watcher.

[inHimshallibe]

I watched soda because he was overly kind to me and seemed to have the best interest for the town.... only to find out that he was visited by FA.

HOLY HELL TWO FOR TWO?

This is a comeback game for me, I think.

[inHimshallibe]

nevermind. I remember who (who he wasn't) soda was now. -_______________________________________________________________-