Apologies for the slight wall; lots to respond to.
DeathNote wrote:Was the glow kill probably a vig kill? Why only one?
Well, either the vig kill was blocked, and glow was the scum kill, or the scum kill was blocked, and glow was the vig kill. What difference does it make to you?
farside22 wrote:Diddin: Any reason you are voting Murph there?
I know I had a scum read on him when I was reading over some players last night.
Mostly the defense of Umbrage and DJ and not saying much going on in the game.
When did I defend DJ?
Flavour Analysis wrote:@
Jmurph
: I want you to look at Beefster's #962, and tell me what that makes you think of him. Also consider that he plays the same way regardless of alignment.
It's probably the most town thing he posted during his entire time here, but one post does not make him town. And if he plays the same as town or scum, what makes you so sure that he's town, and not scum? I don't believe I've seen an explanation of this from you.
Rainbowdash wrote:Jmurph has the two random votes, the fact that his vote landed on Beefy and then stayed there for reasons that he never elaborated on but mentioned existed.
Pretty sure I explained that. The random vote on Beefster was because he lied, and I wanted to point that out. I kept my vote on him because he brushed it off in a manner that rubbed me the wrong way, and nothing he said after that merited a vote-switch.
Rainbowdash wrote:He makes what looks like a case on Umbrage, but then brushes him off as a VI using some other ponies logic for calling him such, and instead latching onto DJ for a one liner. While continuing to subtely push the Beefy lynch along, calling Umbrage a VI and jumping on the Peregrine hate. Its worth noting that Peregrine is likely town here.
I honestly thought that Umbrage was playing as a VI. It was completely my mistake for assuming that this then meant he was town. VI is almost always town simply because it's too risky for scum to pull it off (since VI almost always gets lynched fairly quickly to get him out of the game). This is why I was only marginally on the Umbrage wagon; I thought him likely to flip town, and wanted to keep options open for actually finding someone who was actually town. Not sure what you mean by Peregrine being likely town and my reaction, since I was hardly the only one who felt that way about Peregrine at the time.
Rainbowdash wrote:Now he is voting NtW who I suddenly have reason to think is town.
And it'd be real lovely if you could share those reasons.
NanookTheWolf wrote:Jmurph - I didn't suspect anything of Jmurph until just recently. Lurker, sure. Otherwise everything was good until #1537. She's sheeping and it's day 3. Never ever mentioned at any point in the game that she thought I was scum. Suddenly she votes because I never gave any satisfactory answers for inconsistencies and suchforth? That is crap. What were the questions Jmurph? If you thought this during day 2, then why not mention it? If you did a reread through the night, why not add a better reason to your vote?
Did you miss the part where I was V/LA for almost all of the incredibly short D2? I actually didn't even know a lynch had been reached until I found the thread locked and went forward to the last page. I hadn't caught up in time to make any comments, and I don't think a better reason for my vote was necessary, since my vote was a pressure vote.
As a pressure vote, I feel its mission has been accomplished. NtW isn't cleared in my book by any means, but his reaction has been well enough to alleviate the need for a vote on him. As such,
UNVOTE: .
What matters is, his WHOLE reaction was a bit iffy. "Your defense is that of town alignment" I don't think he'd let it go that easily.
