New York 138: OxyMoron Mafia :: Game Over!

[Thor665]

Tracker is likely town or 3rd party due to maf watcher - which is why redFF is basically conf. town. Even if you want to be Emp and go with the theory that Thor is mafia, he's still basically confirmed town then as well.

[redFF]

hey i still don't like epm at all but im probably gonna hammer. ill wait for dx to check in and claim first tho.

[Nobody Special]

He already did.

[redFF]

kk hammering

i advise we look at epm
VOTE: davidxanatos

[Xeras]

kk hammering

i advise we look at epm
VOTE: davidxanatos

+1 epm should be next. Or OVersoul.

[ObliviousDruidMuncher]

David Xanatos, a

Vanilla Townie

, has been lynched. It is now Night 6. The deadline for Night 6 is October 25th, 2011 at 8:00 PM ET.

[ObliviousDruidMuncher]

Xeras, a

Vanilla Townie

, was chiasmused to death during Night 6. It is now Day 7. The deadline for Day 7 is November 8, 2011 at 8:00 PM ET.

[Thor665]

Xeras?
Flipping Xeras was the NK?
The head asplodes.

Last scum is in the mostly thought of as conf. towns - discuss.

Also;

V/LA - Oct. 30 - Nov. 2

[redFF]

OVERSOUL IF YOU DON'T TELL US HOW EPM IS TOWN IM GETTING HIM LYNCHED.

[Thor665]

@red - based off wifom last suspicions of Xeras, or something else?

Wasn't the case for epm not being scum that he was part of the neighborhood with the JKing actions - if he was SK wouldn't he have got kills through instead of being caught up via JKs?

[redFF]

because he hasnt done jack shit all game and has rode off os calling him confirmed town with no reasoning.

[mastin2]

1. Empking <--Chances of being SK virtually zero. He wouldn't NK someone like that when he knew he'd be the center of attention.
3. Nobody Special Vifam <--Chances of being scum...pretty dang high.
4. Thor665 Lady Lambadelta BomberMan <--Chances of being scum...debating.
6. fatlikepig LTP Mafia <--Not mafia. Could be SK, with the NK.
7. evilpacman18 <--Not mafia; we already had one mafia in the neighborhood.
8. redFF <-- Not Mafia, based on interactions.

So, SCUM SUSPECTS:
NS or Thor.

SK SUSPECTS:
NS
redFF
Thor
fat
Evil
Empking.

Roughly in that order.

VOTE: Nobody Special. No offense, man, but you're expendable.

[mastin2]

(Yeah, bad username pun, but he's at the top of both lists since he has the least in his favor. But there's more.

I'm almost ready to call Empking town. Almost.
And Thor's argument for EPM [that he would know who to avoid trying to NK] is a pretty good one.
That leaves four suspects for SK. Two of them are cleared from being mafia.
We've had no tracker claim, despite Thor claiming there to be one. Therefore, the tracker must be mafia.

There are only two suspects for mafia. If NS flips "Mafia Tracker", Thor's confirmed-Voyear. If NS flips anything else, then we'll know Thor's claim was BS and that HE is likely a Mafia Tracker.

Tl;dr, an NS lynch generates the most information right now.)

[Thor665]

@mastin - redFF is actually also cleared of being SK due to my investigation (and if I'm scum I wouldn't lie, and if I'm SK he's still cleared, so - natch) If he's SK tracker would have seen him go somewhere. If tracker was town, tracker probably would have claimed by now, if tracker was mafia, wtflolomg w. mafia watcher - ergo tracker is likely SK, and possibly can track instead of kill...? Wild guess there.

[Thor665]

@mastin - why mafia tracker+watcher - wtf, yes?

[mastin2]

Would make sense against the strong town power, would it not?

You said it yourself. The town's a bit overpowered.

[Thor665]

I agree town still looks strong but - scum tracker+watcher? That sounds unlikely just on the face of it.
You also were the one saying that we weren't overpowered So now that we agree Thor is more oftent han not right, let's keep going with my reads as I seem to get them about one game day prior to you.

Where would you put yourself on the SK chart?

[mastin2]

I can't read minds.

You could always compare my play here to Pally, since I was in control after Pine flaked (which is somewhere around D3 onward). You tell me.

[Thor665]

@mastin - if mafia are still alive why are mafia not killing?

[fatlikepig]

Have we considered that the SK could potentially be X-shot? May explain the lack of two NKs early on in the game.

I'm slightly unconvinced of there being five mafia, four plus SK already seems pretty weighted against the town. I realise that we had awesome PRs, but even so I have trouble believing that there needs to be so much counterbalance.

If two teams still exist, though, scum may not be killing to avoid NK WIFOM or to slip under the radar while we go SK hunting. Or tet could be hitting protective roles, which is still possible.

[mastin2]

I change my mind.

Fat's the SK.

Unvote, Vote: fatlikepig

.

[fatlikepig]

And why might that be?

[mastin2]

You fit Thor's "Bottom of the suspect list" mold, for starters. And not thinking there's any mafia left.

[mastin2]

BTW, Xeras suspected EPM and Oversoul, with some redFF thrown in as well. Worth lookin' into, though I still think it's fat right now.

[fatlikepig]

And not thinking there's any mafia left.

Why does that make me the SK?

If I were SK, I would want town to think there were mafia. It's not something I could see the actual SK disputing.