SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[Bunnylover]

@DH: The only regret about RBT lynch is that I probably should have left it towards the vig to shoot her. She refused to claim, which means he either could not fathom a viable claim (Scum) or he wasn't playing the game towards his win condition.
An obvious lynch that would occur, a bad player in this game, and very anti-town. Having able to lynch RBT during day 1 where we could afford it if he flipped town was the right choice to do.

@Kcdaspot: Are you really trying to justify your vote? That just has scummy written all over it.

@DH: Don't ask me question if you are going to push my lynch without even waiting for a response from me. I stand by my vote and decision to lynch RBT. You are focusing on the person who Hammered RBT because I asked others if they thought he was scum. Did my vote not say I believe RBT would flip scum? I mean the whole, "Not something town would do," should obviously mean that I believed RBT will flipped scum at that point.
But that does not mean others believed RBT would flip scum. Some of the votes were placed not because RBT was scum, but because of her lack of defense which I don't understand how that is related to been scum.
At my vote, I was fully expecting RBT to flip scum.
But I also knew if RBT flipped town, it was no big lost. I rather lynch a townie on Day 1 instead of lynching a townie in MYLO, but of course I would always like to lynch scum.

[Kcdaspot]

my vote was already justified. my case on him. should be my 3rd post.

I dropped it cuz A. it got nowhere and B. several people noted a town tone in his defenses toward me. I took into account that they were seeing something i wasn't and so I let it lay.

and now I wanna try again.

Just to point out I'm still trying to see a town motive for calling me scum and then dropping it in 3 posts.
SURE, I can take into account the breakdown into account but he hasn't mentioned me since.

[Kcdaspot]

i put "into account" twice in one sentence but yeah.

[DemonHybrid]

BL: Was the way you went about voting RBT, yadda yadda.

[Kcdaspot]

Bunny gains scum points.

>one kill last night
>vig

What DO you know about the setup bunny?

[Kcdaspot]

DH you just made me REALLY uncomfortable. is the hammer on RBT your case or is there more?

[DemonHybrid]

Are you guys even listening? I'm voting BL for his uneasiness tiptoeing around the wagon and then hopping on when everyone was pushing for his hammer.

[Kcdaspot]

*reads iso, rereads and reads again*

Okay i'm sold.

BUT I DON'T WANNA LET PROJECTMATT GO.
UGGH.

DH. ISO Pm. Tell me what you see.

[Kcdaspot]

I mean i go to vote bunny but when i begin to type i get this icky feeling that mattscum will get off the hook.

[Bunnylover]

@Kcdaspot: I find it scummy that you would try to (re?)-justify your vote after the flip, I mean if you saw anyone else do it, wouldn't it raise question?
I know very little about the set-up, and what I know/guessing is me just assuming things.
In every set-up, I always assume their is a vig in the game. Regardless of how many flips their are due to the night, I always think a vig is in the game (plus looking at the person who was killed, its either a vig or sk trying to look townie).

@DH: I'm confused.

Preview Edit:
DH: What uneasiness are you talking about and what tiptoeing?

[Parabollocks]

Vote: stormer

[hiplop]

Vote: stormer

explaix?

[manho]

bunnylover feels like knowing RBT will flip town. good chance he's scum.

will read the thread again when i'm back home to decide where my vote is going, or staying.

[Parabollocks]

Vote: stormer

explaix?

once he pops his head up i will

[Bunnylover]

Vote: stormer

explaix?

Why do you want an explanation on this vote, when you said nothing about this:

VOTE: BunnyLover

?

[hiplop]

he had scum reads, though KCDA. Other than for getting an easy lynch, what other explanations are there for that vote? How about town motivation? Its scummy as fuck

u confused bunny?

[Bunnylover]

he had scum reads, though KCDA. Other than for getting an easy lynch, what other explanations are there for that vote? How about town motivation? Its scummy as fuck

u confused bunny?

Wasn't paying attention to timestamp, I thought your question on the vote was much closer to the vote.

[Kcdaspot]

hiplop:.. i may be confoosed are you talking DH's vote on bunny? or bunny's hammer?

[hiplop]

neither. Vifam on buddy this phase, just on the diddin thing

[Sunset]

VOTE: Bunnylover
Pretty sure there's at least one scum on the RBT wagon, maybe two. Bunnylover was fencesitting yesterday, not voting until she knew it was completely risk free.

[Sunset]

@mod: is there a final VC of d1?

Vote: RBT

Sorry, but eventually RBT is going to be a mislynch (assuming RBT is town) and I rather have it done on day 1 where we know we can afford to have a townie flip.

it's as though you knew RBT would flip town

at the very least, justifying a townie flip before you

should

know RBT would flip town is very suspect to me (as well as our D1 suspicions of you)


anyways, I'm looking back at the RBt wagon to see who emerges the most town (BL the most suspect obv, although jakalope comes close)

celebloki's #532 reads as genuine town frustration at RBT's play and his relucatnce to hammer without a claim among other things in his posts on RBT read as very town to me

we still feel PM is town, and not entirely because he completely avoided the RBT wagon

[Sunset]

we still feel PM is town

When did "we" start to feel that Matt's town? I'm afraid you forgot to tell me.

[stormer]

im all ears parabollocks.

[David Xanatos]

Catching up now..

[Hoppster]

Spoiler: Rant, yo. Beware formatting.

WHAT ZE FUCK GUYZ.

I

wanted

a Bunnylover wagon

yesterday

.

I was

pushing

a Bunnylover wagon

yesterday

.

Most people were

PERFECTLY HAPPY

to just

ignore

my case on Bunnylover, and those that did respond by and large dismissed it with

"lollll Bunnylover being Bunnyloverrrr"

.


So,

today

, I check the thread, and without ANY INPUT from me or ANY REFERENCE to my case,

lo and behold, a Bunnylover wagon

.

... DOES NOT COMPUTE

Overnight, you've gone from

"teehee let's pretend Bunnylover doesn't exist"

to

"OMGGGGG LET'S KILL BUNNYLOVER NOWWWWWWWWWWW".

That does not make sense at all.

Yes, the hammer was dodgy

but it was

no more dodgy than the rest of Bunnylover's play

.

tl;dr

SERIOUSLY WHY THE FUCK DID YOU ALL IGNORE MY BUNNYLOVER CASE YESTERDAY ONLY TO PUSH A BUNNYLOVER WAGON TODAY BEFORE I EVEN RE-ITERATE MY CASE?!

BL has failed to impress us, but then again, BL isn't the sort of player who makes a lot of analysis and I have come to expect this type of play from BL sadly.

VOTE: Bunnylover
Pretty sure there's at least one scum on the RBT wagon, maybe two. Bunnylover was fencesitting yesterday, not voting until she knew it was completely risk free.

???

Bunnylover: Please find a scum-read and/or somebody to vote. Thank you.

===============================================================================================================

In OTHER NEWS.

WrathChild, who was

a Yoshi

, aligned with the

Islanders

, was squished Night 1

gj vig.

oh hes a red yoshi...

Thinking this

might

be a scum-slip. Then again, it might just be hiplop being stupid/forgetful.

Prod Response.

I haven't posted because this day should be OVER.

RBT is today's lynch.

^^^^ needs death ASAP

"teehee i'm deliberately lurking coz day shud be overz lullllllllllz"

NO. DIE SCUM.

VOTE: TheJakalope

I will post something large and useful. I can't make any promises, because I don't know when I have free time, until I actually have free time, but it is coming, and you can count on that.

^^^ You KNEW you needed to post something useful. Yet, your reason for not posting is "lol day shud be overzzzzzz",

not

"OH I HAZ NO FREE TIME", which means you

had

the opportunity to post something useful, but

you made the deliberate decision not to post content

and decided to instead

coast until the hammer

.


I'll also re-iterate my point from before (which you decided not to answer in lieu of coasting/lurking):

Yeah, sorry about my inactivity. I'm having a hard time gaining interest in this game.

I'll give a few quick reads while I'm here.

Isa and Kcdaspot - Town

Vifam, Suneset - Neutral

RBT, diddin - Scum (RBT much more then diddin)

Why the hell would you go out of you way to specifically give Neutral reads on two paticular slots and then ignore 15 players?

This just reeks of giving reads for the sake of looking useful.

Spoiler: TheJakalope-diddin connectionz

Yeah, sorry about my inactivity. I'm having a hard time gaining interest in this game.

I'll give a few quick reads while I'm here.

Isa and Kcdaspot - Town

Vifam, Suneset - Neutral

RBT, diddin - Scum (RBT much more then diddin)

Alright, well RBT is lynch priority #1 today because of his bullshit "Vote for me if you're scum".

I'll do an ISO on diddin and see what I can present.

Ok, so turns out, diddin's ISO is pretty uneventful. I'm not sure if I got this game mixed up or what, but I don't have scum read on him anymore.

diddin is probably scum if TheJackalope is scum.

tl;dr

- Bunnylover wagon is dodgy, staying well away from that until I get some explanation as to why everybody was content to ignore it yesterday and then suddenly pile on today.

However, TheJakalope is lurking/coasting scum and needs to die.