Kids in the Hall Mafia - Game Over, Daves are Supreme

[VP Baltar]

why did that role information just come out...

[Amrun]

Umbrage, give it up. Your case isn't even close to convincing. It's all about "these things could be twisted and construed as scumtells" when no one else sees them as scumtells.

In your wall, you ask, "Is this normal for her?" Everyone says yes, and then you whine about meta excuses. YOU ASKED.

DGB is not at all willing to get a lynch on anybody - she declared scooby town when it was still up in the air, for example. She has been listing all game, and therefore those people on her town list are people she is not willing to lynch.

You get an explanation for the "seeking a boyfriend" thing (breadcrumb) and you dismiss it.

Bad case is bad.

p-edit: It's IS' fault.

[Internet Stranger]

/came close to chickening out.

Check.

^personal pic

Will you be my boyfriend? I'm looking for a long-term relationship. THIS IS A SIRIUS OFA.

Check.

"A" for effort, SpyreX, but my heart is set on Mysterio. He's the studliest stud that ever studded.

Check.

Mmmmmmmmmmmmmm that's pretty hunky dory, it looks like Mysterio has some competition. That Corona hat and the painted on mustache sure are draws.

I'm looking for a long-term boyfriend, though. I want to play house. Do you want to play house with me?

Check.

scooby 142: "scum want to look active in the breaking point" -

I think this is projection

on scooby's part: he's scum and wants to look active, and he's projecting that logic onto everyone else.
scooby 148: "Prove this. Now." This is very much a gut hunch, but that abrupt response sounds to me like it could come from scum happy to have found something they can legitimately challenge someone about.

This sort of argument is like a siren's song to me.

VOTE: Scooby

Check.

Players that went after Scooby for making a good attempt to alienate scum: Umbrage, Vollkan
Opportunists: UT, Gurgi, Umbrage (again),

Kison

, Imaginality,

DBG

(again),

pops

(again), lurconis
Conversation Misdirectors:

pops

, Amrun,

DBG

Spinning:

Farside

Farside

coming off as threading water again.

Kison

, lots of hem and hawing, but at least questioning pops.
VP, ugly ugly defense of

DBG

, even if its a joke.
Spyrex, blatant

DBG

defense

Farside

, being Captain Obvious, really helpful.

Farside again

,

pinging that scumdar.

Great, game derailed, thanks

Farside

.

Great, there goes

farside

.

DBG

, oh look opportunistic Umbrage vote to start the day. Great!

Im caught up! yaay! This first one is going to be so easy.

I really wanted to go after

Farside

,

[DGB] =

Really crappy cases on

Scooby and

pops

,

Vollkan is looking awful for

pops

.

Still wants Scooby over bullshit.

>>>I wasnt too sure on

pops

, but meh, the lynch was justified anyways.<<<

...constant bullshit lists (I hate bullshit lists) and now employs the services of Mr Angry White Knight, Poro (I HATE white knights) in an attempt to railroad Umbrage in a late coming OMGUS strategy and no reasoning whatsover.

Vote:

DBG

General question:

When IS's reads suck eggs and he screams for the overdeath of dead townies, while deriding everyone else, while boasting of past success in some other game, is he scum, or is he town? How about when he himself declares the pops lynch justified, while railing against other players that thought the same?

Check.



Well, im convinced that she is breadcrumbing the fuck out of the Chicken Lady role, which obviously does exist (Its funny as hell actually). So its possible that she is the Chicken Lady. Its also possible that it could be a fakeclaim.

Im not thoroughly convinced that the Chicken Lady is all that innocent either. If you notice Elvis, you have one of them vaginers. What would happen if she had fed the egg to a male instead? Cult? SK? roleblock? etc etc?

I need to think some more about what her role is supposed to accomplish. I can still fall back to the fact that her behavior is clearly not town-like. Its possible that she is a part of a gang of freaks or something as well. I have to start looking some things up.

[VP Baltar]

@ amrun - I mean, IS is stupid and all, but claiming that was unnecessary. There was no pressure to do so. sigh.

Anyhow, Umbrage and IS look like poo for harping on this when it's been clear for awhile that DGB is lost town at worst.

p.edit - well it's a two horse race of stupid grudge reads now

[Internet Stranger]

Oh wait, its not a fakeclaim if Elvis claims to have received an egg. Unless she is lying (which would be insane), ignore the fakeclaim part.

[Amrun]

............

IS, are you serious? She has the matching night action and it's a "fakeclaim?"

Also, just because elvis has a vagina doesn't mean her role character does.

*bangs head against wall*

p-edit: Slightly better.

[Internet Stranger]

Ahh very correct Amrun about the characters. Im going on the assumption that Elvis has a female character then. Until I look into this further, im very suspicious that these "eggs" will fuck somebody up if they are a male.

[Internet Stranger]

My god, researching this took a whole of two seconds.

Chicken Lady
Bearded Lady
Rooster Boy

Sounds like the makings of a scum team to me.

This is so ridiculously obvious. Combine that with her really really awful actions and this tells me that DBGScum needs to hang.

[Internet Stranger]

And to further spam the thread, I understand why Elvis is so passionate about defending the chicken lady now. But Elvis is still wrong. Unless she is willing to admit that her character is male and swears that nothing happened to her, then im convinced that this is how its being played out.

Them eggs are the devil!

[Amrun]

Ahh very correct Amrun about the characters. Im going on the assumption that Elvis has a female character then. Until I look into this further, im very suspicious that these "eggs" will fuck somebody up if they are a male.

WHY

THIS MAKES NO SENSE

ASDLJ;ALKF

[Internet Stranger]

They why the fuck go through the whole routine of feeding people eggs if they dont do jack shit? The chicken lady is after MEN, why is it so preposterous that the eggs would do nothing to a female and something to males?

What exactly do you need to hear Amrun? That DBGScum's eggs are full of nothing but rainbows and shiny happiness? I dont trust the fucking eggs!

[Umbrage]

Umbrage, give it up. Your case isn't even close to convincing. It's all about "these things could be twisted and construed as scumtells" when no one else sees them as scumtells.

In your wall, you ask, "Is this normal for her?" Everyone says yes, and then you whine about meta excuses. YOU ASKED.

DGB is not at all willing to get a lynch on anybody - she declared scooby town when it was still up in the air, for example. She has been listing all game, and therefore those people on her town list are people she is not willing to lynch.

You get an explanation for the "seeking a boyfriend" thing (breadcrumb) and you dismiss it.

Bad case is bad.

p-edit: It's IS' fault.

One more time.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

[Amrun]

Umbrage, give it up. Your case isn't even close to convincing. It's all about "these things could be twisted and construed as scumtells" when no one else sees them as scumtells.

In your wall, you ask, "Is this normal for her?" Everyone says yes, and then you whine about meta excuses. YOU ASKED.

DGB is not at all willing to get a lynch on anybody - she declared scooby town when it was still up in the air, for example. She has been listing all game, and therefore those people on her town list are people she is not willing to lynch.

You get an explanation for the "seeking a boyfriend" thing (breadcrumb) and you dismiss it.

Bad case is bad.

p-edit: It's IS' fault.

One more time.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

Control yourself.

You've been given several reasons, and there's no need to re-iterate them.

Your case is bad and you have no answer for what I said about it.

[Umbrage]

Yes, actually I do have an answer.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

GIVE ONE NON-META REASON WHY DGB IS TOWN, OR SHUT YOUR FUCKING MOUTH.

[Porochaz]

Jeez, chicken lady could mean anything, you just keep trying to frame DGB using faulty logic... Im not saying its a town or scum role but she has breadcrumbed the shit out of it

I have read your DGB post, multiple times. I'm not saying she's town but Im saying your case is not a good one, see what we have said and what amrun has just said.

and unfortunately meta is everything when it comes to DGB and if you dig down into your own case its all meta and twisted circumstance.

[Internet Stranger]

This is the thing Poro, saying that she breadcrumbed the shit out of it means nothing. It has been established that she is likely the Chicken Lady. Great. Wonderful.

Wasnt meta and twisted circumstance what was used to lynch pops? Hell, how else does anyone ever get lynched if not meta and twisted circumstance? Scum dont make confessions you know.



So answer me this then, all of you Chicken Lady lovers:

Is the Chicken Lady on the side of good, or the side of evil?
Are the eggs beneficial, or harmful?
Do they work on females, or males, or someone specific?

I propose that she is evil and aligned with the bearded lady and rooster boy.
What do you propose she does with these eggs if she was good?
What do you propose her purpose is if she is indeed good? Shes obviously not a plain townie.

If you dont know the answers, then why are you giving me all sorts of shit?

[Medicated Lain]

Aaaahhh seems like I have missed a bit. Sorry guys, I can't make a post without having read this day thus far. I'll make a post when I get off of work later. Can't promise how soon that will be, the weather's a bit misty today, not the best for bicycling far distances.

[Lurconis]

Chicken lady doesn't seem like it would be a scum role. And your proposal for bearded lady and rooster boy to round out the scum team makes it even less likely. There has been nothing to suggest flavor isn't holding true in this game as farside was a tracker and kison a double voter matches their roles. Not sure what dave counter would translate to in the game.

Not saying chicken lady couldn't have an alt win con just doesn't seem like a scum role.

My vote is staying on gurgi as i feel IS's case is wrong not necessarily scummy.

Pedit:
I don't know the answers i just feel there is nothing to suggest flavor isn't holding true and chicken lady only ever harmed sexual fantasies with the exception of possibly rooster boy. If anything i could see chicken lady being a lynchee type character who has to give her eggs to rooster boy. Then again i am basing that on the same thing you are which is nothing but speculation the differnce is i'm not convinced i outguessed the mod which you seem to be.

[Lurconis]

Actually looking through the advanced role wiki a variation on bomb would probably make most sense for chicken lady.

[SpyreX]

These pages I swear.

Chicken Lady means squat on a squat either way.

Umbrage you've went off the deep end scale it back.

[Amrun]

Why can't the egg do nothing and just be a red herring of sorts?

I do think it's possible she is seeking a particular male character, but not necessarily likely. Either way, I see it unlikely to be a scum role, as she is unlikely to be able to submit kills and give eggs on the same night, which would out her easily later on in the game. And obviously, this is why she needs to be a town read. If you want to stick a "for now" on it, go ahead, but instead we ought to just claim whomever gets the egg each day and if we get down to one scum and the egg suddenly stops going around... welp.

[DrippingGoofball]

I've haven't voted anyone for rolefishing since 1974, but this case takes the cake. There is no town reason to do it to this extent. Umbrage will have to wait his turn for the guillotine.

VOTE: Internet Stranger

[Umbrage]

I've haven't voted anyone for rolefishing since 1974, but this case takes the cake. There is no town reason to do it to this extent. Umbrage will have to wait his turn for the guillotine.

VOTE: Internet Stranger

OMGUS. This is getting old now.

[Amrun]

Why is omgus a scumtell in this situation?

[DrippingGoofball]

Umbrage is scum, he accused me on OMGUS'ing when he wasn't voting me, and hadn't posted today yet.