NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[HezLucky]

But your defense of Mastin is noted.

[Psyche]

That's not the point. I'm trying to determine your alignment based on your tone to me in that one post.

That seems like a disingenuous explanation given that 1719 implies that you already found me scum before reading the post (which then corroborated said view).

Actually, I did.

Go look at my post with a lot of reads.

So you weren't trying to determine my alliance from just one post.

[Psyche]

My defense of mastin? Have I even typed his name today or even a pronoun referring to him?

[OhGodMyLife]

Also somebody tell me who actually made a case on Rack yesterday and who was just bandwagoning.

Anyone? Anyone? Bueller?

[Junpei]

nd hypothetically why do you think Mastin-scum would of felt the need to cut himself off from previous ties? Why bother?

It's a form of waffling and not having to worry about work he hasn't done. Basically it's the old "I haven't done any scumhunting, let me just start from the top and tell them that I am doing a second read when it's really my first".

pedit: OhGodMyLife why are you voting me.

[OhGodMyLife]

Solid town reads on benmage and lambda.

LLD's reaction to TML's goofy cop claim makes sense from town.

Scum don't just forget who got mislynched if they had something to do with it (and ben was on the wagon). Also, Junpei is really quick to try to talk people out of making that a town tell Which, again, is what scum do, because townies who recognize other townies are the scums' worst nightmare.

[drmyshotgun]

Hey y'all. I'm just reading day two for now, because the deadline is imminent. Just a few pages in and I'm immediately suspicious of everyone trying to discredit shotgun. Dude is town. Only scum want to un-confirm a confirmed town.

Vote: Junpei

Pine tried to disclaim me too and he even went as far as to place a vote on me.

[OhGodMyLife]

Junpei: Trying to un-confirm the obv confirmed shotgun. Throwing dirt on benmage's towntell. And being the L-2 vote for yesterday's mislynch, though granted I haven't read any of day one aside from the last votecount.

Also bandwagon, choo choo, all aboard.

[OhGodMyLife]

Pine tried to disclaim me too and he even went as far as to place a vote on me.

He did, but Junpei did it at least twice (that I recall) and I don't like lynching a player slot that's getting replaced, its too easy for scum to make excuses about saving the mod the trouble.

[Junpei]

Also, Junpei is really quick to try to talk people out of making that a town tell Which, again, is what scum do, because townies who recognize other townies are the scums' worst nightmare.

It's not a town tell, but whatever, this isn't what made you vote me. Why are you voting me.

pedit: Uh, how the hell is it possible to unconfirm someone who is obviously confirmed town? That makes no sense whatsoever. It wasn't a town tell and you need to be sat down if you think it is (I'll PM you a review of your play after the game if you like). L-2 is not inherently scummy and I find it funny that you think it is.

Stretch harder.

its too easy for scum to make excuses about saving the mod the trouble.

They only make that excuse if it is town... you know Pine to be town??

[Nero Cain]

Hey Mastin. Did anyone ask you for your reads? No? Then why are you giving them. Other than an attempt to try and look town I can't for the life of me understand the purpose behind your post (O LETS GIVE MORE INFORMATION TO THE MAFIAZ)

its pretty common for town to give reads, idk why you are upset over Mastin giving reads.

Also somebody tell me who actually made a case on Rack yesterday and who was just bandwagoning.

Anyone? Anyone? Bueller?

pretty much all the early votes. Benmage, The Mini-Librarian, Firestarter, Lady Lambdadelta, Maxous, GreyICE, FakeGod are the ones I remember being crap votes.

[Maxous]

nd hypothetically why do you think Mastin-scum would of felt the need to cut himself off from previous ties? Why bother?

It's a form of waffling and not having to worry about work he hasn't done. Basically it's the old "I haven't done any scumhunting, let me just start from the top and tell them that I am doing a second read when it's really my first".

He did'nt read the thread previously even though he wrote that 6 part wall of doom with his reads on the whole playerbase?

P-edit: Why was my vote crap exactly, nero?

[Nero Cain]

he was pretty obviously town.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

OhGodMyLife, Nero Cain is deluded. Most of the votes on the Rack wagon were deserved.

Do your own research.

[Maxous]

Was Nero's last post a reply to me?
If so, it makes no sense.

[Nero Cain]

OhGodMyLife, Nero Cain is deluded.

Most

of the votes on the Rack wagon were deserved.

Do your own research.

Which ones were?


LLD, your FakeGod read please.

[PeregrineV]

Vote Count 2-8

(as of Post 1740)

Pine (8)

- Maxous, scooby, Kublai Kahn, Benmage, The Mini-Librarian, drmyshotgun, Psyche, kdowns

Junpei (5)

- mastin2, HezLucky, Lady Lambdadelta, Nero Cain, OhGodMyLife,

mastin2 (2)

- Pine, Junpei

kdowns (2)

- Code_X, DeasVail

The Mini-Librarian (1)

- StrangerCoug

redFF (1)

- drmyshottyizsik

OhGodMyLife (1)

- redFF

Not Voting (3)

- FakeGod

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch

Deadline:

Monday, May 14, 2012 3pm CST

Replacing:

Pine

Prods:

drmyshottyizsik

V/LAs:

Mastin May ??

[Benmage]

Junpei: Trying to un-confirm the obv confirmed shotgun. Throwing dirt on benmage's towntell. And being the L-2 vote for yesterday's mislynch, though granted I haven't read any of day one aside from the last votecount.

Also bandwagon, choo choo, all aboard.

Liking OMGL.

Gonna need a new look at Junpei.

[StrangerCoug]

#1164 and #1170: I could have sworn mastin2 was in Mafia 91, which had two teams of four, under his original account. I'd have to double-check that game, though, and it was a 30-player game instead of a 24-player game anyway.

even if he was, why is this scummy?

That is not part of my case on mastin2. Yes, one of us has his facts wrong about other games, but that was a game from 2009 and it's possible neither one of us has a clear memory of the scum teams in that game.

That my sense of humor is shot is conceded, but joking around claiming you are a certain role in a Mafia game is like joking around claiming you have a bomb at an airport. You cannot do either without serious repercussions. I stand by my vote, no matter how unpopular.

So do you actually think he is scum or what?

Yes.

[HezLucky]

Junpei: Trying to un-confirm the obv confirmed shotgun. Throwing dirt on benmage's towntell. And being the L-2 vote for yesterday's mislynch, though granted I haven't read any of day one aside from the last votecount.

Also bandwagon, choo choo, all aboard.

Liking OMGL.

Gonna need a new look at Junpei.

Since when do you take looks at people? I'm not condoning your behaviour, but given what you've been doing all game I half-just expect you to vote him.

[Benmage]

A little free time if I got it to iso 1 player aint that much.

Me being swamped has been the largest detriment to this game. With free time and a little desire, I could 180 my actions.

[drmyshotgun]

ISO me.
Jokes

[Benmage]

Also I was previously reading Junpei town. So I would like a little more personal research if I'm just gonna 180 that read.

[DeasVail]

Maxous:

I don't feel that strongly about anybody.

Biggest scumreads probably are:

FakeGod
kdowns
Pine
Mastin2

[kdowns]

@Nero Cain, I don't really care about the votes on me because I always have votes casted against me, it isn't something new to me.