D.N. Does Star Wars (Town Victory)

[Slandaar]

ITT: Magna thinks I was trying to avoid the thread but doesnt seem to get that if that was the case why have I instantly reverted to mass post upon returning? why not lurk more?

Magna thinks im a mastermind scum who knew all this so decided to mass post in hopes to hide the fact I as scum was trying to lurk but meanwhile is suggesting I as scum am an idiot who decided avoiding a thread entirely untill I am mentioned is a good idea

Magna is being ridiculous. Hes scum.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Well thats the truth.

Well, it’s at least what you are presenting as the truth.

So who is scum who is voting Fennin then? and I assume you think Fennin is town. Why is that?

Once you flip scum I can go back and review the timing and speed. On gut I had a scum read on Kdub from the original thread.

As to Fennin – he’s null. His posting was whelming in the first thread but hardly obv-scum. On the other hand plenty of my scum reads (such as yourself) are voting him which makes me think he probably is Town.

No I am saying I as scum wouldnt play full on retarded which is what you are suggesting.

And yet you think everyone you call scum is doing the same. So, no, I’ll take your self-meta and throw it out the window thanks.

Do you agree? you vote yourself if I am town?

Why aren’t you voting yourself or me? I find it hard to take this for anything other than scummy grandstanding given I am the only one of us actually voting each other. You aren’t even agreeing that it’s a 1 v 1 but keep asking me about it. Funny, huh?

I think you missed the point. I view you as viewing me as 1 which makes me believe you are 2 or 3 because a townie assuming someone is 1 is 3 or 1 themselves... However you seem intelligent so you are in fact 2. Scum.

Yup, that’s complete crap. I view you as scummy and am voting you. Your over-simplified and stance on the situation really isn’t relevant to me.

[Slandaar]

Magna just agree or disagree

do you want the 1v1 or not?

are you sure I am scum or not?

why so coy? why do you keep dodging?

[Iecerint]

That reminds me ... why are you so 'emotional' over my observation that you were fence-sitting on Slandaar?

Because it was a misreading/misrepresentation, and the same one that Slandaar had been making for an entire page of text.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Nope. Once you actually make a commitment yourself then we can talk.

Until then keep up with your empty posturing about 1 v 1.

[Slandaar]

You seem so certain im scum but at the last minute you back off?

How strange.

[Foxace36]

I cant be bothered to read ALL of these WoTs on my phone atm but I'm getting a town read on slandaar and magna looks like a townie trying too hard.

[MagnaofIllusion]

You seem so certain im scum but at the last minute you back off?

How strange.

Lulz. I've backed off? I'm still voting for you. How have I backed off?

I'm ignoring the smoke-screen that you are attempting to raise with your empty 1 v 1. You know ... the one you keep talking about while not voting me. It's empty posturing by which you are artificially trying to present a Town persona.

If you really thought it was a 1v1 situation you would have actually voted me. You haven't. You are blowing smoke hoping to distract people.

Why aren't you voting me again if you really want a 1v1?

[MagnaofIllusion]

I cant be bothered to read ALL of these WoTs on my phone atm but I'm getting a town read on slandaar and magna looks like a townie trying too hard.

Did you just call the Slandaar versus Me series of posts Town versus Town without having actually read the posts?

[Foxace36]

I read the jist of it.


Like I said, it was just my first impression. I'll be sure to reread it in it's entirety right now. Dont expect a respons for a while tho as I am on my phone.

[Slandaar]

I dont care about 1v1, SD is better vote than you...

I just wanted to see if you really believe I am scum but you failed.

[Slandaar]

Already highest post count and people accuse me of lurking? scummy as anything. Its an easy reason with no basis. I did not know thread existed and there is no evidence to the contrary including the fact I didnt receive a pm which SD seemed to find unbelievable... yet how could I get away with lying there? hes scum.

[MagnaofIllusion]

I dont care about 1v1, SD is better vote than you...I just wanted to see if you really believe I am scum but you failed.

You pretty much are solidifying my opinion that you are indeed 1 on that list of yours.

I don't think you are scum? I'm voting you and holding your feet to the fire.

But Shadow is a better vote than me when you think I'm scum? One of us is afraid to support their position that the other is scum. It's not me.

[Slandaar]

You make it sound like I have not clearly stated I think SD is scum also

What is the issue with me voting SD a scum read and not you Magna? what is my scum motivation behind it?

[SleepyKrew]

I am awesome because I changed my avatar to Rick Santorum.

[MagnaofIllusion]

@Kdub

- In reading throught he archives here is what Fennin said about Malee with his Slan vote -

I suggest we lynch Slandaar today.

Vote: Slandaar

Accused Malee of being prob scum. Me thinks he is afraid that Malee will last long enough to put on interesting reads and analyses. You trying to discredit her = scummy. Although what she posted = more of a summary than real reads, she did something. What did you do?

I disagree wholeheartedly with your suggestion that Fennin voted Slan for anything other than Slan's bad vote on Malee for giving content. And also your stance that he admitted it wasn't content isn't valid - he says it was 'MORE' a summary. The important word is more.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Oh and another little tidbit from the archive

This guy is scum

Its obvious.

He tried to lurk out of the early suspicion he garnered.

What do we see here? Direct acknowledgement from Slandaar that scum will attempt to lurk out pressure early on in the game (in the quote above he is referring to Fennin).

Yet when I call him out for doing the exact same thing he goes off on a rant about how that's the stupidest play ever for scum. See the Cognitive Dissoance? Can't be a valid tell to use against someone (Fennin) that suddenly isn't a valid tell when applied to himself.

Confirm Vote - Slandaar

[Shadow Dancer]

Hmmm... I read till Magna's #77 so far and possibly realized something. So before I go into further in depth analysis of the Slan case I'd like to have a theory cleared up that just appeared on my attention:

@DN: Can you please openly confirm to us whether you prodded every one or just the people that did not show up in the signup thread?

[Slandaar]

I didnt lurk

I didnt know the thread existed

How hard is that to comprehend?

[Shadow Dancer]

OK, having read it all there's nothing more to add for now...

Just to every one not in {Iec, Slan, myself}: In case DN does not answer, please state whether you received a prod when this thread came back online.

[Midnight's Sorrow]

What the heck is wrong with you people?

Why are we pushing this 'Lurking' thing on Slandaar?

It's as easy as checking the pm you got that said that D1 was starting.

See anything missing or not?

[MagnaofIllusion]

What the heck is wrong with you people?

Why are we pushing this 'Lurking' thing on Slandaar?

It's as easy as checking the pm you got that said that D1 was starting.

See anything missing or not?

Some of us did not get start of day Pms from Deathnote ...

The question remains - do you find his explanation that he posted in the Reboot Queue thread that he as back in and continued to post on site but failed to either check back in on the status of the game in the Reboot thread or look in the Large Theme area believable?

[Midnight's Sorrow]

Yes Magna, I'm well aware that not everyone in the game got the same Day start pm as me. Although...

As to your question- what does it matter?

It's all WIFOM to me- or perhaps a better word/phrase would be 'irrelevant'.

Maybe when he first posted in this thread, is when he first checked up on the status of the game?

How am I to know this happened, or whether he in fact just lurked until he posted?

I'm not, and therefore it won't have any bearing on whether I think he is scum or not.

I'm kind of surprised that it seems that way for others though. It's baffling.

Anyways, I've got a loads more pages to re-read(I'm not sure there is all the pages, as I'm finding it hard find certain ones.. but I'll get there.), but I'll probably something later tonight or tomorrow.

[SleepyKrew]

dear god
the cache is sucking my will to live

[PeregrineV]

Still here, but still need to look back over the first 10 pages.