Memento Mafia - Over

[MagnaofIllusion]

See I'd have reciprocated, but AGM decided that he'd out the scum QT with or without my consent.

Which is not Kosher, and the reason you get people's consent is half the QT can vanish at whim.

Um, no.

Standard practice for me is that ALL QTs will be made public post game. It's part of my ruleset. I don't think it was in this one (didn't check as I was composing) so that's AGM's choice.

This 'sanctity of the Scum QT' bullshit I see being floated is crap. There is no 'magic strategy' that you are hiding. Anything you say in the QT you should be willing to own up to.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I don't know what the fuck LLD sees in you

Um, EXCUSE ME?

Are you ACTUALLY trying to compare a MAFIA game to someone's real life character?

I don't think you want to go down that road.

Because if that were the case, I'd have some really interesting things to say about your character and what kind of person YOU are.

[Faraday]

tbh i love reading qt's post game and feel cheated when people don't make them public.

so yeah, i agree with fate.

[Amrun]

Yeah, I make scum QTs public as a mod. And I always will.

[Empking]

Though the thread has moved from where it was when AGM PM'd me. I'll post what I thought about the balance anyway.

Spoiler: Balance

3 scum (w/day kill right?)
10 Townies

3:6 Nightless is balanced.

The set up was 3:10
+ Daykill = 3:8.5 (At least)
So the question is whether the starting ability is worth at least 1.5 townies. The answer is obviously "yes".

[GreyICE]

See I'd have reciprocated, but AGM decided that he'd out the scum QT with or without my consent.

Which is not Kosher, and the reason you get people's consent is half the QT can vanish at whim.

Um, no.

Standard practice for me is that ALL QTs will be made public post game. It's part of my ruleset. I don't think it was in this one (didn't check as I was composing) so that's AGM's choice.

This 'sanctity of the Scum QT' bullshit I see being floated is crap. There is no 'magic strategy' that you are hiding. Anything you say in the QT you should be willing to own up to.

I didn't say anything bad.

I just deleted it to piss Fate off.

[MagnaofIllusion]

The set up was 3:10 Daykill = 3:8.5 (At least)So the question is whether the starting ability is worth at least 1.5 townies. The answer is obviously "yes".

I think you mean 2.5 Town since 8.5-1.5 does not equal 6.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Actually, you know what?

I want an apology for that comment Fate. If you want to show that you're more of a man than Grey is, then own up and give me a fucking apology for that shit.

[Fate]

I don't know what the fuck LLD sees in you

Um, EXCUSE ME?

Are you ACTUALLY trying to compare a MAFIA game to someone's real life character?

I don't think you want to go down that road.

Because if that were the case, I'd have some really interesting things to say about your character and what kind of person YOU are.

I'll take it back, I admit that line was over the top and added on there with a "mehhh should I even say this" feeling to it.

But yeah.

Its not the mafia game, its not the mafia personality, its the ACTIONS. Because I say and do a lot of shit as part of my MAFIA game, but post game I actually have comments and insights and advice.

POST game is out of character, out of "game".

And POSTGAME Grey decided (well apparenty he did it "in game" for no fuckin reason) to withhold his QT which as others have agreed to cheat the other players, for what can only be a completely selfish motive.

So yeah.

Go ahead and say whatever things YOU want about my character OUT of game, because it sure as hell isn't going to be the same as the douchebag I play on TV if you read closely enough.

[GreyICE]

And it pisses me off.

Given that was the goal, good.

Mission Accomplished

[Amrun]

See I'd have reciprocated, but AGM decided that he'd out the scum QT with or without my consent.

Which is not Kosher, and the reason you get people's consent is half the QT can vanish at whim.

Um, no.

Standard practice for me is that ALL QTs will be made public post game. It's part of my ruleset. I don't think it was in this one (didn't check as I was composing) so that's AGM's choice.

This 'sanctity of the Scum QT' bullshit I see being floated is crap. There is no 'magic strategy' that you are hiding. Anything you say in the QT you should be willing to own up to.

I didn't say anything bad.

I just deleted it to piss Fate off.

If that were the case, you would answer me.

[Oversoul]

I fucking new GreyIce was the scum on my wagon. Really did not see Edmund flipping scum. >_>

I would also like to say a formal apology for what I did after I was quick lynched, but I was livid after that happened. That was completely inexcusable and if I had been able to fucking claim things would have gone better.

pedit:

Every game I have won with GreyIce so far... he has bitched up a storm.

[Empking]

The set up was 3:10 Daykill = 3:8.5 (At least)So the question is whether the starting ability is worth at least 1.5 townies. The answer is obviously "yes".

I think you mean 2.5 Town since 8.5-1.5 does not equal 6.

Yeah I meant 2.5. The answer is less obviously "yes".

[GreyICE]

And POSTGAME Grey decided (well apparenty he did it "in game" for no fuckin reason) to withhold his QT which as others have agreed to cheat the other players, for what can only be a completely selfish motive.

Deleted by author 09-16-2011 02:02 AM

Postgame?

I cleaned it all out over a week ago.

[Fate]

So your intent was to "piss me off" after I caught your entire team the second I replaced in?

That's hilarious, actually.

[Ellibereth]

3 scum (w/day kill right?)
10 Townies

3:6 Nightless is balanced.

The set up was 3:10
+ Daykill = 3:8.5 (At least)
So the question is whether the starting ability is worth at least 1.5 townies. The answer is obviously "yes".

why is DK 1.5
and starting ability worth that much.
Especially since they come back and all that.

[Oversoul]

Wait... why didn't the scum just kill 2 of their own players and let town mislynch for the first three days?

[Fate]

And POSTGAME Grey decided (well apparenty he did it "in game" for no fuckin reason) to withhold his QT which as others have agreed to cheat the other players, for what can only be a completely selfish motive.

Deleted by author 09-16-2011 02:02 AM

Postgame?

I cleaned it all out over a week ago.

You did somethign with no "INGAME" advantage, something that would only even come to LIGHT post game.

But keep arguing semantics, it shows your TRUE CHARACTER for all to see.

[Ellibereth]

I fucking new GreyIce was the scum on my wagon. Really did not see Edmund flipping scum. >_>

I would also like to say a formal apology for what I did after I was quick lynched, but I was livid after that happened. That was completely inexcusable and if I had been able to fucking claim things would have gone better.

pedit:

Every game I have won with GreyIce so far... he has bitched up a storm.

Why didn't you pm me

[Faraday]

wait, i thought greyice deleted the posts b/c he was pissed agm shared the qt

but instead it was b/c fate caught him as scum? lol? er kay

[GreyICE]

So your intent was to "piss me off" after I caught your entire team the second I replaced in?

That's hilarious, actually.

Nah.

I'm just actually annoyed that every single game I play in with you from now on it's going to be 'trololol I can read ICE, he's scum, I called his entire team in Memento mafia.'

When like a dozen games say you can't.

[GreyICE]

wait, i thought greyice deleted the posts b/c he was pissed agm shared the qt

but instead it was b/c fate caught him as scum? lol? er kay

1) Yes it's petty, but it's payback for him doing exactly the same to me in exactly the same situation, so well etc. I'm petty and I like it.

2) AGM told me he'd out it despite me having a clear reason to not want it outed.

Also you didn't even play in this game.

[Oversoul]

I fucking new GreyIce was the scum on my wagon. Really did not see Edmund flipping scum. >_>

I would also like to say a formal apology for what I did after I was quick lynched, but I was livid after that happened. That was completely inexcusable and if I had been able to fucking claim things would have gone better.

pedit:

Every game I have won with GreyIce so far... he has bitched up a storm.

Why didn't you pm me

I raged PMed everyone who was on my wagon their first post of that day.

GreyIce was actually on when I sent his and I was like torlolol talking out of game thread Ima get you modkilled.

I bluff a lot.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Also you didn't even play in this game

Lulz. Maybe if you hadn't gotten steamrolled he would have had the chance ...

[Faraday]

Also you didn't even play in this game.

u mad