Mini 1313: Blood Bowl Mafia (Game over)

[inte]

shoulda been at least an instant indicator that i knew what i was talking about, and wasn't trying to mislead when i flipped town

[GreyICE]

On other shit that COMPLETELY MISTIFIES ME.

Why would Yates vote BBMolla, as town, believing 100% he was throwing the game away and letting me win
Then insist on no lynching when a plan was reached where we could lynch BBMolla and the town could still win

This makes no fucking sense. At all.

I swear unto god after that moment he was obvious fucking scum, and I still don't understand it. He played completely against his win condition, then when the same decision was faced, NOT against his win condition, he decided against it.

There was like... no town motive there.

[GreyICE]

shoulda been at least an instant indicator that i knew what i was talking about, and wasn't trying to mislead when i flipped town

WELL AT THAT POINT BBMOLLA WAS OBVSCUM
BUT THE PROBLEM WAS THE SERIAL KILLER
WHO DIDN'T EXIST, BUT THE OTHER OPTION WAS SCUM HAD TWO NIGHT KILLS
WHICH IS LIKE... FUCKING RETARDED AND TERRIBLE DESIGN AND HORRIBLE BEYOND ALL BELIEF

[Tierce]

Mhm.

I've never played so selflessly. This is a terrible loss, with the lynches we had. Sorry, Johoohno, but this setup is very bad.

And I was absolutely right to think BB was caring too much about my read on him.

[BBmolla]

And I was absolutely right to think BB was caring too much about my read on him.

That was part town gimmick, part me wondering how long before you realized I was scum.

[inte]

grey you should've saved the troll information till after it was a perceived mislynch
i prob would of believed it more if bbmolla flipped town cause i wasn't gonna start doubting glork with his cop claim, it was too believable

Look at it from my perspective.

You have information that the lynch, IN LYLO that you are about to undertake may be on town.

Do you claim said information, y/n?

Yes, it turned out to be bad to claim, but I still don't fucking understand why any townie in their right mind would do ANYTHING other than claim it right then and there.

i ain't even mad at you for doing it, cause it was reasonable, im just saying its what i would've done, knowing that i was town, and that there is a race cop, you had to of realized you were a secret miller

[GreyICE]

Why?

I mean look at the flavor. Goblins are allied with trolls in blood bowl. It makes perfect sense for there to be trolls on a goblin team.

I mean how the fuck am I going to realize I'm a secret miller?

[Tierce]

And I was absolutely right to think BB was caring too much about my read on him.

That was part town gimmick, part me wondering how long before you realized I was scum.

The second half of that reasoning was what gave me pause. If you were town, you would expect me to read you perfectly well and would not have insisted on it so much at that stage.

Dead QT
Can we have the scum QT?


And sorry for the grumping, Grey. You had no way of realizing you were a miller, but neither did we--so the suspicion was understandable, and particularly painful after I turned myself inside out to get you through N2.

Why did you breadcrumb doc?


Seriously, this hurts, after I did just about everything in D2 to push town forward regardless of whether I survived--and I

did

help town, there were scum lynches D2, D3, scum vigged... and a loss. Ow. ;_;

[inte]

well my line of thought was whats the point of a race cop if there wouldn't be any real results

also seeing as there isn't any investigative roles, i wasn't gonna doubt it at that point

[Tierce]

Race cop.
With a secret miller.
And a godfather.

I don't even.

[GreyICE]

Oh someone did catch it!

The answer was in my role - 1-shot bulletproof. If figured that the breadcrumb was hidden enough that it looked legit but sloppy enough one of the three scum would catch it.

Since I was pretty sure BB was scum and that would leave me obvtown when he flipped plus the breadcrumb, I figured I could draw a kill and then fuck with the scumteam when the kill on the breadcrumbed doctor failed.

[BBmolla]

http://www.quicktopic.com/47/H/tpRZCw9gg2p2s

Scum qt.

[Tierce]

Yeah, I caught it. Being paranoid helps.

So being BP was why you claimed reflexive roleblocker. I was wondering how the claim matched your actual role and why you would breadcrumb that.


This game was very silly, and this is a gentle description of the absurd outcome.

[GreyICE]

So much hate in the deadthread.

Why would a SK ever claim to save scum or visa versa?

No one ever explained that. I was fucking obvious town, and that's not just 'in my opinion.'

Oh well fucktarded game was fucktarded. Scum having two kills a night is insane.

[BBmolla]

Oh yeah.

I think Glork and Majiffy were switched so we killed Majiffy n1 instead of Glork.

[BBmolla]

I don't know why my dead scumbuddies thought there was an SK

[Tierce]

I was trying to keep Majiffy alive through N1. >_< I wanted to call him town at the start of D2, so when he died I was completely thrown in for a loop.

Grey, we... didn't know.
No one did.
You can hardly blame us. ;_:


And yes, I nom'd Glork for MVP N1.


PEdit: Because your team was derping and was lucky enough to have a fourth player named This Whole Bloody Setup.

[GreyICE]

Wait.

Wait.

PV was 1-shot bulletproof too.

SO THE TOWN GETTING VIG SHOTS WAS A TOTALLY WORTHLESS WASTE OF TIME THAT WOULD ONLY MK TOWNIES AND THE ENTIRE MVP MECHANIC WAS A SICK JOKE.

This is on my top 5 worst game lists. Ever.

[BBmolla]

@Johoo:

Who reviewed this?

[Tierce]

Also thinking glork is cop of some sort with his insistence on pizza town. He said it twice. Also feels like a tierce/glork neighbor thing. Tierce is insisting on town glork and there are only a few ways that town is that certain.

Neighbors? No. Gobbie trusts Glork, that's how.

Plus I caught the repeated cop softclaims.

[GreyICE]

Like, let's review:

Flavor cop. Gets a good guilty on two players. Gets false inno on one, gets false guilty on secret miller.

Irritating bomb - might vig someone. But scum were Bulletproof anyway

Bus driver - weaker, since scum couldn't die to night kills.

1-shot bulletproof secret miller - this isn't the scummiest role claim IN THE HISTORY OF EVER

MVP mechanic that wouldn't get off the ground until town lynched scum. Didn't let you vig scum anyway.

Versus:

Scum godfather
Scum bulletproof vigilante
Scum bulletproof

-_-

This is as bad as the Tarhalindur game with the 2 lightnig rod scum-specific PGOs.

[Magister Ludi]

This is as bad as the Tarhalindur game with the 2 lightnig rod scum-specific PGOs.

Oh man that game was awful.

[inte]

will y'all quit being butthurt, shits a game, and we lost
im gonna assign blame here tho, yates, dazzy, and grey lost us this one :p

[Tierce]

It's not butthurt. It's a setup that is heavily skewed toward scum, and it makes no sense that a 13p game in which you mislynch ONCE you end in a scum win.

And no, it was not their fault, so don't you even try. They couldn't expect a double scumkill, a secret miller and BP scum. They did the best with the info they had.

[Slandaar]

Better luck next time town we were just too sneaky for you!

I didnt think there was an sk BB