NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[jasonT1981]

I don't see any reason as town you would avoid/refuse to answer questions.

Anyway, my usual weekend V/LA,

back Sunday night/Monday morning - depending on Hangover. Drink and 2 Football games, F1 and NASCAR.

[drmyshottyizsik]

I'm just not seeing rack as all to scummy atm.
Also with psych, I think he may just be bad, or not know how to play, but wants to act like he can. His attitude is coming off more arrogant than it is scummy.

[Benmage]

Not nero tho shotty.

[DeasVail]

Mastin2:

Are you just asking for the sake of asking, or do you actually want the reasoning? Also, why do you find the reasoning for my other townreads satisfying?

Mini-lib:

Why does drmy need to be vigged?

Hez has moved to weak town, mostly because of his jump on benmage.

Jason:

What reason is there for scum to avoid/refuse to answer questions?

[drmyshotgun]

Question by Deasvail: drmyshotgun: Why did you mention the questions if you didn't think it was a good idea?

Cuz I always do them, and in this game there were 24 people. I always got criticised for throwing "useless" questions so I didn't want some people answer and others don't. But y'know, its worth a mention. If a lot of people like to have questions, I would have posted them.

[drmyshotgun]

Hmm...I'd certainly not want to get vigged...It's my first PR!

[Benmage]

Gunny, your reverse role baiting is too obvious.

[drmyshotgun]

??? I'm Town's Universal Backup

[drmyshotgun]

Which means, if a PR dies, I get his role.
So I shouldn't die. So someone else should.

[Candy Corn Vampire]

stop...just stop drmy...

[Benmage]

*headdesk*

[DeasVail]

Not my reaction at all, but ok.

[Pine]

Guh. Thought that was newb scum overplaying a softclaim, but that's definitely newb Town.

Unvote
Vote: Rack

The suspicion of Firestarter has merit. Going to stick with my earlier vote

[Nero Cain]

I disagree.

[Pine]

With...?

[mastin2]

Mastin2: Are you just asking for the sake of asking, or do you actually want the reasoning?

Wouldn't have asked if I didn't want an answer. Yes, I want reasoning.

---

As it stands, I've got a Khan-Ninja-Firestarter scumteam; drmy's been knocked off for obvious reasons. rack

might

be joining, but that'd still be only 4/6; I am about to reconsider a few things. Be back later.

[Macros]

I'm going to go ahead and

vote benmage

Now I had decided to do this based on post 305, the second I read it.
Overreact to one vote much? He then suddenly becomes a proactive player.
Its just too micof a reaction, his following posts do nothing to change my impression of someone trying to push attention away from themselves entirely too hard.

[DeasVail]

Mini-lib-

Combination of appearing genuine, short posts with limited explanation of his opinions, little things like the compilation of townreads and the read on firestarter and not being scummy.

Mastin2-

I can't see you as scum doing what you're doing with KK unless it's as an excuse to look town while tunnelling. Your posting that is unrelated to KK makes this unlikely.

Shotty-

His posting seems good. I particularly like his recent thoughts on rack and psyche.

Candy-

This read is really weak. Not much more than a weak feeling really.

LLD-

Seems quite genuine, and I find the little inconsistencies that have been pointed out in her posts to be towntells.

vijay-

Looks like natural town posting overall. Main thing is his reasonless vote for drmy and reaction to being called out for it.

Null reads basically mean I can't work out whether their posting to date has been indicative of town or scum.

PEdit: Move macros to weak town. I'll decide what I think of Benmage later.

[Benmage]

I'm going to go ahead and

vote benmage

Now I had decided to do this based on post 305, the second I read it.
Overreact to one vote much? He then suddenly becomes a proactive player.
Its just too micof a reaction, his following posts do nothing to change my impression of someone trying to push attention away from themselves entirely too hard.

What would've been a proper reaction?

Moreover I found the vote baseless, and ironic as I was calling hezzy scum.

[Benmage]

Oh, and what do you mean by me "suddenly becoming a proactive player"....?

[drmyshotgun]

Thought Benmage was Best Town Performance...Wouldn't it be disadvantageous to Town if we were to lynch him??

[DeasVail]

Actually shotgun might be scum.

[Benmage]

Yes, I am definitely one of the better/best and more experienced player on this list. KK being another legit and experienced player. And Mastin being a pain for a long time now.

Tho one should consider that a double edge sword, as I would be the best possible scum on the list as well.

That said, evaluate me the same as you would anyone. I feel this is more or less pretty standard Benmagetown. There's a lot of people I haven't played with before, or haven't in awhile so explaining things I often consider common occurrences or common knowledge is a bit different for me.

Jason might be able to have a better grasp. Pine certainly should.

[Benmage]

Actually shotgun might be scum.

No way dude.

That absurd claim. No way in hell. That straight 100% noob town. It won't even matter because the night after the first dead PR, he dies. So you can pretty much ignore him as NK fodder.

[DeasVail]

Hmm, i'll leave it for now, but there may be things I want to discuss later.