A Feast for Crows Mafia - Valar Morghulis.

[Oversoul]

LOL

[Benmage]

No, but taking her maidenhood before a Stark had ever even kissed her does.

Hearsay spouted only from your own lips.

Cats the female version of Ned. She wouldn't. She thought you only as a brother. And it crushed you and caused you to be the twisted

little

man you are today.

[zoraster]

No, but taking her maidenhood before a Stark had ever even kissed her does.

Hearsay spouted only from your own lips.

The question is what sp

r

outed between

her

lips.

[Oversoul]

LOFUCKINGL

[Eddard Stark]

Day 1, Votecount 5

Mastermind of Sin (1) - MagnaofIllusion
Hasdgfas (1) Shadow1psc
Mina (3) - Wraith, FourseenCircumstance, Benmage

Shadow1psc (5) - Empking, Deity of Flame, Hasdgfas, Cogito Ergo Sum, Plum

Cogito Ergo Sum (1) - Monday
Empking (1) - Magister Ludi
FourseenCircumstance (1) - greenknight

Not voting

(10) Mina, ooba, Albert B. Rampage, Magua, Mockingjaye, Mastermind of Sin, Oversoul, xvart, diddin, Feysal

With 23 votes in play it takes 12 to lynch.

• Deadline for Day 1
  : 15:29 GMT on the 17th of November.
  
• Countdown
  : (expired on 2011-11-17 11:29:00)
  
• Please point out any mistakes in the votecount.
  
• Mockingjaye is V/la until Friday, xvart also informed me he was V/la 'till Sunday.

[Mastermind of Sin]

See my siggy for V/LA.

[MagnaofIllusion]

This is a joke. Zoraster known scum, claims to want to use character names.

F-that.

scum confusion tactic already.

QFT. If this is the Benmage we are going to be seeing I’ll slot you as worthy of potential sheepage again.

You didnt assume scumdaytalk?

Scum didn’t have it in either Clash or Storm. Mod meta says less likely to happen.

--

Shadow's play rings a bell in my head as... skeptical. Doesn't seem genuine in my opinion.

So you are saying Shadow’s play suggests scum play to you and you had no active vote as of this post?

Hascow is town because I highly doubt scum would say something such as that.

Scum would never fake a crippling post restriction and then Dayvig a partner. Your expectation of what scum would never do is very unrealistic. Smells like buddying up right here.

Also, 2 scum groups in this game, so 1 with the Moqorro and 1 with Littlefinger so scumhunting/not scumhunting will probably not be that useful of a tell.

Bzzt … wrong answer. You clearly didn’t bother actually reading the Victarian sample PM.

Your response when this is pointed out stinks like day old catch in the Fishmonger's Market.

Your play over the past 3 pages deserves my attention. And a vote

UNVOTE: MoS
VOTE: Oversoul

--

Furthermore I doubt anyone ever has dealt anyone in an equivalent role.

Actually I have, from both sides of the table, on another site. It’s why I said that ignoring the impotent Scumstump is the best course of action. His only goal is to spread WIFOM / chaos / misleading or incorrect information. The best way to deal with him is to hunt down his partners, hang them high, and watch as he slinks back to the Vale with his little tail tucked between his legs.

[Oversoul]

Wait, MoI are you actually serious with that Hascow comment? You think that Has is going to repeat what he did in the last Game of Thrones game? How is that even relevant here with the smalltown deal?

[Oversoul]

Also, let it be known, before my meta gets overanalyzed as it always does, I am stingy with my vote. I can see Magna is already trying to kindle that fire.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Wait, MoI are you actually serious with that Hascow comment? You think that Has is going to repeat what he did in the last Game of Thrones game? How is that even relevant here with the smalltown deal?

Are your reading comprehension skills faulty due to a non-noble upbringing? Your post smells of overjustification of why you think Cow is Town. Frankly his play isn't pretty non-descript so far. But you latch onto what is basically a Meh post and declare him Townie McTowniePants.

Which is classic over-eager scum play.

Were you scum in Blackest Night? I got killed too early didn't really follow along very closely.

[Oversoul]

Wait, MoI are you actually serious with that Hascow comment? You think that Has is going to repeat what he did in the last Game of Thrones game? How is that even relevant here with the smalltown deal?

Are your reading comprehension skills faulty due to a non-noble upbringing? Your post smells of overjustification of why you think Cow is Town. Frankly his play isn't pretty non-descript so far. But you latch onto what is basically a Meh post and declare him Townie McTowniePants.

Which is classic over-eager scum play.

Were you scum in Blackest Night? I got killed too early didn't really follow along very closely.

I was cult, so yes.

I didn't call him McTowniePants. I called him town. I'm not buddying him. If anything, I am buddying Shadow (see my discussion with Empking). I honestly do not understand where you are coming from with this.

And psh. My upbringing is noble. I should have my lady execute you for saying such blasphemy.

[Benmage]

@MoI

Oversoul isn't skilled enough to fake post depth. His filler lolz at chesskid, I mean zoraster screams of ineptTown.

Empking is the one to keep an eye on. Shadow is obvtown too. Add greenknight to my scumlist.

Right now, we wait for those who have yet to contribute and those who have said little.

[Magua]

This is a joke. Zoraster known scum, claims to want to use character names.

F-that.

scum confusion tactic already.

Holy shit, I agree with Benmage on something.

Character-based voting, especially, is a tool to separate the player from the slot, and to be able to justify votes for reasons tied to character/flavour (ie, bullshit) over actual play. No way, no how.

Secondly, Oversoul is 10,000% scum and needs to die.

1) His Moqorro bit is fake if he actually bothered to read the role PM, which he didn't.
2) Since town's faction color is red, scum are incredibly likely to be blue (see ASOS) which Oversoul as slipped as being his faction color.
3) His reaction when being caught as scum (seen it in Marathon games, seen it in BDM) is to play "lol imma dumb newbie" which he is decidedly not.

VOTE: Oversoul

[zoraster]

@MoI

Oversoul isn't skilled enough to fake post depth. His filler lolz at chesskid, I mean zoraster screams of ineptTown.

Empking is the one to keep an eye on. Shadow is obvtown too. Add greenknight to my scumlist.

Right now, we wait for those who have yet to contribute and those who have said little.

= bitter that he came up short in a battle of wits with Petyr Baelish.

[zoraster]

This is a joke. Zoraster known scum, claims to want to use character names.

F-that.

scum confusion tactic already.

Holy shit, I agree with Benmage on something.

Character-based voting, especially, is a tool to separate the player from the slot, and to be able to justify votes for reasons tied to character/flavour (ie, bullshit) over actual play. No way, no how.

Secondly, Oversoul is 10,000% scum and needs to die.

1) His Moqorro bit is fake if he actually bothered to read the role PM, which he didn't.
2) Since town's faction color is red, scum are incredibly likely to be blue (see ASOS) which Oversoul as slipped as being his faction color.
3) His reaction when being caught as scum (seen it in Marathon games, seen it in BDM) is to play "lol imma dumb newbie" which he is decidedly not.

VOTE: Oversoul

= Bitter that his wife isn't sexually satisfied with only him.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Also, let it be known, before my meta gets overanalyzed as it always does, I am stingy with my vote. I can see Magna is already trying to kindle that fire.

The fire where you call someone scummy and have no active vote in a Large Theme game Day 1 where the lynch threshold is well over 10 and no-one has more than what, 5 right now? And then trot out the 'I'm stingy with my vote' crap self-meta.

Yes, that fire needs stroked with votes.

[Magua]

= Bitter that his wife isn't sexually satisfied with only him.

My god, I so wanted that role just so I could do exactly what you're doing right now.

[Benmage]

MoIs right... noone should really talk to to or comment about his filler shit. If you want to pry like I did initially thats one thing. Otherwise he's a fluff spam game filler. I'm starting to regret that roles institution (mods).

His PR should be once a day or something. Whats stopping him from Spamming the game?

[MagnaofIllusion]

His PR should be once a day or something. Whats stopping him from Spamming the game?

Well clearly nothing ... its what he's doing now. The secret is just ignoring him. Eventually if you don't feed the troll he's going to get bored.

[Magua]

@MoI Oversoul isn't skilled enough to fake post depth. His filler lolz at chesskid, I mean zoraster screams of ineptTown.

This is not true. He did the exact same thing in Brightest Day Mafia, where he had no end of filler "lol" posts.

[diddin]

New suggestion

- everyone pretty much ignores Zoraster. Every single thing he says in thread

1. Is inherently WIFOM given his status.
2. Is meaningless to scum-hunting efforts.

^

Character voting and acting in character are all pointless distraction tactics.

Also Oversoul needs to die

Vote: Oversoul

[zoraster]

For Stranger's sake, it's not a

distraction

it's the

point

. The point of the game is to play a game of mafia set in the world of a song of ice and fire. Maybe speaking in characters makes things a bit harder, but (a) it'll get easier and (b) it makes the game more

fun

. And the game is about fun.

[zoraster]

oh and VOTE: Blue Bard

[zoraster]

New suggestion

- everyone pretty much ignores Zoraster. Every single thing he says in thread

1. Is inherently WIFOM given his status.
2. Is meaningless to scum-hunting efforts.

^

Character voting and acting in character are all pointless distraction tactics.

Also Oversoul needs to die

Vote: Oversoul

Seriously. What the hell kind of post is this? So light on content it's laughable yet a serious throwdown vote on Swyft? Yeah. someone's not in it for Westeros.

[diddin]

I'd explain why Oversoul needs to die but it's basically be copypasting what Magua said so it's not worth the time.