Mini 1313: Blood Bowl Mafia (Game over)

[Glork]

GI, who exactly do you think are the scums right now?

Vote count

(10 players alive = 6 to lynch)
(3) Slandaar – GreyICE, PeregrineV, pizzadudes7
(2) PeregrineV - Tierce, Glork,
(1) Glork – inte
(1) StefanB – Ghostlin
(1) pizzadudes7 – Slandaar

Not voting

: Dazzy, StefanB,

Deadline

: Saturday 31 March 20:00 CET

[Slandaar]

And the reason for that is to eliminate timing tells?

[Glork]

For me, it's just habit when I'm on my home desktop. I always open every game, and start reading through them. Sometimes I get wrapped up in something that needs to be addressed. Other times, I will read multiple/all games and go back and post afterwards.

Regardless, that's just one possible explanation for why there may have only been a two-minute gap between Pizza's posts. For all we know, maybe he hit Preview on one instead of Submit, so the post times are off. Or he was forced into a preview.

While I understand your perspective, I have to say, you're not on the right track.

[Pizzadudes7]

The explanation of time difference between games, I read through this game, saw that I needed to post here (got a prod), soI opened it in a new tab. I read through it, then went to eat some food (doughnuts if you must ask), came back read my other threads and forgot to post here. I hhad already read everything, just hadn't posted my vote.

[Slandaar]

So... you didnt ISO me?

[Pizzadudes7]

I did.

[Ghostlin]

[quote="In post 287, PeregrineVI reread day1 half-assed, but I'm not going to go back to read it again to defend against whatever reason your giving (bad vote?).

And since you think Slandaar is town,

ask him what he thinks about Ghostlin and inte, and if one HAD to die, which would he pick?

[/quote]

quote="In post 286, PeregrineV"]

@Slandaar- Suppose I were to

stop voting you, but would then only vote Ghostlin or Inte. Who should I vote and why

?

Well, I didn't really expect an answer, so not surprised I didn't get one.

I'm good with my vote on any of these three.[/quote]

@Slandaar- Suppose I were to stop voting you, but would then only vote Ghostlin or Inte. Who should I vote and why?[/b]

*Plays the Sesame Street Song* One of these things is not like the others. One of these things just doesn't belong...

You didn't really ask what his opinion was. You offered him a prisoners dilemma: in exchange for your vote, either inte or I must be scum. He may not believe either of us are scum, and you're scum so your vote doesn't really matter, for example. The question's bullshit, you

know

it's bullshit and you're fishing for a fake associative tell to use later.

[Ghostlin]

In fact I'm really tired of this.

Unvote.

Vote: PV

[Glork]

In fact I'm really tired of this.

Unvote.

Vote: PV

A++ post.

Would read again.

[Slandaar]

Pizza...
You know why I checked your post history when I did? because ISOing someone? you? didnt make sense... I knew you were lying and you are.

also nice explanation: 'oh well you know I read the thread then OH I GOTS PROD BETTA POST' with such a detailed explanation telling me you got doughnuts which yes I needed to know! but you forgot the part where you ISOed me apparently. Its basically the only explanation (in theory) you could give but you botched it.

Pizza is so obvscum here...

[inte]

completely re-reading and posting my thoughts:

reading up to page 8 (day one):

im for a PV lynch (now), he rubbed me the wrong way
pizzadudes was skimming too hard, saying he is confused is a load of bullshit
kondi should not of been lynched
i still retain what i said a few pages back (that slandaar seems scummy for things hes posted). he has a weird way of posting exactly what people need to hear

more will come later :p

[GreyICE]

Pizza...
You know why I checked your post history when I did? because ISOing someone? you? didnt make sense... I knew you were lying and you are.

also nice explanation: 'oh well you know I read the thread then OH I GOTS PROD BETTA POST' with such a detailed explanation telling me you got doughnuts which yes I needed to know! but you forgot the part where you ISOed me apparently. Its basically the only explanation (in theory) you could give but you botched it.

Pizza is so obvscum here...

...

This is town?

[Slandaar]

yep

[Tierce]

Catch up later today. Sorry, general burn out in most of my games. >_<

[PeregrineV]

PV are you trying to make a point?

What is scummy about not answering a very pointless question?

Why are you voting me? do you have reasons? (nice not answering my question which you seem to say is scummy)

My point is I want your opinion on inte & Ghostlin, whom I suspect are scum. However, I also suspect you are scum. That is my point.

It wasn't a pointless question.

I'm voting you because I suspect you are scum with inte and Ghostlin.

[PeregrineV]

PV, my "not very good reasons" are as follows:
1) You called out pappums, especially for his Kondi-vote while jumping into the Kondiwagon yourself without giving reason.
2) Your attitude towards lynching/bombing Kondi indicates that you knew pappums to be a kill target, and is consistent with how I would expect scum to behave.
3) You're encouraging infighting amongst people I consider more-likely protown while largely sitting on the sidelines and failing to respond to things directed to you.

That's plenty enough to run you up.

1) OK. I'm sure I had reason at the time.
2) Not sure what this means, but I'm past day1, so OK.
3) What has been directed at me that I've failed to respond? Link or post please, and I'll be glad to respond.
And just because you consider them pro-town doesn't mean I do. And it doesn't look like anyone (my top 3) is fighting at all, so I don't get that part either.

[Slandaar]

ghost town inte scum as I have said before

So, what valuable information have you obtained?

[PeregrineV]

PeregrineVI reread day1 half-assed, but I'm not going to go back to read it again to defend against whatever reason your giving (bad vote?).

And since you think Slandaar is town,

ask him what he thinks about Ghostlin and inte, and if one HAD to die, which would he pick?

@Slandaar- Suppose I were to

stop voting you, but would then only vote Ghostlin or Inte. Who should I vote and why

?

Well, I didn't really expect an answer, so not surprised I didn't get one.

I'm good with my vote on any of these three.

@Slandaar- Suppose I were to stop voting you, but would then only vote Ghostlin or Inte. Who should I vote and why?

*Plays the Sesame Street Song* One of these things is not like the others. One of these things just doesn't belong...

You didn't really ask what his opinion was. You offered him a prisoners dilemma: in exchange for your vote, either inte or I must be scum. He may not believe either of us are scum, and you're scum so your vote doesn't really matter, for example. The question's bullshit, you

know

it's bullshit and you're fishing for a fake associative tell to use later.

Firstly, it was a different way of asking for his opinion on you two. You can misread it however you like.

Secondly, what was his answer?
What would town-Slandaar say?
What would scum-Slandaar say?
What would scum-Slandaar say if inte and/or Ghostlin were on his team?

I play mafia basing many of my expectation of responses to be similar to mine in the same situation. So, if someone answers (or doesn't) in a way I would as town, I tend to see them as town. I know others don't play that way, but to each his own.

Also, your current reads on all the players, please.

[PeregrineV]

ghost town inte scum as I have said before

So, what valuable information have you obtained?

Just more info, which I want/need/like.

[Glork]

Yeah, PV needs hanged now.

What are you waiting for, Slandaar and GreyICE?

[Slandaar]

PV is good but pizza is just better.

He clearly lied.

[Johoohno]

Vote count

(10 players alive = 6 to lynch)
(3) Slandaar – GreyICE, PeregrineV, pizzadudes7
(3) PeregrineV - Tierce, Glork, Ghostlin
(1) Glork – inte
(1) pizzadudes7 – Slandaar

Not voting

: Dazzy, StefanB,

Deadline

: Saturday 31 March 20:00 CET

[Pizzadudes7]

Pizza...
You know why I checked your post history when I did? because ISOing someone? you? didnt make sense... I knew you were lying and you are.

also nice explanation: 'oh well you know I read the thread then OH I GOTS PROD BETTA POST' with such a detailed explanation telling me you got doughnuts which yes I needed to know! but you forgot the part where you ISOed me apparently. Its basically the only explanation (in theory) you could give but you botched it.

Pizza is so obvscum here...

...

This is town?

yep

Is this confusing to anyone else?

PV is good but pizza is just better.

He clearly lied.

Pizza did no lies. He did that, he just thought that saying that he was looking through the thread and things would let you make that connection. Sorry for not giving you a minute by minute account of what I did.

[Glork]

PV is good but pizza is just better.

He clearly lied.

You're arguing that your case of word-choice/semantics is better than PV's acceptance of two completely legitimate points against him and a canned lazyscum response to the rest? Are you actually being serious?

Pizza did not lie. He just wasn't crystal clear in explaining how he read the thread. I am having a VERY difficult time believing that you actually think you caught him in any kind of lie.





On a somewhat related note, it occurred to me a little but ago that the scums are probably not busing/voting each other right now, given the probable multiball/SK situation and the plethora of decent lynch candidates. I'd say that as of this exact moment, there's probably only one scum voting a scumbuddy. Just skme food for thought.

[PeregrineV]

You're arguing that your case of word-choice/semantics is better than PV's acceptance of two completely legitimate points against him and a canned lazyscum response to the rest? Are you actually being serious?

3) What has been directed at me that I've failed to respond? Link or post please, and I'll be glad to respond.

What two points? And how have I responded if I've failed to respond?