Kdowns:
We've gone into it at lengths that we are not lynching Kdowns today, but his ISO reads like a guy dodging death at evry corner. Several of his early ISO #s seem like Kdowns knows Maru is a mislynch. ISO #2, he says "potential msilynch" which is very close to "sure mislynch but I'm just covering my ass". ISO #4, he votes Maru because his "self-destruction is imminent". It's not a vote-worthy thing. If scum is going to self-destruct why vote them until they actually Sefl-D? If he's town why vote him at all? In ISO #7 he says he voted Maru because he's hard to read, but when he voted Maru he said it was because he thought he'd self-destruct. The Genie claim was at L-3 and a bit premature. The way he justified it as saying "You know what side he's (Genie) on" also reeked of mod-supplied fake-claim (we also know that Jaffar becomes and evil genie and the good genie would be a very logical mod-supplied fake claim) (
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MY_ebpdn41I). Later (ISO #18) he says his two scum reads are Maru and Sera (who I strongly believe is town). But earlier he said he was just trying to lynch Maru because he's hard to read, not scummy, and before that it was because Maru would self-destruct. ISO #22 (and #23) are scumzor to the max. His reasoning for not wanting to use his mass role-block was so we can base our Day 2 lynch off cop-results. What kind of dumb cop would claim his results Day2 unless absolutely necessary? Let's ask the cop to out themselves Day 2 so we can have a small percent chance of being spoon fed a SINGLE SCUM. Then take into count the concerns with cop sanity and it sounds even worse. Like it has been universally decided, we leave Kdowns alone today, but if anything but a mass-block happens tonight, he should see major scrutiny.
Lady:
Unfortunately Maru dug Lady a pretty deep hole. See Maru's comments.
MoI
: Buckled down pretty hard on Kdowns at first (+Town). Even though he is voting me for very unclear reasons, most of his other reads look sincere and he puts forth good effort into his analysis... with one exception. I played with MoI as scum in my 2nd game and he was very obvious scum IMO and I can't believe it took town so long to lynch him. Gets down hard on Hiraki for trying to clear Kdowns. I like his reads and his style. Most signs point to town on MoI.
Maru:
First to post (scumtell I've been guilty of before), his ISO reads Gibber Jabber Gibber Jabber HOLY CRAP OVER-REACTION Gibber Jabber Over-REaction Rage-Quit. ISO #29: "Start looking for
" to Sera. Slip? Absent from any Meta, this is a scum-ISO. It will be interesting to see what LLD comes up with to cover up for this.
Maxous:
Honestly, I didn't even notice Maxous was in this game until I was accused of being scum-buddies with him. However, Max's ISO looks pretty clean to me. His comments seem, straight forward, insightful and sincere.
*Prepares for mindless Maxous + WC sitting in a tree comments*
Meran
: Seems pretty content lite, has a weird vote and back down on Scott, has a terrible trap that Ray springs (supposedly), but mostly seems to be a weaker player and not terribly scummy, so I'm gonna go against the grain here and say probably town.
RayFrost:
His first interaction with Agar makes me question my read on Agar a bit. The "Late to the Party" comment with his RVS makes me a bit suspicious (PS I find the first RVS from scum is most often placed on scum, but that is neither here nor there at this point). I see an over-extention of RVS, easy wagon votes, provides baseless reads, switches his stances on Spyrex with no posts from spyrex, constantly dropping lines at/about Agar. Really tries to argue me out of wanting to believe Sera is confirmed town. Claims some sort of suicidal role. All in all I was a bit surprised how much Agar came up in this ISO. I'm gonna say null to scum here, I think there are better lynches today.
Scott:
Not much has changed since I ISOed him earlier. I was not impressed with his response to my accusations and now he has V/LAed. Null to Scum.
Sera
: Sera is another one of those players who plays aggressively, making it hard to determine if they are scum or just jerks. Fortunately, I know Sera is town (95% accuracy) and I will be shocked if I'm wrong. The wording of his claim fits perfectly to mine and at this point we have plenty of other valid lynch targets. I'm not saying that Sera can not be scum, but at this point in the game based on the evidence I possess, Sera is NOT going to be anyone I consider lynching for a moment.
Spyrex:
For some reason Spyrex feels intimidating, but looking through his ISO, his posts aren't the most aggressive of the groups and he seems to have pretty good insights. For some reason I feel like there is this unsaid Spyrex/GI/MoI alliance, but I don't read it as a scum-group. I'm reading Null to Town on Spyrex. Honestly, I was expecting to see a bit more from him.
Toasty:
Really jumps on the Spyrex "Fish" on Sera, I was a bit suspicious of him for mis-repping me about my Maru vote, but his response was pretty civil and since then he seems to have contributed sufficiently, not huge amounts, but enough. I'm gonna say Null-Town on TT.
I swear I left my gun somewhere.
