Worst Role Mafia - GAME OVER!

[saulres]

it would make a lot more sense as a duplicating alignment role

No it wouldn't. It would be very broken. A transformed scum could just out their scumpartners.

[Gimmicky Alt]

that wouldn't hurt the cultleader though.

[saulres]

there are no other aspects to my role

Actually there is: Whether it's one-shot, once-per-day, x times, etc.

[Phillammon]

Ooh. Good point. I don't know what happens if scum target me, I will ask the mod. This role is a bit powerful, but there is a power limiter on it that I will NOT be sharing, for obvious reasons. I maintain that I am not a third party, still.

[Phillammon]

Ooh. Good point. I don't know what happens if scum target me, I will ask the mod. This role is a bit powerful, but there is a power limiter on it that I will NOT be sharing, for obvious reasons. I maintain that I am not a third party, still.

[Gimmicky Alt]

oh i see what you are saying. I'm not quite familiar with the cult leader aspect. It just seems like a really weird town role. maybe survivor

[Gimmicky Alt]

okay phil i believes ya if there some inhibitor you aren't claiming.

[ShadowGirl]

Is it a habit for you to say if [so and so] flips [whatever], then [so-so] is next? Because that's the second time you've done it.

Then I guess it is a habit

Sometimes (often?) I have null reads on someone, which will only go one way or the other based on associative tells with someone else -- which I can't get until that other person flips. In the case you're quoting, I have a null read on Hippos, but if you flip scum (which I doubt, because I have a townread on you) I'd be looking for additional relationships between him and you.

As to why I mention it, would you rather I don't mention where I think people should look for connections? I've been helped in scumhunting by dead townies who posted their associations (and other thoughts), and then when I'm rereading after more information comes out, I suddenly see an association they mentioned (or something else) and catch scum. So why wouldn't I want to do the same for others?

I'm not sure if I can say it's a good habit or not. :/

Alright, that makes a little more sense, considering we're on D1 (although two people are dead that isn't much) that there's no solid reads at the moment. I don't actually ever remember quoting Hippo, but thanks for the vote of confidence, nonetheless?

Hmm, I see. So it's more like a signal for other players who might think I were scum that then it would make sense to look at this person? I was more so seeing it as you just putting it out of there as some sort of mechanism for flip flopping.

there are no other aspects to my role

Actually there is: Whether it's one-shot, once-per-day, x times, etc.

Falls under the blanket of 'my power'. (Or at least that's what I was trying to get that.) I mean I don't have any secondary powers or other side conditions or some such.

[knox]

there are no other aspects to my role

Actually there is: Whether it's one-shot, once-per-day, x times, etc.

Falls under the blanket of 'my power'. (Or at least that's what I was trying to get that.) I mean I don't have any secondary powers or other side conditions or some such.

[Candy Corn Vampire]

So did everyone miss BBmolla's rolefishing and lying?

Candy corn, What actually stops you from posting regulary?

So did everyone miss Captain Haddock's Rolefishing and hypocrisy?

[Phillammon]

So did everyone miss BBmolla's rolefishing and lying?

Candy corn, What actually stops you from posting regulary?

So did everyone miss Captain Haddock's Rolefishing and hypocrisy?

QFT.

[BBmolla]

VOTE: Captain Haddock

I'm leaving this here, on Captain Haddock

Only six posts and all of them suck

He's either scum or lyncher, I don't know which one

Let's lynch this kid and get the deed done.


Phil seems town, that's what I think

But I have an idea that might have a kink

Moneybags' role seems pretty bad

He could explode making me sad

If he can visit, even if it's "kill"

He should try targetting good old Phil

[mcqueen]

BAK FROM V/LA!!!111! WTF IT SEMS A LOT HAS HAP3NED AND IN AL HONESTY I DO NOT LIEK 2 READ 15 PAEGS!!1!1!1! OMG WTF LOL I WIL TRY 2 BLAND BAK IN2 THIS GME!!!!!!!1 LOL

ANYWAYS I DONT SE DA BIG DEAL AS ITS BASTARD MODNG SO TEH GMAS HALF SCR3W3D ALRAADY!!!!1!!! WTF P

[Teleporting Speed Hippos]

Because town would want to be altruistic, not selfish.

Unfortunately, this is not often true. What is your mafia experience, TSH?

I've played with you before on a number of occasions.

Anyone targeting me loses their role and becomes a ditto too.

Does this make them a carbon-copy, i.e. the same alignment as you? As in, should we be looking at this as a reverse-cultist, even if you're town it would still work the same way? Because if so this game is nine kinds of broken.

So did everyone miss BBmolla's rolefishing and lying?

Candy corn, What actually stops you from posting regulary?

So did everyone miss Captain Haddock's Rolefishing and hypocrisy?

QFT.

QQFT

[saulres]

Umm, no. I'm missing it. Spell it out for the dumb ones.

[mcqueen]

LOL MCQUEEN.
I THINK.
WE HAVE.
SAME ROLE.

NO IT LOKS LIEK UR IS 2 POST FLUF AND INCLUD3 LOL EV3RY TIEM OR SOMETHNG LIEK TAHT1!111 OMG WTF

[ShadowGirl]

there are no other aspects to my role

Actually there is: Whether it's one-shot, once-per-day, x times, etc.

Falls under the blanket of 'my power'. (Or at least that's what I was trying to get that.) I mean I don't have any secondary powers or other side conditions or some such.

Props for using Dark Phoenix. Anyway, I feel it's best that I don't answer.

@Moneybags: Is your comprised of anything other than your post restriction and that you explode at an undetermined time?

Umm, no. I'm missing it. Spell it out for the dumb ones.

Captain pointed that BBmolla was rolefishing, and then Captain asked Candy Corn about her post restriction (role fishing).

[Amrun]

Then you should know better than to assume town isn't selfish, tSH.

Phillamon's role makes me uncomfortable and I think he's scummy in his own right. LYNCH PLZ

[saulres]

Captain asked Candy Corn about her post restriction (role fishing).

Oh I see. I didn't think that was rolefishing because I don't equate post restrictions with roles. And especially in this game, an annoying post restriction != a bad role, but is probably laid on top of a bad role.

[saulres]

Phillamon's role makes me uncomfortable

Why?

I don't know what to make of him yet. If it's a real claim it does seem townie. If it's a fakeclaim it's a good one to discourage investigations. Of course...

I know I'm a newbie, so shouldn't know it

Playing the newbie card in a newbie game is one thing. Playing it defensively in a non-newbie game is also one thing. But playing it

in advance

over something no one called you out on? What's your thinking here?

[Amrun]

I disagree that if the claim is real it's townie. It's very difficult to balance for town. It would absolutely cripple any scum faction that targetted him. It makes a lot more sense as a scum role.

[Oversoul]

I'm back.

Gimmicky I'll respond to your vote, but another game of mine basically doubled in size while I was away.

[ShadowGirl]

Captain asked Candy Corn about her post restriction (role fishing).

Oh I see. I didn't think that was rolefishing because I don't equate post restrictions with roles. And especially in this game, an annoying post restriction != a bad role, but is probably laid on top of a bad role.

I don't think it's really a perfect parallel either, but it's amusing at the very least.

I disagree that if the claim is real it's townie. It's very difficult to balance for town. It would absolutely cripple any scum faction that targetted him. It makes a lot more sense as a scum role.

So why would he claim it?

[Amrun]

So why would he claim it?

He has to claim something - and he might not understand balance, and this IS the worst roles mafia. He can definitely appeal to benefit of the doubt, but I'm not buying it.

If I didn't find him scummy on his own, I might watch and see, but I think he's scummy, and I think his role is more likely scum, so I think we should lynch him.

[saulres]

Hmm...

I don't know what happens if scum target me, I will ask the mod

It makes sense that as scum, he wouldn't have thought to ask what would happen if scum targeted him...

I'll have to ISO him and see if there's a strong enough case.