Mini 1217 - Campaign Mafia (Game Over!)

[hiplop]

looking back at his iso it's just fluff to me

no analysis or anything

Yeah, I admit I lurked. But I did post content, just victim of circumstance I suppose.

[Twistedspoon]

looking back at his iso it's just fluff to me

no analysis or anything

Yeah, I admit I lurked. But I did post content, just victim of circumstance I suppose.

so why should we (i say we, but I know you're conf. scum) believe you're town?

[Quilford]

ts without referring to hiplop please tell me why you're town 'coz i'm not seeing it

[Twistedspoon]

ts without referring to hiplop please tell me why you're town 'coz i'm not seeing it

hipop lurked and posted fluff

I analysed, made lists of reads, contributed

just iso the both of us and the result should be clear in 10 seconds

[Quilford]

'without referring to hiplop'

[Lurconis]

Twisted has pointed out that hilop mainly just lurked and posted little to no-content which to me is more scummy than how Twisted has been acting. Other than the maruchan hammer can someone who thinks twisted is scum explain it, cause I haven't seen it since then.

[Twistedspoon]

'without referring to hiplop'

so? I'm up against him so i have to be compared

I contribute he doesn't

I don't see what the problem is here

[Shadow Dancer]

looking back at his iso it's just fluff to me

no analysis or anything

Yeah, I admit I lurked. But I did post content, just victim of circumstance I suppose.

Doesn't explain why you're still doing it, though...

[Shadow Dancer]

ts without referring to hiplop please tell me why you're town 'coz i'm not seeing it

Then explain why twisted is scum, eh?!

[Quilford]

'without referring to hiplop'

so? I'm up against him so i have to be compared

I contribute he doesn't

I don't see what the problem is here

Twisted you do not have to be compared

You know this

[Packbat]

VOTE: hiplop

I'll move that if I have to.

which part of hiplop do you find most town?

His posts are tolerable - the only problem with them is that their kind of thin and sparse at the same time.

[Twistedspoon]

'without referring to hiplop'

so? I'm up against him so i have to be compared

I contribute he doesn't

I don't see what the problem is here

Twisted you do not have to be compared

You know this

I've said 100 times i contribute and analyse

hiplop doesn't

now tell me why the decision is so hard?

VOTE: hiplop

I'll move that if I have to.

which part of hiplop do you find most town?

His posts are tolerable - the only problem with them is that their kind of thin and sparse at the same time.

so I assume my posts aren't tolerable or something?

you haven't said why I'm scum?

[Twistedspoon]

you two are scraping the bottom of the barrel for reasons to vote hiplop over myself

[Lurconis]

This is very telling, no one here is giving any reasons for why twisted is scummy. If you think hiplop is town that is fine, his posts did read town but so did twisteds and twisted provided a hell of a lot more content and analysis. Twisted actually scumhunted this game. Hiplop sat on the sidelines this seems like a no-brainer to me. If you all disagree so much then fucking say why give your reasons for why twisted is scum instead of asking him to prove he is town. He has already done that from his actions starting Morning 2 on.

[Twistedspoon]

the only reason packbat is voting hiplop is because his few posts are 'tolerable'

so unless my posting is wholy untolerable to packbat and he hasn't mentioned it, that's the weakest excuse to vote hiplop over me I've ever seen.

Packbat clearly has a reason to vote hiplop; he knows he's on his side. Packbat just can't justify his hiplop vote from a town PoV

[hiplop]

so why should we (i say we, but I know you're conf. scum) believe you're town?

Theres no scum motives for anything i've done, I was trying to find scum, and I was keeping a long with the trhread, I just posted when I wanted to know something. I did lurk a little too much, and I'm sorry, but your case on me is just that, lurking. Town lurks just as much as scum, and if you look at my other games, I do tend to lurk as town.

[Twistedspoon]

so why should we (i say we, but I know you're conf. scum) believe you're town?

Theres no scum motives for anything i've done, I was trying to find scum, and I was keeping a long with the trhread, I just posted when I wanted to know something. I did lurk a little too much, and I'm sorry, but your case on me is just that, lurking. Town lurks just as much as scum, and if you look at my other games, I do tend to lurk as town.

you're justifying lurking here, not saying why we should believe you're town

you never scumhunted. You asked about 3 fluffy questions, the impact of which were zilch, and you had 1 unexplained reads list

that's it

no reason to see you as town, every reason to see me as so

of course, your two buddies are desparaately seraching for reasons to find you town, such as calling your posts 'tolerable'

it's a joke. An absolute joke

[hiplop]

Justifying lurking b/c thats all you've said.

[Packbat]

I've had a feeling that Twistedspoon's posting was ... artificial, since hiplop's nomination. Facts like his flip-flopping on whether hiplop's

ISO

was scummy (I've seen scum with towny ISOs) and his trying to paint showing up early when the thread reopened as scummy tend to push Twistedspoon farther from the townie end of the reads than he was before, for example.

Pre-Edit: Oh, and hiplop raises another good point - Twistedspoon took my answer to "which part of hiplop do you find most town?" and pretended that it was an answer to "why are you voting hiplop". I'm voting hiplop because I have been convinced that Twistedspoon is scum, not because I was convinced that TS was town.

[Twistedspoon]

I've had a feeling that Twistedspoon's posting was ... artificial, since hiplop's nomination. Facts like his flip-flopping on whether hiplop's

ISO

was scummy

obviously, because I say him as town but now he's become confirmed scum to me, it's only natural for my read to change

hiplop has done the same too (he had a town read on me yet he's saying I'm confirmed scum)

Yet you don't point this out

packbat, you are obvious scum

Pre-Edit: Oh, and hiplop raises another good point - Twistedspoon took my answer to "which part of hiplop do you find most town?" and pretended that it was an answer to "why are you voting hiplop". I'm voting hiplop because I have been convinced that Twistedspoon is scum, not because I was convinced that TS was town.

all y9ou've said is you find hiplop's posting 'tolerable'

that is all you have given me to work with

the reasons you're voting hiplop are pathetic. It's obvious you're voting him since he's your buddy

[Packbat]

Twistedspoon, why did you say hiplop was towny before he was selected to run against you today?

[Sunset]

Twistedspoon, why did you say hiplop was towny before he was selected to run against you today?

by PofE

because I was convinced I knew the scumteam and that hiplop had to be town for this to fit in

[Twistedspoon]

Twistedspoon, why did you say hiplop was towny before he was selected to run against you today?

by PofE

because I was convinced I knew the scumteam and that hiplop had to be town for this to fit in

[hiplop]

thats not what it looks like when i ISO you. Why are you trying to make it look like you doubted my towniness earlier? never did you mention PoE...

[Twistedspoon]

hiplop, I don't have the energy to humour you today

I have it on good authority that arguing with you is pointless

I've already explained that I believed I knew the scumteam so i convinced myself you were town. Twist this however you like, claim to read my iso however you like

all I've read is the vagueness of 'tolerable' on your part and 'artificial' on me that your buddy is trying to do to get away with voting you when it's obvious they'd do anything for a legit reason;

but there isn't one

you're a bad actor hiplop and I'm not going to waste any more time with you. The only reason you're still alive is because Johog assumed the rest of the townies would be able to see the forest for the trees, but so far only Luc has done this