Open 387: Jungle Republic (Day 6 - ends in a Town Victory)

[Chrimi]

#1000 post.

I'm sorry, I just couldn't... COULDN'T help it.

[BK201]

It was good, but his claim should've countered that by far.

And can we please switch it around? It won't change wether we win or lose.

Slaandar's posts were a huge reason I voted Om of the Nom. I mean even Om of the Nom's opening post where he posted reads was annihilated by Slaandar. Then he spat out good scum-hunting until is untimely death. I mean for day 1 that's pretty sick.

P-Edit:

As scum, I would never try and switch it around cause I'd still lose. I'd make up some bullshit why some people on Om's wagon are scum.

But you see, I am not scum, and I already know that I win this game. I'd just like to win a game ALIVE for once >.>

The only problem with that for me is that you're the most likely last scum.

[BK201]

#1000 post.

I'm sorry, I just couldn't... COULDN'T help it.

Noooooooooooooooooooo

[Chrimi]

Yeah I know, but if you lynch me after the other two you still win, right?

And it would be very nice of you

[BK201]

but if I'm correct, we have to lynch you in order to win no matter what. :p

[Chrimi]

No, you have to lynch thomith or Fat_Tony.

I'm going to guess thomith, though.

So go on, there is no night phase so we can just lynch lynch lynch and be over. Cookies if you do it my way!

[BK201]

I'm telling you guys right now Thomith is one of the least scummiest to lynch. Please read my previous posts everyone who is not scum :p
The only other person I would consider voting today would be Fat_Tony, but I think the evidence against Chrimi is pretty damning. Well I g2g for now!

[Chrimi]

VOTE: Fat_Tony

Fine, I'm down with Fat_Tony. If he's not scum, lynch me tomorrow. When you see I'm not scum, then you'll have to lynch Thomith the scum.

Simple as that.

[Chrimi]

But look at thomith: He could've hammered Om, but he decided not to vote anybody at all (Same as me, and because I'm town that makes him doing it sort of a townread)

Then Fat_tony: He votes me trying to get a wagon started on me and off of Om.

He stands out from the 3 of us. Might as well hit the mole that's sticking out the most, right?

[andrew94]

@BK, i would appreciate if you dont quote 10+ posts and then only have 2 sentences. I understand and agree with some of what your saying, but its really annoying
to read

for example at your post 973, when i was isoing asher, i realised that he really looks like seer, i may be biased cos i read after i got my role pm, but yea....

Also, i really like asher , feels like the points he points out would be what i would have pointed out at that time too.


@ Chrimi, really i find you and Thomith to be suspicious
It is easy for you to 'call it' since you know who you are, but i hate your 'i can wave it into your faces'


I know im keeping prob kassadin or BK (ignore what i said about pirate being scummy when i first reread)
for lylo, so the rest of you can die in whatever order

vote chrimi

I'll deny you! ;P

[Thomith]

actually chrimi, when om got hammered, i'm pretty sure i wasn't online, as i remember om being at L-2 or something when i left, and i was going to vote him when i get back.

out of fat/chrimi i prefer a chrimi vote, so

VOTE: chrimi

[Fat_Tony]

Picking up my prod.

So sorry guys, like I said, life stuff. I'll catch up and post properly this evening.

[Fat_Tony]

That is the most basic case ever.
Why else is Thomith scum?

Did a quick catchup and caught this little beauty.

Torn between Chrimi/Thomith for last scum, but 99% sure it's one of them.

Chrimi's reactions over the last page or so seem like frustrated townie, although the vote hopping seems a bit weird.

Phone posting so need to check out the vote count before I place a vote, don't want to accidentally speedlynch anyone!

I note that still nobody has made a case on me but my name is getting mentioned as scum a lot. I think Om was the first to bring me up as scum before his world went tits up, and he had zero case. I'm fine with you guys saying you think I'm scum, but I'd like the chance to defend myself, and I reckon that's a lot easier for me to do if you lay down your case.

I'm also ok with being the lynch today of it gives us info. We have 4 shots, wasting one on me, while suboptimal, wouldn't be the worst thing, it would give us a conf town and also shine a light on those pushing for my lunch with little reason. I reckon that BK is a townie and that Chrimi's opportunity to take the opportunities presented to him to deflect attention elsewhere when he gets the chance to do so, as any town lynch he can push helps, particularly if he didn't start the wagon.

So, in summary - would my accusers please state their case? Ta.

[Fat_Tony]

Ok, Chrimi looks town today, but only today, could be frustrated town but could be desperation. I don't want to hammer (because I'm pretty sure that it's L-1

{mod- vc?}

) straight away, but please take this as confirmation that I'm willing to do so.

BK - what makes me potential scum in your eyes? Please state your case. Also, why do you have a town read on Thomith? He seems to be everyone's number 2 suspect about now.

Finally, my reads from town down to scum:

1. Me (but only cos I've seen my role PM)
2. Andrew (because Asher was seer)
3. Kassadin (convinced he's just troll town. See conviction against Om)
4. BK (wouldn't be stunned if you were scum, you're trying to lead the game. Your posts look like scum hunting but are actually just quote walls with a line or two of basic logic. Could be a genuine hunting effort, could be a smokescreen)
5. Thomith (because a lot of your play throughout has felt off)
6. Chrimi (because damn.)

Honestly, if we lynch 6,5,4,1 there, it would seem we are bound to hit the scum before the game ends. I include myself last because if 6,5,4 are all misses, even I would think I was scum after that. Equally, if you want to lynch me first, go for it, but avenge me - the lynch order is Chrimi, Thomith, BK.

[andrew94]

yea im thinking Thomith next cos of that OM post

[Thomith]

or om was scum making it look like i was his buddy?

[andrew94]

So how come you didnt mention that when he was 'buddying' you

[Fat_Tony]

Question

@Mod - does Andrew know who Asher investigated D1?

Andrew, if you do know that, it might be of some use. Asher's reads have been good all game, so if he found someone suspicious it might be of use.

(It's going to end up being me, isn't it? )

EBWOP: Valid, Thomith. But explain the scummy looking play from every other day? Not saying you are scum, not saying that quote was proof, just something interesting that I noticed. Same as I noticed Chrimi going all out on Kassadin because he thought Kass may be an easy lynch yesterday, especially after Kass locked on to Om.

For the record, I was surprised Om flipped scum. Genuinely thought he was town.

[BK201]

BK - what makes me potential scum in your eyes? Please state your case. Also, why do you have a town read on Thomith? He seems to be everyone's number 2 suspect about now.

You're my number 2 because of PoE. Thomith was

heavily

opposed by OmNoms.

Finally, my reads from town down to scum:

1. Me (but only cos I've seen my role PM)
2. Andrew (because Asher was seer)
3. Kassadin (convinced he's just troll town. See conviction against Om)
4. BK (wouldn't be stunned if you were scum, you're trying to lead the game. Your posts look like scum hunting but are actually just quote walls with a line or two of basic logic. Could be a genuine hunting effort, could be a smokescreen)
5. Thomith (because a lot of your play throughout has felt off)
6. Chrimi (because damn.)

Just want to pat myself on the back for reading nearly 40 pages the same day I replaced in. I mini-quoted everything that I thought was important, and then just said what I thought. I quoted that stuff so I could look back on it, but also so you guys can see what main posts I am basing my reasoning off of. I'm not a fan of long-winded posts, and try to get right to the point.

[Thomith]

So how come you didnt mention that when he was 'buddying' you

because i didn't know what he was going to flip, and he could have been town "buddying" to me.

[Thomith]

also unless you explain my "scummy looking play" then i cant explain why it looked scummy.

[Ravel]

Question

@Mod - does Andrew know who Asher investigated D1?

I haven't publicly revealed who the Seer is (the only way I could do that in this game is if the Seer died or wins in the end), so I can't answer that.

[Ravel]

Day 5 Vote Count

Chrimi

L-1

(3): BK201, andrew94, Thomith
Fat_Tony (1): Chrimi

Not Voting (2): Fat_Tony, Kassadin

There are 6 players alive, which means it takes 4 votes to lynch.

Plurality lynch is active.

Whoever has the most votes by the deadline will get lynched.
Deadline in

(expired on 2012-05-19 20:36:00)

(May 19, 8:36 PM EDT)

As of Post #1021

[Fat_Tony]

Question

@Mod - does Andrew know who Asher investigated D1?

I haven't publicly revealed who the Seer is (the only way I could do that in this game is if the Seer died or wins in the end), so I can't answer that.

Of course, sorry.

[Fat_Tony]

also unless you explain my "scummy looking play" then i cant explain why it looked scummy.

This is true.

By the way, BK, heard of distancing? Your PoE has a flaw. But again, if you guys want me dead, go for t, it'll help town (sort of). Of course from my point of view I want anyone besides me or Andrew to die because that way town is guaranteed a win, so I'm having to assume Kass-town, based on distancing from Omscum, so my entire thought process is flawed.

I'm 99% sure either Chrimi or Thomith is scum. I feel pretty strongly that Kass is town and I'm leaning town on BK, but not sold.