New York 138: OxyMoron Mafia :: Game Over!

[Empking]

If there was a tracker and no Mafia then (presuming the SK was a Ninja) the only use from a Tracker would be confirming you. Since there's no Tracker claim its self-evident that there's no Tracker AKA you're a fakeclaimer AKA you're Mafia.

PEdit: No because you're hiding and trying to pretend you're all dead but you unluckily slipped.

[Thor665]

I unluckily slipped by claiming a fake PR who, if he never showed up, would put me at pretty much assured lynch in lylo?
Yeah, pull the other one, there's bells on it.

[Empking]

I unluckily slipped by claiming a fake PR who, if he never showed up, would put me at pretty much assured lynch in lylo?
Yeah, pull the other one, there's bells on it.

No you slipped up by claiming there were five Mafiosos.

If its lylo then you can just go "lol wifom scum tracker".

[Thor665]

@Emp - I had a longer rebuttal, but I'm going to settle for making a raspberry noise instead. Let's point out one important facet here, there's no way you're getting me lynched today - but it would be exceedingly easy for me to get you lynched. So make a very nice, very pretty, very convincing 'This is why Thor is scum, Empking is sexy and brilliant, and everyone else is stupid' post and lay out the whole case.

Then go and actually start discussing the actual issues at hand today and stop wasting everyone's time.

[Empking]

@Emp - I had a longer rebuttal, but I'm going to settle for making a raspberry noise instead. Let's point out one important facet here, there's no way you're getting me lynched today - but it would be exceedingly easy for me to get you lynched. So make a very nice, very pretty, very convincing 'This is why Thor is scum, Empking is sexy and brilliant, and everyone else is stupid' post and lay out the whole case.

Then go and actually start discussing the actual issues at hand today and stop wasting everyone's time.

Thor is claiming that there is a Tracker. There is no Tracker. Thor is scum.

Do you disagree with the first statement?
The second statement is obviously true. Unless you can give a reason why any Tracker should hide away?
Do you think there's a problem from getting the third statement from the first and second?

The knowledge only Mafia would have (the secret fifth member) and the basic scum posturing (your last post) are unimportant to the basic fact that you are a confirmed lying fakeclaimer.

[Thor665]

Excellent, now what are your reads for SK since I'm confirmed not SK and we are looking for an SK at the moment - do you support the David lynch off the JK, also, what's your read on mastin?

[Empking]

Excellent, now what are your reads for SK since I'm confirmed not SK and we are looking for an SK at the moment - do you support the David lynch off the JK, also, what's your read on mastin?

Yes I support the DX SK, hence my former vote.
Mastin is clearly town.

[Thor665]

Why is mastin clearly town?
Why do you think DX SK tried to kill you?

[Empking]

Why is mastin clearly town?
Why do you think DX SK tried to kill you?

He's not Mafia (obv) or SK (obv).
No clue and I can't remember that far ago.

[Thor665]

If it's so obvious can't you just tell me? Otherwise I'm going to lynch him, and that would be bad I understand.

[Empking]

If it's so obvious can't you just tell me? Otherwise I'm going to lynch him, and that would be bad I understand.

If there's a Mafia left it has to be you. DX is the Serial Killer.

[Nobody Special]

So, wait, if I understand correctly, we have Thor=Mafia (per Empking, who I don't really trust), and David=SK (per general consensus, which I agree with)?

I trust Thor far more than Empking.

I'm waiting for the votecount before voting David. Empking can wait, at least a day.

I'm not sure I buy that there's another mafia. It doesn't seem right, numbers-wise.

[Thor665]

If there is an additional mafia they either no killed, were stopped by another PR blocking/defensive role, or targeted the SK and the SK is bulletproof. So...possible, but I'm leaning unlikely.

@Emp - why is mastin obv. town?

[Empking]

@Emp - why is mastin obv. town?

Because he isn't scum.

[Oversoul]

If it's so obvious can't you just tell me? Otherwise I'm going to lynch him, and that would be bad I understand.

If there's a Mafia left it has to be you. DX is the Serial Killer.

Voyeur and Watcher? That seems a little... iffy for the Mafia.

I haven't seen Empking play like this before. O_o

[evilpacman18]

So why hasn't he been lynched yet?

[Nobody Special]

I'm waiting for a votecount.

[ObliviousDruidMuncher]

Day 6 Vote Totals

If there is a mistake, point it out.

Last post seen:

Nobody Special

, page 71.

[4]David Xanatos:

Oversoul, mastin2, David Xanatos, evilpacman18 [L-2]

[1]evilpacman18:

redFF [L-5]

[1]Oversoul:

Xeras [L-5]

[1]Thor665:

Empking [L-5]

Prods:

Xeras
redFF

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. It is currently Day 6. The deadline for Day 6 is November 1st, 2011 at 8 PM ET.

[Empking]

If it's so obvious can't you just tell me? Otherwise I'm going to lynch him, and that would be bad I understand.

If there's a Mafia left it has to be you. DX is the Serial Killer.

Voyeur and Watcher? That seems a little... iffy for the Mafia.

I haven't seen Empking play like this before. O_o

Voyeur is a fakeclaim. Nobody is suggesting that Thor is a Mafia Voyeur other than those putting it up as a strawman. I said myself that if there was a Tracker Thor would be confirmed town.

[Nobody Special]

You have David voting for both himself (correct, I believe) and Oversoul.




P-Edit: To be clear, I am not suggesting that Thor is Mafia Voyeur.

[Nobody Special]

Ack. Boldification:

@MOD: You have David both voting for himself (correct) and Oversoul.

Fixed. ~ODM

[fatlikepig]

VOTE: DX

L-1 choo choo

What are the chances of scum watcher?

[Nobody Special]

I'd say 100%, since Otolia, the Mafia Watcher, was lynched Day 3.

[fatlikepig]

tracker

i meant tracker >.<

[Nobody Special]

Then, I would say probably very small.