This is an amazing OMGUS, and I'm trying to figure out if it's scummy. Food for thought.
Grey did not declare Ghostlin town for one action. I was the one who said his vote on StefanB/BBmolla when he could have jumped on Slandaar (most likely scum) was very good (though in retrospect, with my current townreads, it's actually a red light and requires review tomorrow).
Since I can now say this, my original scumread on Ghostlin was due to a (then ongoing) game in which he had flipped scum and was acting very similarly to this game. On closer inspection, the comparison doesn't seem to hold.
As scumbuddies, I would powerbus Grey like a boss.
I am not scum, and I think Grey is town. You're right, if we were scum together it would make the whole trading votes situation make me look awesome and selfless and super townie while not taking any actual risks, but I've been bending over with protown actions for most of today. (Yes, yes, I know, nauseating. Btw, by ridiculously protown I was actually referring to the other three because reckless I-don't-care abandon from me
, but anyway.) My reply as for Grey being town is NOT wrong at all. Glork posited a very clear explanation as to why Grey is very unlikely to be scum, and I agree with it. Post 366, pointed out by Slandaar
of all people, is not coaching--it's me trying to pull the confrontational level down. I know that, as scum, there's little else I love more than to see Grey tunnel town to their grave while being obnoxious and loud.For scum meta. (Also Glork and GreyICE town meta.) That's a completely different definition of cowardly.
The MVP quotes say:
"I nominated Tierce because I did see her as most pro-town."
Come D2:
"I haven't decided on the legitimacy of Tierce's little "vengekill" frenzy.
Glork is an early town read."
"At the end of D1, I was reading inte and [Tierce] as weakTown."
And now this, from your latest post:
"Going into N1 you were my top pro-town rank followed by Glork."
So... when day started today, you said that inte and I were weak town reads on the end of D1. Glork did not feature on that list.
I just fail to see how your strongest town reads on D1 are three
weak
town reads, since you were reading me as weakTown, inte as weakTown and apparently Glork as weakTown too (where did that come from, again?). They are far too soft, uncompromising reads. I am not afraid of changing my reads, heck, as town I've been known to tunnel on scum, call them town and tunnel someobe else who then flips town. :/ But your reads... meh. You do not take strong stances, those reads are weaselly.It's not that you changed your read on me, it's that on early D2, you show no record of having a good, solid townread on me from D1. You have an "early town read" on Glork". Why did the MVP go to me and not Glork, then?
PEdit: Ghostlin has not been on MS.
PeregrineV, you know better about my town meta. MwtK had Tiercetown completely confused about why I was alive.
As for Glork, you are clearly not reading the thread. He changed his mind on Slandaar. As town does. Seriously, Glork is town, and so is pizza. I can't make this any clearer.
