New York 138: OxyMoron Mafia :: Game Over!

[TOGTFO]

P1- confirmness- cool
*Johhog votes self, never understood the purpose of that other then to stand out.
*Ignored answers to questions as I am not much of a phycology guy.
*dislike Vifam for not sticking to games due to boredom.
P2-
*49- LOVED mastin putting reads so early. Why??? Cause it gave people something to go off of. He could have been totally bullshitting that but it got stuff going regardless.
P3-
*Oversoul fake scumhunts at 59
*Oversoul is called out as scum early and is now reacting.
P4-
*Enter out-guessing mod territory… BORING!!!!
*Johhog annoys me with his useless posts. He seems desperate to fit in.
P5-
*Yay mod shut down out-guessing. Its a large Normal… jeeze.
*If not for mastin, this page would be filled with useless crap… -_-
*Reading pre-game? How can you get alignment out of that?
P6-
*Empking is not very solid with his reads. I lolled at all the times he switches just because someone says something cheezily town like, "Massclaims are not the best idea"
*David wants to get lynched. Be a team player dude!!!
*Oversoul lists the two people who are the ONLY two people to get pissy with each other as scum. Maybe if multiple scum teams but for now I am going to dock a town point from Oversoul.
*Like FFs 142. RVS is still part of the game and can be used to get reads.
*Yeah… FF has a good grasp of RVS
p7-
*151- Vifam.. it was the confirmations stage. Him unvoting isn't going to do anything lol.
*155- Oversoul worried about being called out as scum before the game officially begins.
*168- Lame post is lame. Lets get other people suspicion off me by putting suspicion on them.
p8-
*KC>Oversoul
*Johhog starts tunneling on Vifam but still appears slightly town to me.
*198- Estyn shows his town side.
p9-
*205- No no no… RVS can find scum because scum get excited for being scum. Occasionally you get people who are newer and get a scum role and feel important. This is just one way to find scum in a RVS stage.
*Johhog is not handling this page well. Why freak out over someone calling you out for being online? Who cares if you didn't respond right away?
p10-
*226- SP decides to quote a post out of context… hmm… Also, all of the questions are rather useless to an extent. If you answer some, why not answer all? -1 town
*227- LC was the first person to point out stupid argument about if Johhog was online or not. +1 town
* I don't like Fool_Hardy and his random posts. Has he said anything game related yet? Oh, he starts finally giving inputs soon.. thank goodness.
*Vifam and Johhog are so town arguing. Idiots...

[Ironhead]

Empking is his scumbuddy.

I doubt it. Empking is being skeptical -- which is pro-town. What is not pro-town is calling two unconfirmed players "confirmed town." Also, do you have any news for us from last night's investigation?

what do we think of the oversoul/hoppster/secret project "mason circle"? I think it could be worth it to look into these guys and maybe lynch into those 3 today.

I don't know if any are worth lynching today. But they are all worth checking out, questioning, etc, to ascertain a better read on them. They are certainly not confirmed.

also complimenting doctor/bodyguard is a scumtell.

You suppose that Oversoul is a scum who bused his partner yesterday? It is possible, but as long as he keeps producing investigation results that we can demonstrate to be true we ought to keep him around.

Are you guys seriously fucking retarded?

Why would Hiplop, as scum, out all three of us if we were the scum group together?

Or do you think there are two mafia groups, which there clearly isn't.

He did that so that the mafia would know to shoot in the now confirmed town neighbor group.

WIFOM, from what I can see. And I would very much like to know how you know there "clearly isn't" two mafia groups?

VOTE: FATLIKEPIG

[fatlikepig]

I doubt it. Empking is being skeptical -- which is pro-town

oic, when I'm skeptical it's scummy, when Emp does it it's pro-town.

k.

[Xeras]

Vote: Fatlikepig

For omgus.

[fatlikepig]

WHAT OMGUS

[redFF]

oversoud who did you check/what was result.

[mastin2]

*insert halfhearted posting here*

Screw my analysis. It being slightly biased by my reads is worth the tradeoff of having read the game, knowing what's going on, and having the motivation to actually DO the analysis.

[Oversoul]

WHO DO YOU THINK I HAVE A RESULT ON

/peeved

and the reason that I know everyone is confirmed town in the qt is that when Lew's slot was absent

immediately on day 1 when I was getting pressured I claimed gunsmith in the qt so they would get off my back.

I didn't die that night.

yesterday, hiplop claimed everyone in the qt. Why would he have to do that as scum if there was scum already in the qt? USE FUCKING LOGIC

[Oversoul]

Two scum groups... 1 night kill each night... ya...

[Otolia]

Oversoul, you are going stop right now with the insults and the swearing.

[Xeras]

WHO DO YOU THINK I HAVE A RESULT ON

/peeved

and the reason that I know everyone is confirmed town in the qt is that when Lew's slot was absent

immediately on day 1 when I was getting pressured I claimed gunsmith in the qt so they would get off my back.

I didn't die that night.

yesterday, hiplop claimed everyone in the qt. Why would he have to do that as scum if there was scum already in the qt? USE FUCKING LOGIC

Myuu. Who

did

you check. We aren't mindreaders. I believe I said something similar to 'even if Lew flips mafia, there is a good chance that oversoul is mafia'.

The fact that you are not willing to share, and would rather spit out insults only makes this thought process seem more like a possibility to me.

[redFF]

honestly mastin has done absolutely nothing this game and i am fine with lynching him.

[Ironhead]

Vote: Fatlikepig

For omgus.

To echo Fatlikepig's protest: What OMGUS??? I'm voting him because of his pattern of behavior yesterday, and if you want to jump on that reasoning you are welcome to do so. But his comments today are not OMGUS. Please explain what you think is OMGUS.

WHO DO YOU THINK I HAVE A RESULT ON

/peeved

I would like to know who you investigated so that we know who might know is cleared /exasperated

Oversoul, you are going stop right now with the insults and the swearing.

I hate self-righteousness. Oversoul's behavior is grating, but this isn't any better. And isn't about time you started scumhunting? Who do you think is scum?

honestly mastin has done absolutely nothing this game and i am fine with lynching him.

Do you think he is scum for not doing anything this game? I look at his gameplay so far and see mastin being mastin -- not a scumtell for me. Are you familiar with his gameplay, and if not, have you checked his meta?

@TOGTFO: Can you please finish your analysis and tell us your reads?

[TOGTFO]

p11-
*redFF and Empking get points for telling them to stop the argument.
p12-
*HAHAHAHAHA literally the biggest waste of space between johhog and vifam.
p13-
*Like Mastin2 still and FoolishFool
*Johhog seemed town to me but man do his posts stink. I can see why FF is being cautious but pressuring at the same time.
*David would have to be a very bold scum player to be saying what he is saying. He is a good vig target though.
p14 thru 17 -
*kcda annoys me. His posts are town for the most part but his comments are so negative. Just a personal thing I guess.
*Bomberman has bad reads but gets town points for at least giving them.
*haha I like bomberman. Again, his reads are not that great and he kinda reaches with his cases but he is getting reactions and I like it.
*Oh… he is an alt. ReaperCharlie's alt at that… No wonder everyone is disliking him so fast. Or was that not true?
*Mastin is becoming lazy +scum points
*So… oversoul is still in the game. Yet he votes himself.
p18-
*LC complains on kcda posts but really is just upset with the quantity… that lame.
*kcda and bomberman being buddy buddy puts me on edge. People tend to tunnel when stuff like that happens.
*redFF possible scum buddy with Oversoul
p19-
*458 both of you are wrong. Anti-town not scum but not needed. Lynch it.
*SP relations to David noted.


At page 20 right now. I can't wait to see why certain people have not been lynched... -_-

[evilpacman18]

Probably gonna be voting Otolia today. It seems like we have a semi-broken game on our hands. We're figuring it out.

[Oversoul]

I received a positive result on Otolia.

Everyone should be voting him now.

There are no second groups or Serial Killers as there hasn't been a second kill all game.

I claimed gunsmith on day 1, when Lew was not in the game. I didn't die night 1. Hiplop claimed who was in the neighborhood because there would be no other way to tell his scum team. Therefore we are all confirmed.

You can choose to not trust me, but Hoppster and EPM are confirmed.

[Hoppster]

VOTE: Otolia

[fatlikepig]

Vote: Otolia

He should claim now, if I'm not mistaken.

[Empking]

Unvote, Vote: Oto

[David Xanatos]

VOTE: Oto

I may be missing something.. why are both Hoppster and EPM confirmed?

[Empking]

VOTE: Oto

I may be missing something.. why are both Hoppster and EPM confirmed?

Oversoul wasn't killed N1 despite claiming to them.

[David Xanatos]

Aah. Right, I get you. The hiplop/Hoppster thing threw me off for a minute (just woke up).

[redFF]

OTOLIA CLAIM

[ObliviousDruidMuncher]

Prod check/vote count later today. I'm still thinking of you guys.

[Ironhead]

UNVOTE: FATLIKEPIG
VOTE: OTOLIA

By my count, this brings Otolia to L-3. And I agree that he needs to claim.

Incidentally, I was concerned that Oversoul would get role-blocked and would himself become a target for lynch today when he could not produce a result -- but the fact that he did is pretty compelling proof that the scum don't have a role-blocker (or rather, if they do, it is probably Lady Lambdadelta, the inactive player). If they don't have a role-blocker, though, what does that mean about the number and strength of our PRs?