Open 388: Medical Mafia (Game Over)

[Hoopla]

Just a reminder that the night phase ends in a little over 12 hours. Any players who fail to submit an action will forfeit it - this is the only warning I am giving.

[Hoopla]

An eventful night unfolds:

DCLXVI

has died Night 1. He was a

Town Doctor

.

Thomith

has died Night 1. He was a

Town Doctor

.

SaintKerrigan

has died Night 1. He was a

Town Doctor

.

Alicewondering

has died Night 1. She was a

Mafia Goon

.

Day 2, Vote Count #1

With four alive, it takes

3

votes to lynch and

2

votes to no lynch. Deadline is scheduled for 09:00 GMT, April 22nd <Countdown>.

Not voting -

4

(Elmo TeH AzN, kondi2424, HippoEtymologist, Om of the Nom)

[Elmo TeH AzN]

So were at lylo after one night. This is wonderful

[kondi2424]

Wow...

We all need to claim targets. I targeted Thomith, hoping I was a Vigilante.

[Om of the Nom]

I targeted Hippo, hoping I was a doc.

[HippoEtymologist]

I targeted DCLXVI
Hoping it would make him die.

[Elmo TeH AzN]

I was on Kondi. So now thats setteled. Tome to read this back over

[Om of the Nom]

Why were you on kondi?

[kondi2424]

Om, why did you want Hippo protected?

Looking at double-ISOs with Alice and each of you, I'm thinking Elmo is probably town.

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Why were you on kondi?

I can give a list of reasons. But really I figured I was a doc with no powers. And I either would have been on you Om or Kondi.

[Elmo TeH AzN]

And we can have some of the crew from 377 in here

[Om of the Nom]

Who do you guys think was the mafia kill? I'm guessing SK.

Now we know from the night results that one of the dead people doc'ed Alice and killed him. I don't know which one yet.
Kondi is presumably a vig doc, Hippo too.
I am either a do nothing doc or a protect doc, Elmo is the same

[HippoEtymologist]

I would rather not speculate
Who mafia tried to eliminate.
With protects and kills being so widespread
Their target may not even be dead.

There's an age-old tell that's basically
Vote someone, FoS a buddy.
This post looks to me like that tell
Which would make kondi as well.

[HippoEtymologist]

Whoops, missed a word, silly me
This is what it was meant to be:

I would rather not speculateWho mafia tried to eliminate.With protects and kills being so widespreadTheir target may not even be dead.There's an age-old tell that's basicallyVote someone, FoS a buddy.This post looks to me like that tellWhich would make kondi

scum

as well.

[Om of the Nom]

@Kondi: I thought Hippo was town.

@Hippo: Yeah we can tell that the mafia nightkill went through. There are only three possible doctors that can die or kill, the weak doc (dies when targets a mafia goon), the CPR doc (kills their target if they aren't being nightkilled) and Quack doc (kills their target instead of protecting them). Yet there were 4 deaths, meaning the nk went through.

One of the CPR doc or the Quack must have killed Alice, and it must have been someone who died because nobody is claiming the death.
The scum nk is most likely SK. As both you and kondi have claimed two of the deaths as your targets.

Really, the only people alive who haven't killed anyone are Elmo and I. Our targets aren't confirmed, unlike kondi and Hippo. However, I know I'm town, which leaves Elmo as the last scum.

FoS: Elmo

Do you guys agree?

[Om of the Nom]

Wait, I just realised that one of kondi/Hippo could also just be claiming the kill to appear town.

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Om - there's too much grey area here. Exactly anyone can claim the kill.

[kondi2424]

Anyone up for a no-lynch, agreeing that no one targets anyone? It would be the equivalent of no-lynching in a regular game.

[Om of the Nom]

Yeah, I'm up for it.

[kondi2424]

Actually, I'm pretty sure we could game the system here to our advantage. I'll come up with a reasonable plan tomorrow. I'ma go back to finishing Soul Eater. <3

[Om of the Nom]

Yay Soul Eater :D

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Yeah, I'm up for it.

[HippoEtymologist]

@Hippo: Yeah we can tell that the mafia nightkill went through. There are only three possible doctors that can die or kill, the weak doc (dies when targets a mafia goon), the CPR doc (kills their target if they aren't being nightkilled) and Quack doc (kills their target instead of protecting them). Yet there were 4 deaths, meaning the nk went through.

I stand corrected, scum kill went through
And every possible death did too.

Anyone up for a no-lynch, agreeing that no one targets anyone? It would be the equivalent of no-lynching in a regular game.

I like this plan, we should do it
As soon as kondi agrees to it.

[kondi2424]

I've been working through breaking the game for the past hour or so, but there's no possible way because we targeted 2-2 (two of us targeted live people, two of us targeted dead people).

We do know something, though. Elmo and OmNom can't be killing Doctors. Both of you should be on either Hippo or me tonight. Decide before we no-lynch.

[Om of the Nom]

No, if we are on one of you two then the mafia will just kill one of Me/Elmo.

I'm not going to say my target, and I advise Elmo does the same.