Open 379: JK9++ (Game Over)

[Lord Mhork]

No shooting is your best bet, Phillammon, as I don't think there are any obvious targets and you can't be guaranteed to hit scum.

[Lord Mhork]

Also yeah, this is MyLo, as I'm pretty sure nothing rolls up a scum team of 1.

[SpyreX]

Its not mylo if we lynch right and/or take a shot.

Depending on how this shakes out, sacrificing not only a confirmed town but a power role is silly and is simply following the mantra.

(as it sits it is the equivalency of lylo with a confirmed innocent with the only change being the loss of the innocent)

[Lowell]

if we believe vig claim, we should pick two ppl; lynch one, vigkill other. we need be right only about one

[Chimera]

if we believe vig claim, we should pick two ppl; lynch one, vigkill other. we need be right only about one

There's an "if"? There were three kills N1 and the SK has flipped...looks pretty confirmed to me.

On phone so will look over stuff later....as in an hour or so.

[SpyreX]

I'm a huge slacker and I'm not getting to this tonight.

My apologies.

Yo viggenstein if you're figure out the permutations don't present them until after a massclaim.

[Phillammon]

I was planning to. THat way I can see for sure precisely who must be lying, et voila! We have our two kills.

[Phillammon]

What happens when scum = town? Cause if it's 3 v 3...

[SpyreX]

I like the way you think good sir.

Depending on mod it could go to today because of the vig.

[Phillammon]

Okay then. I reckon that some popcorn is in order. If no-one disagrees with a popcorn massclaim, then: TML, please!

[Phillammon]

Right. I've worked out all the possibilities. Don't lie in the massclaim, that's a PLable offence at this point, but suffice it to say that we must have killed off all the VTs. So make this good!
Also, don't challenge my analysis here until I've had a chance to look at the actual claims.

Massclaim Go!

[The Mini-Librarian]

vt

lowell go.

[Phillammon]

Could have sworn I mentioned we were out of VTs. Oh well. We'll see what else comes up.

[Chimera]

but suffice it to say that we must have killed off all the VTs

I'm not sure how you are getting this....so far we have two confirmed letters; your K and iceguy's I...and a serial killer flip. There's either two or three scum...if there are two then there's just you and the two of them that are not VT. If there are three then you're right (the SK makes 4Ts impossible).

Sorry about not getting stuff on here...*sigh*...I'll have to get to it later today, but I'm still rereading through the thread...having kondi and maru BOTH flip town was...surprising and screwed with my reads.

[Phillammon]

Well, so much for that gambit.

[Lowell]

i'm VT. chim next.

again, I'm right about picking two to kill...and phil should stop talking for awhile.

[Lord Mhork]

Chimera, may I ask why in the

hell

did you have to come out and say that other Power Rolls are impossible? Why present the maths before the popcorning's even done? All I can think of is that you were trying to tell your scumbuddy that he shouldn't fakeclaim something like cop with a guilty--or lie at all!

Heavy, massive, and unbelievably big FoS: Chimera

[Chimera]

....I...didn't. Where did I say that they were impossible? I simply was saying that phil's claim that VTs were impossible was false. We have either all PR (+ mafia) or none. not all PR as phil was saying.

Agree with Lowell. And VT.

Spyrex go.

[Lord Mhork]

Well did you ever consider the possibility that Phillammon was attempting to draw out false Power Role claims in order to find obv-scums to lynch and shoot for the glorious win? Gah!

[Phillammon]

Hence, I'll back up that HoS on Chimera, but Spyrex: Do indeed go.

[Chevre]

Vote Count 3-1

(1) No Lynch (The Mini-Librarian)

(5) Not Voting (Chimera, Lord Mhork, Lowell, Phillammon, SpyreX)

With

6

players alive, it takes

4

votes to lynch.
The deadline for Day 3 is

1 May 2012 @ 3:27pm U.S. Central Standard Time

.

[SpyreX]

(Still haven't caught up and on vacation so slow)

VT - Mhork

[Lord Mhork]

Gasp! VT!

That should be everyone...

[Chimera]

Well did you ever consider the possibility that Phillammon was attempting to draw out false Power Role claims in order to find obv-scums to lynch and shoot for the glorious win? Gah!

Briefly. And then I realized that considering we've had two PR flips, one living PR, and the mafia knowing (almost...one case where there is uncertainty) how many Ts were rolled (assuming they're not idiots) it's either ridiculously simple and inconclusive for them to fake-claim PRs or they'd spot it from a mile away; either way all it proves is that the scum are lying, which is basically a given. As in, the gambit was null. Also, considering that Phil is relatively new it was a possibility that he had miscalculated and wind up believing someone scum for the wrong reasons...which is why I wanted to make sure he wasn't just making a simple mistake.

[Lord Mhork]

But. Why. Didn't. You. Wait. Until. The. Claim. Was. Over??????????????