↑ DLG wrote:I read 4nxi3ty's post and was taken with the smear 3, vote someone else nature of it. Nachomamma8's questions were different than mine. I wanted answers to those as well as mine. I wasn't offering Nachomamma8's questions as my reason for voting 4nxi3ty in any way. I saw that 4nxi3ty had posted answers to Nachomamma8 before I posted, but didn't have time to read them or edit the post to acknowledge that fact.
But he didn't smear three. He said that only one of the three were scum, he did not say that all three were. His vote also makes sense because he later said that he did not know which of the three was the scum. So why would he vote for somebody with only a 33% chance of hitting scum?
I said this “Why should it matter if you said it as scum before? I've said lots of things as scum but that doesn't mean that anybody who says it is scum.”
That has nothing to do with meta. My point is that just because somebody has said it as scum, doesn't mean that somebody else who says it as scum. Instead of actually giving a reason for why whatever indecision did was scum motivated you just gave this reasoning which then turned out to be wrong.
Why didn't you just wait to post until after you read the game so far and then give your complete reasoning for your vote?
If it really is just a gut read, than you should know what about that post makes you have that gut read.
↑ Hinduragi wrote:Clarification of what? Are you reading the other posts? I thought it best to ignore the "us" and just move on with the game and remember it for later. What about that makes it look like I thought it was likely to come from town? If you saw it, you should've said "ok, Nacho's either 1.) derp'ing 2.) reaction fishing 3.) being a failure of a mason or 4.) scum. 3/4 of those are town but that doesn't mean it's likely to come from town. Instead, it's best to remember it when you look at Nacho later on in the game and when you think he's actually scum, bring it up. Until then, if he's town, you might've just handed scum a mason.
That is exactly why you need clarification as to which of the 4 it actually is. I don't understand what you mean when you say “ 3/4 of those are town but that doesn't mean it's likely to come from town.”
What about my questions is useless and stupid? Also, are you saying that i'm not scummy or your quotes aren't scummy?
Were you telling the truth when you said that you thought 1 out of those 3 are scum?
What's your reasoning behind this? Also, can you change the light green to a different color, it's hard to tell whether somebody is green or light green.
Why did you change your vote? Did timeater dissuade you from it somehow?
↑ Hinduragi wrote:I thought you were scummy for something a while ago or maybe it was during my reread, I don't really know. You've sort of just been "there" when I've been reading so I haven't paid you much attention. I'll go back to it later. For now, I've got to no-life Skyrim with the little free time have, sleep, go to work, sleep, go to a movie with a date, and I'll get back to you either during my break, before I go to work, or after all of that. I know Faraday will give me plenty of stuff to read through, though. I've been trying to spam but it's not working. I just checked and he has 77 fucking posts. I've got 20-something.
Again, why didn't you go back and read before you voted him?
What?
