New York 138: OxyMoron Mafia :: Game Over!

[evilpacman18]

vote: projectmatt

[Xeras]

lol. Do we have a busdriver?

Vote: ProjectMatt

[fatlikepig]

I was thinking more along the lines of a PGO, actually. Dunno though.

[Xeras]

The only reason why I was thinking Busdriver, was because I was a pro town busdriver once. I managed to get the Godfather to kill himself, and the Serial Killer to kill himself. ^^

[Empking]

The only reason why I was thinking Busdriver, was because I was a pro town busdriver once. I managed to get the Godfather to kill himself, and the Serial Killer to kill himself. ^^

Busdrivers aren't normal.

Vote: Projectmatt

[Oversoul]

Whoever killed Pine is like confirmed town

Hence, why they shouldn't claim, though I have a decent idea for who they are.

Anyway. VOTE: Project Matt. Pretty sure this'll end the game in a town win.

Xeras
Nobody Special (replaced Vifam, and Vifam was a previous town lean.)
Thor665 (Probable.)
TOGTFO (town lean as well, though this read is a little shaky.)
evilpacman18 (Not sure.)
redFF (Leaning town as well.)

So if all of my town leans are correct, that would leave:

Xeras
Thor
Evil

Here are the problems that I have with Matt's reads.

They are weak and uncertain. TOG as a shaky town read? Are you serious dude? He basically outted Foolish Fool as a scum power role? EPM as a not sure? When I have been vouching for his towniness all game? Thor as a probable town when that slot replaced out in a fit of rage?

I have successfully found the vig and it is between two people. If this game doesn't end with your lynch, ProjectMatt, then it may be a serial killer, and the list gets bigger.

I got a guilty on Matt last night.

Fat, I said one of Ironhead or you is town and the other is scum. WELL....

[David Xanatos]

VOTE: Matt

Guilty is guilty.

[Oversoul]

That was the hammer.

[ObliviousDruidMuncher]

Not going to bother with an official end-of-day vote count, considering Day 5 was less than 24 hours.

projectmatt, a

Vanilla Townie

, has been lynched by the town. It is now Night 5. The deadline for Night 5 is October 18th, 2011 at 8:00 PM ET.

[ObliviousDruidMuncher]

TOGTFO, a

Jack of All Trades

, was chiasmused to death during Night 5. It is now Day 6. The deadline for Day 6 is November 1st, 2011 at 8:00 PM ET.

[David Xanatos]

VOTE: Oversoul

A guilty, eh?

[Oversoul]

Are you fucking serious David? Yes. Let me tell you. I fucking claimed a guilty on two of my teammates, one was a lurker with literally NO SUSPICION on him, implicated another one and essentially outted the fourth as a roleblocker?

Let me tell you.

We have a serial killer or some such shit.

[Oversoul]

Also, WHY THE FUCK WOULD A DAMN MAFIA ROLEBLOCKER IF I WAS FUCKING MAFIA MEMBER VISIT ME?

LOGIC FAIL YOU ARE MOST LIKELY THE DAMN SERIAL KILLER. FUCK OFF.

I DON'T KNOW IF THE DAMN MAFIA HAVE A FRAMER OR WHAT BUT I AM NOT CLAIMING ANYMORE SHIT UNLESS I HAVE TO

[Oversoul]

VOTE: David

[redFF]

Also, WHY THE FUCK WOULD A DAMN MAFIA ROLEBLOCKER IF I WAS FUCKING MAFIA MEMBER VISIT ME?

LOGIC FAIL YOU ARE MOST LIKELY THE DAMN SERIAL KILLER. FUCK OFF.

I DON'T KNOW IF THE DAMN MAFIA HAVE A FRAMER OR WHAT BUT I AM NOT CLAIMING ANYMORE SHIT UNLESS I HAVE TO

we already know your role. claim your check.

[Oversoul]

Negative on Empking. David is likely the SK for wanting a gunsmith to investigate him. His play has also been relatively scummy and I took the roleblock from Hoppster to be relatively safe assumption he was town but it would make sense that he did not get to kill someone then.

Vote David.

[mastin2]

Oversoul, you've made my job significantly easier.

See, I had concluded last night that the last scum was 41% redFF, 39% Empking, 19% on NS/Vifam, and 1% on someone else.

Empking is now clear.

So, now that I have 40% extra...

60% redFF, 30% NS/Vifam, and 10% on someone else. (In order from most to least, {David, Xeras, Thor, Fat}.)


So.

VOTE: redFF.

[mastin2]

Oh, wait.

Unvote

.

It's not a "last scum".

It's worse.

It's a Serial Killer.


Different kill method+four dead scum+crossreferencing Neruzian which only had one extra player = SK.

In that case...

VOTE: Secret Project/Evilpacman.

Oversoul, you're obviously not a SK-Gunsmith, or a SK-faking-Gunsmith. But think about it. Hoppster was in your neighborhood and was a PR. You were a PR. Lew/Hiphop was a Mafia Goon. So...what is Secret/Evil? "Just a neighbor"? No, think about it. He's far more likely to be a serial killer than pretty much any other player.

It also makes sense. Think about it. Scum had daytalk in Neruzian to compensate for their small size. If this game is the same way, then scum with daytalk makes sense. (The only thing against this is hiplop posting in-thread the teams, but still, the theory makes overall more sense to me.)

Heck, Scum-With-Daytalk is the latest fad among Large Normals. (The fad before that being "two scumgroups".) You have daytalk, scum having it to counter you makes logical sense.

So, no more mafia; they died with Pine. Think about it, Oversoul--why have you continued to live? When TOGTFO only had a single doc protect, which was presumably used up the night Pine died? Instead of you? It not only means the Serial Killer is not threatened by you, but that you are more of an asset to them than TOGTFO, or (if I were somehow wrong) Secret Project/Evil. You've probably cleared the thought of Evil out of your mind as a suspect, haven't you? Why kill a great ally?

And, hey. The temptation to have a neighborhood with an SK and mafia in it is generally way too high for most mods to resist.



Tl;dr,

Secret Project/evilpacman is the most likely Serial Killer, and therefore, the ideal lynch today.

[mastin2]

To make sure it's not missed.

VOTE: evilpacman18.

[Oversoul]

I concluded that the kill must have been either from Thor or NS (PGO/VIG) but since it is clear that it is a serial killer that has expanded to include Xeras and Empking and David. You were calling redFF town the other day when I claimed a fake innocent on him.

David I feel like is probably the SK...

Fucking SKs.

You said you claimed you knew where the shot on Pine came from yesterday, is it redFF?

mastin, please for the love of god no. Trust me. it isn't Evil.

[Oversoul]

Why wouldn't SK kill the JK and just run it off as oh the scum in the neighborhood must have leaked?

[mastin2]

Fucking SKs

Yeah, I really can't hunt them, either.

You said you claimed you knew where the shot on Pine came from yesterday, is it redFF?

My first guess was Evil. My second guess was TOGTFO lying about an ability and possessing a vig. My third guess was one of {redFF, Empking, Xeras, NS}. I don't think I thought of Thor or David.

Why wouldn't SK kill the JK and just run it off as oh the scum in the neighborhood must have leaked?

Hide their presence. Not let anyone know there was a serial killer. Or, it's possible that the serial killer targeted the jailkeep target.

Though...come to think of it...


...Wasn't Xeras blocked night one and two?

Unvote, VOTE: Xeras.

[mastin2]

Wait, nevermind.

Night 1:
Jailed DavidX
Investigated Lew - Positive

Night 2:
Jailed Empking
Investigated Otolia - Positive

One of these is the jailed SK, the other is a failed SK hit. My money's with you, Oversoul. So, UNVOTE: , to what I should've done.

VOTE: David Xanatos.

[mastin2]

Nobody visited Xeras D1.
Nobody visited Hoppster D2.

These results are likely valid. Though it's not that helpful; he was a scum watcher, rather than tracker. But still, these results have importance.

[Oversoul]

Ya. I am almost positive it is David. Please follow me with this Mastin. I will do a full reveal to Evil tonight and if he doesn't post my full reveal after I die tonight then you guys can lynch him, but I highly highly highly doubt that he is SK. After I die my mood when I get my whiny after death post should be enough indication of my feelings.

Mass claim? Although I feel like everyone is going to claim VT

Thank you David.

I was going to say that the SK is likely a Ninja... but... ya...