↑ hasdgfas wrote:Pretty much the entirety of trying to link dead scum to people is WIFOM. What am I supposed to say when it's "well, SD defended X and Y, so they're his buddies"? I said that I find it more likely that scum will defend people they know aren't scumbuddies.
Just because there is WIFOM doesn't mean you can't analyze something, you just have to think and weigh the likelihoods. Just saying it's WIFOM and hoping that flies doesn't work. What tangible evidence do you have that the links split was finding between dead scum and yourself are not valid in this specific scenario?
↑ Iecerint wrote:This thought had crossed Iec's mind too. However, if ever, Iec thinks this should be considered only a) in the very late game and b) when Old Anakin and/or Vader haven't flipped.
This strikes me as scummy, trying to put suspicion on confirmed town. Is your setup speculation possible? Yes. Likely? No, and definitely not to put ahead of hunting actual scum, which you are doing very little of.
↑ drmyshotgun wrote:Well, I'd say I put in great amount of effort coming up with an idea to lynch someone NO-ONE suspects.
Innocent Child-esque role in Large Theme Park games is kinda suspicious. I'm sure there's another side to this.
Yes, let's lynch confirmed town in a game run by an experienced mod and was not advertised as a bastard game. I maintain that no player is legitimately as stupid as shotgun is acting, and I think the mod should seriously consider force-replacing him because it is obvious he is not playing to win, no matter his alignment.
Nexus, is that the extent of your catchup? What is your opinion on BB and Shmugen?
~